‘An Ode to the 80s’

Written by Ammar Junaid Asghar

 

The idea of the 80s having an aura of ‘simpler times when kids used to ride bicycles without a care in the world’ is an attractive proposition. It is modern enough to relate to and old enough to feel a certain degree of nostalgia towards it. Popular culture embracing the 80s by rehashing old movies as well as making new ones with similar themes is a defining feature today.  But it doesn’t come without its predicaments.

Now I love the 80s, I really do. San Junipero is Black Mirror’s best episode by a mile, and part of it is because of the entire 80s music and setting. Similarly, Stranger Things, IT and various other works of television really do shine when highlighting a simple yet effective idea; a fictionalized version of a childhood we all seem to have lived. And of course by referring to 80s classics like ET and Back to the Future, they are popular with the actual 80s kids as well.Image result for stranger things

The problem arises when these remakes try to fit in a narrative that is a product of the 21st century. When these remakes bring in African American characters in titular roles, LGBT characters and strong female characters, they ignore the reality of the 80s itself. They ignore that the 80s were deeply misogynist, homophobic and racist times. They ignore the police brutality of African Americans. They ignore the divisive policies of Reagan that systematically ghettoized blacks, Latinos and marginalized poor women. When television creates a highly romanticized version of the 80s and we accept it at face value, we must consider that these were not ‘Glory Days’ for a large number of individuals.

Furthermore, this nostalgic wave makes it impossible to create original works of fiction. Sure, there are great new movies coming out every year. But the vast majority of them either borrow heavily from times gone by, or explicitly remake them under the same name. Even the notoriously popular Joker is clearly an ode to Scorsese’s Taxi Driver. Now there is nothing wrong with being inspired by works of art. But when it comes at the cost of any contribution from modern day directors, Hollywood becomes more of a cash grabbing entity than ever before. There are exceptions of course, but as long as film executives know that they’ll garner ample audiences of teenagers seeking ‘vintage aesthetic’ and older parents craving nostalgia, they know that by churning out these movies, they’ll make more profit than by actually thinking of a plot and then executing it.

A similar obstacle exists in the music industry. Although not as apparent as Hollywood, the consistent rehashing of 80s tunes, rhythms and even the beats takes its toll. Artists ranging from the Jonas Brothers to mega pop star Taylor Swift’s entire album ‘1989’ incorporate a similar tangent; funky pop songs that are pure escapes from this dark depressing world.  There is however, one prominent exception. Spanish Pop whatever your take on it, is firmly established as a reliable way for artists to make bucks. The fact that they can get artists like Justin Bieber or Demi Lovato to sing a few words in Spanish and the crowd goes wild, is testimony to the fact that foreign music is gaining enough traction.

Should Hollywood stop with this 80s love affair and make unique revolutionary movies? Or should it stick to a tried and tested method, and hope for audiences to keep showing up? Either way the 80s are bustling and alive and there’s no stopping it!

Shaba Jt: The Unfortunate Reality Of All-Boys Schools

(Trigger warning for body shaming)

When you belong to an affluent Punjabi family that tends to invest everything for the wellbeing of their male child, your privilege reflects itself in nearly all aspects of your life. My parents’ decision to enroll me in arguably one the best schools in Lahore was a  culmination of tireless effort and financial investment equivalent to a  lifetime’s fortune. If one school did not fulfill their set academic benchmark, I was then made to transfer to some better institution.

But then came O-Level, when perhaps the uncertainty finally came to a halt!

I was finally admitted to Lahore Grammar School Johar Town (LGS JT or just JT for short) with the thought incorporated into my mind that this will be my abode for the next 5 years.

As a 13-year old pampered kid, I was unable to decipher the problematic and the toxic environment surrounding (almost every) all-boys school. For me (and my parents), these aspects perhaps had only a little impact on the decision. The academic excellence, prestige, and a purpose-built campus overweighed any other factor crucial for my mental wellbeing as a teenage student.

So, where did the problem lie?

Just about a few months back, an article in DAWN raised the issue of exploitation under the hands of private institutions mainly LGS, Beaconhouse and Aitchison. To study in either  of the three places (or any other private school for that matter) can cost almost as much as a kidney for the monthly fee. Include other miscellaneous expenses such as learning materials, mandatory school trips, and evening tuition services, and the cost begins to rise even further.

While the issue of financial exploitation may have gotten the necessary attention, not many people are aware of the othe problems prevalent in institutions like LGS JT that create a plethora of challenges for a student studying there.

When I now look back at my 5-year time spent at that school, probably at no point can I reminisce any fond memory I have of that place. What I will illustrate next can be relatable to a number of my fellow alumni, who will nod in agreement with me for their unpleasant times at JT.

Let me start with the deeply entrenched toxic masculine culture purposely ingrained within each JTite.

We were supposed to act in accordance with these values that were literally based upon dehumanizing women, trivializing the experiences of victims and breeding the toxic culture further within the student body.

The teacher-evaluation process provides a cohesive example in that regard.  One of the students back in my O-Level years, dared to make derogatory remarks about the body of a female instructor only out of personal grudge and dislike. In another similar unfortunate situation, a guy was reported to the administration for vandalizing the walls of the school with unspeakable words about the faculty members.

Step further ahead out of the vicinity of the school, and you will find these toxic traits exhibiting in other manifold ways. While the AC-JT rivalry is not news to most Lahoris, the enmity usually turned into a matter of “ego and pride” (long story short, let’s see who has a fragile male ego). The unnecessary rivalry came at the cost of expulsions/suspensions on both ends as well as physical injuries sustained during several out-of-school fights.

In case you haven’t guessed yet, these fights were most of the times over girls who were somehow a matter of ego between the boys. These ideas of ownership of the other gender carries forward as soon as these boys reach LUMS and equate getting a girlfriend with a trophy for social excellence.

If you were someone who even remotely doubted your sexuality, then LGS JT was never your safe space to be in. Exploration was out of the realm of possibilities because you were socially conditioned to abide by the cis-heteronormative values (boys will be boys). Your eagerness to dress nicely or even listen to Lana Del Rey was frowned upon and sought the disapproval of the JT community at large for being too “feminine.” When one student came out as a non-binary individual, they were ridiculed and otherized, forcing them to drop out of the A level program just one year prior to completion. The strong inculcation of homo/transphobic values only proved to legitimize bullying against anyone who stood in defiance against these principles. And when any relevant concern was brought up with the administration, the higher authority festered the grievances further as opposed to finding any meaningful solution(s).

To make the matters even worse, some would also refrain from filing a complaint in the first place out of sheer embarrassment and unexpected repercussions. In grade 9, when swimming constituted a mandatory slot in our weekly timetable, the idea of freeing myself from the crippling academic stress through twice-a-week dip in the pool soon came to an end as a result of body-shaming and that too under the hands of my swimming coach. The event left a tear in my heart that still hangs till this very day. For the first time in my life, I felt uncomfortable with my body forcing me to undergo a long period of starvation soon afterward. But never did that day arrive, when I would expect an apology from the swimming coach or the school administration.

 

While empirical evidence would certainly show JTites scoring more A’s than perhaps any other institution in Lahore, the physical and mental exhaustion behind the struggle never really gets the needed validation. Behind the hundreds of A’s in A level, there are stories of students who were subjected to physical and psychological abuse under the all-respected principal of the program. When an AS student tried justifying his underperformance in the Sessional Exams on the basis of his deteriorating mental health, the principal sidelined any of the legitimate concerns by saying, “Ab tum mujhe dobara dawaiyan khatay nazar na ho” (I shall not see you again having your prescription medicines). Additionally, being even a minute late to your class could earn you a literal slap from the principal in front of all your fellow peers and friends. The act embarrassing in all the many ways, often left students traumatized for the rest of their time at the school.

Lastly, let us not forget how a number of JTites, who are now part of universities like LUMS. have actively failed to give up most of the toxic traits they picked up from JT. As someone who assimilated within the “JT group” for the first part of the freshman year, the friendships continue to be defined by the nebulous “BRO-CODE.” Individuals who willingly (yet, unfortunately) manifest a connection with their high school batchmates do so based on conforming to the same problematic values I mentioned in this article. But possibly with added severe form of emotional manipulation and ghosting pitted against the group members as well as other non-JT Luminites.

As an alumnus of Lahore Grammar School Johar Town, I seek no pleasure in ever calling myself a JTITE. My dissociative relationship with that school would always be characterized in terms of my unpleasant experiences and unfond memories I have of that place. Perhaps, the urgent need of the hour is for other fellow alumni members to step up and call-out the toxicity that remains rampant in that institution. If no timely solution is sought, we will probably witness the degradation of our new generation under the hands of “one of the best schools in Pakistan.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Godspeed, PLUMS! A Farewell Note by the Vice President

Like you, I also feel a social pressure to write something cool, but for a moment, let’s be ourselves. Let’s bravely face our humble, real selves and leave our cool masks on the shelf. We, millennials, associate our identity with  plenty of artefacts; social media, pop culture, Netflix and the stories they tell. We know these distant, detached stories told to us; those that we can only see or hear through a device, but not touch or smell. We know less of our own selves and the immediate surroundings which can be seen, heard, touched, smelt and felt – realities that are more certain than the former. We all carry an urge to be “cosmopolitan middle class individuals through indulging in transnational consumerism of things, ideas, ideologies and cultures”. But imagine that internet or cable networks cease to exist today; then what are you? Who are we? How will we have conversations? The consequences will be horrendous: our Johnny self will become Jamshéd and will fall short of “pickup lines”.

“World will always look for unstable, impulsive, hormone-imbalanced youth to further its propaganda on one hand, and grumpy, old, arrogant lot on the other.”

Our identities depend on these distant stories so much that if they cease to exist, we would be nothing. This is our weakness. We have built the world around us, but there is nothing inside.

پڑھ پڑھ علم  ہزار کتاباں،  کدی اپنے آپ  نوں  پڑھیا  نئیں

جا جا وڑھدا اے مندر مسیتی، کدی من اپنے وچ وڑھیا نئیں

We must link the immediate with the distant. As our sense of reality is dislodged from our immediate surroundings, we are pushed to a conundrum of expectations that inculcate a façade of a “certain” future. But that “future” never happens. You’ll be asked to connect the dots, but the expectations will align them in a way that the line goes in a direction that the “expectors” wish. When we pursue life with a detached sense of reality, we deceive and lie to ourselves about the “is” through “ought”. The world disappoints us each time; and unlike our numb “reality”, these contradictions are felt bitterly through all our senses! As what is, exists independent of what we think is, and we do not run over the bus when we have our arms crossed, the bus still runs over us.

I’ve been believing in something so distant,
as  if  I  was human!

I’ve been denying this feeling of hopelessness,
in  me;  in  me!

So much in this world, ultimately, tends to move from instability to stability. Perhaps that explains our need for certainty and meaning. But to reach the highest level of certainty, we need to conjoin all our senses to know, than relying on only seeing and hearing through devices. We are only exposed to the ‘distant’; detached from the ‘immediate’. We are an unstable generation plagued with a weaker sense of certainty than our ancestors. Perhaps this is the “instability” that reflects as mental illnesses, among other reasons?

I have built this as a foundation to encourage you towards “originality”, and “being yourself” in your creative projects, which you must understand in terms of eliminating the problem I have  put  forth.  We  are  a society, a community that has a common goal: writing. All our departments work together to produce this end, learning manifold skills in the process. As I see a promising future of this newspaper, it is imperative  that we preclude this ‘millennial problem’ of detached reality, disconnected from our immediate surroundings, in our writings. Let’s link the distant to the immediate. Right now, for instance, we are students at a university. What being a “student at LUMS” means, is for us to define; not just the administration or faculty; not Google; not Instagram, not JSTOR and certainly not Netflix.

کوئ  دور  رہ  کے  قریب  ہے

کوئ قریب رہ کے بھی دور ہے

Should we be “critical”? A popular concern found in the students’ culture these days, is of “thinking out of the box”. What we don’t realise is that when we go out of the box, we jump into another box and stay there. Should we, then, keep jumping through the boxes persistently to facilitate inquiry? I never really understood that. If you wish to “deconstruct”, you find yourself in Jacques Derrida’s box—you may choose to stay there, perhaps because it’s a “French” box.  But following the earlier logic, no matter how much we jump, we are tempted to make a box around us; of certainty; of stability; and stay there even when it starts corrupting with contradictions. And do you see, we have the audacity to see this world in a “horse shoe”? If we realise our surprising abilities, no horse shoe will be able to theorise us.

If we believe that there are no absolute right or wrong – or no “box” – we will still be tempted to generalize our personal right and wrong to the world. Maintaining a façade of acceptance of others’ values counts to nothing if, by practice, we still move towards the absolute in many respects. Just because we say or believe that we are not, does not change the practical reality and its consequences. Isn’t that we are tolerant in being, tolerant in sayings, but intolerant in doings? Though we have grown apparently elastic in it, we still compete to be the demagogue.

As this society is relieved from resource dependencies, you will witness this newspaper leaning towards such direction, which will be an existential threat. I already see certain factions running after it like wild hounds. There is apparently a consensus among the academics that being completely value neutral is impossible. For a person, I find it true to a vast extent, but not for the institutions. For a newspaper that hosts a constellation of persons, using this consensus to justify propaganda is precarious; it can compromise free speech, result in compelled speech and a lack of diversity. You will see dominance of one narrative and exclusion of others. The contrarians will be discouraged to write or enter the society altogether. The newspaper will attract a label and facilitate cult formations on either sides, which is a catastrophe. We don’t want to see an “Intellectual Dark Web”, do we? Cults are, by definition, exclusive; when you make one cult, four more cults will be formed around you. Would you wish such a campus?

I declare this society open for all kinds of students—Northerners and Southerners alike, brand schoolers and non-brand schoolers alike—if they can think originally and be themselves. For how long can we hide behind an arbitrary grandiose of city, or a brand name of a social engineering factory? We are someone else too, without association to these jewels; someone more than a market niche. We must not be eager to replicate the tyranny of the world inside the campus. The world outside is, but a huge ego-sizing contest. In reality, their ego is the same; it is the gazing of the shadows that misguides them. Thus, those who are farther from the light, see  bigger shadows of their egos, and those who are closer, know their place and that of humanity very well. I encourage you to be the latter, and not the former.

The media in the world too, is accused of showing a distorted reality to facilitate narratives. They have to, but we dont. As I depart, I recommend the Editorial Board of PLUMS to maintain as much value neutrality in the editorial policies as it is possible, and to avoid implicit and explicit association with any ideology or narrative that must govern all writers. As I stated earlier, we will be tempted to turn populist, towards any side of the spectrum. But the highest level of maturity is when we strictly observe that what we are tempted to do is not always what we should do. Though it generally happens in the world outside, it is not best for us students. We are here to learn acceptance of differences, not activism and propaganda; the former is harder to learn; the latter is, or soon will be, instilled in us by the logic of the world anyway; as we let it.

Another reason why I deplore propaganda through the newspaper and its unapologetic affiliation with a narrative is to keep us students from being used. We get used by the things we don’t know how to use. We don’t control the narratives that we are a mouthpiece of, someone else does; who doesn’t love us as much as we begin to. How does religious fundamentalism use us, tapping into our beliefs, which they don’t themselves respect? How does right capitalism use us, taking advantage of our greed, avarice and vanity; feeding us theories of individual agents, then treating us as collective? And how does neo-Marxism and postmodernism use us, capitalizing on the “millennial weaknesses” these days? Karl Marx or Karl Mask? Taking a moral high-ground in the comfort of the blanket about the complicated world (immediate reality) that we never interacted with! Have we read a book called the world? What we say, remains in our throat, as we say so to be sublime characters, online or otherwise. It was all a meaningless hashtagging and posting, until they said it can change the world, and we adopted it impulsively to get meaning, stability and certainty in what we were habitual of doing meaninglessly. Can it really change the world? We were never critical of its premises, as what the world is and which direction of “change” it must follow, are not questions devoid of narratives, shortcomings and interests. The list above is not exhaustive or literal, be imaginative! We are in a world of defenseless lawyers and diseased doctors. All in all, we are not the end for them all, but a means to an end unknown to us.

Some cover their propaganda under cunning “rationality”, others facilitate demagoguery by a façade of compassion and piety. Serving humanity in saying, could be feeding our vanity in doing. They are a “public consent” away from a vulgar dictatorship that they had been hiding all along. Seemingly benign, inherently sinister!

Faking compassion for politics, rather; harms the very regime of it, by making the public skeptical of its discourse whenever it is signaled—failing to distinguish the fake from the genuine. Let the postmodernists disagree.

ہے علم جسے ہو حاجتِ  اندازِ بیان، محض رعب
پاک علم ہو گرچہ سادہ، کرے شعلہ بیان زدوکوب

Yet another choice is edginess, but that too is meaninglessly endless. You get edgy, edgier, edgiest and then what? You “walk over the edge”?

Though I am a big fan of feminists, as they say “men are trash”, I rather contend; why are they so lenient? How about the whole world is trash? Why is there a food-chain? We complain about the game theory, but why are the
resources scarce? Isn’t water running out, in our immediate reality? What will we do? If the world is this trash, does that imply we must adjust and be trashy ourselves? Or that we must manage to make it less trashy? How do we do it? Resource allocation? Modernization? Eliminating grand narratives? Revivalism? Hedonism? World abnegation? Self-purification? Which is the best answer? No one is sure. Façade of certainty! We are all internally scared and insecure; and we hide this behind the veil of vanity. Some get to shout and hurl through a pedestal; others get to sit with a European leg-cross at an NGO’s event. Their sayings are not doings, and doings are not what they speak of; their thinkings are not feelings, and feelings are not for what they think; their beings are not what they are, and what they are, they don’t want to be! They are distant, and all alike. They will bring us nothing, but make us become like them. You’ll be swimming through life somewhere, but your heart will float elsewhere; the heaviest of its pieces will be drowned, others will go here and there.

حق نوں آکھ کہ ہک کرے

ترا    ٹوٹا    پھوٹا     دل 

But the world will always look for unstable, impulsive, hormone-imbalanced youth to further its propaganda on one hand, and grumpy, old, arrogant lot on the other. We must spare ourselves from this game, at least as long as we are in the university or in the learning stage – or in a hormonal imbalance, for that matter.

Growing up is not a choice, but a necessity, for if we act like a pre-pubescent kid, the world will treat us like one; that treatment will less resemble that of our parents and more so of pedophiles. We would never know when, where and how were we ripped off.

Yet I’m militantly against pessimism, though I know that my words reek of it. But it only reeks to those who have learned to be governed by it; I have conjured all optimism in my Urdu poetry; those who cannot read it, missed out on it.

ٹھانی تھی دل میں اس نے اک آرزوۓ عروج

کہ  کردار   باکمال   ہو ،  شجاع   خوب  خوب

کروں  میں کچھ ایسا  کہ عالم حیراں   ہوجاۓ

ٹالوں  میں  وہ  بلا،   کسے  ٹالی  نہیں  کبھو

ملے  اسے    جلال  و  اضطراب  و  استطاع

مگر    بلا   نہ   آئ ،   بلا    ٹالتا    وہ   کیا

جب  کام  ہی  نہ  تھا    تو  کامیاب   کیا  ہوتا

نہ  تھا کوئ  فرعون  تو  موسیٰ وہ  کیا  ہوتا

جانا، کہ   مصیبت  بھی   ہے  اک نعمت  خدا

مانا،  کہ  اہم ہیں   یہ  فتن ، فِسق  اور زبوں

نہیں  ہے  دنیاۓ عفریت و عزازیل بلا  مقصد

دجال   نہ    فضول،   نہ   یاجوج  وَ ماجوج

The only acceptable activism is one that originates from yourself; from your immediate reality, that is: you are a student at a university—which is just one shallow instance. What concerns do you face being a student? Ask yourself! Would you not speak of non-profits shifting from social service provision to a mere donation collection; from “altruism” to “greed”? Do you see your peers implicitly excluding NOP scholars and then rant on LDF about mutual acceptance? Do you  recognize imposters amongst you, who talk of feminism, tolerance and piety, but do the opposite? But first sweap your own house, as the most immediate is, yourself. For us, it is less terrible, as this is our age of making mistakes; though it’s over for those who sit in offices. It is when you are aware of the immediate reality first, you are good to talk about the distant matters, while maintaining a link. And for that, you do not need to follow an ideology or a school of thought. No PhD knows more than you, what being a student at this university today feels like. You own this domain. You have the right and legitimacy to speak out through the platforms that PLUMS provides. Lastly, be critical, but not in the manner described earlier.

Words never erupt out of a newspaper to grab anyone’s collars. I have no right to obligate you to listen, nor have you, to constrain me to explain. As through this, I do not seek the limelight; I never wanted to be noticed. But I humbly put these words out, so the consequences that are not consistent with them, are off my shoulders. Mera Ranjhan hun Koi Hor!

If Harvard Crimson can last more than a century, this newspaper can last as long as LUMS itself, and it will (IA). With this hope, I bid farewell, both, as the Vice President of PLUMS (EC’19) and as a student at LUMS. Khuda Hafiz!

 

 

 

Sonder and Mokita: In conversation with Haider Ilahi

“The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge”- Stephen Hawking

There is something to be said about a person who draws knowledge from the world, the people and the events surrounding him, the good and the bad; and turning it into a symphony of words that speaks to the soul. Like a tree with its roots firmly in the ground with the world spinning quickly by, as years turning into aeons; people into a kaleidoscope of colours whirling into a spectacular illustration; time burdening it with its age-old secret and the dawning truth ageing it further every day.

There is nothing more radical than to learn, unlearn and relearn oneself from the knowledge that one is provided with and it was by chance that I stumbled upon somebody quite similar to that. From the batch of 2019, Mr Haider Ilahi tells us about what he learnt so far from his experience as a member of the LUMS community and how it shaped him as a person.

Sleepless due to reading Songs of Blood and Sword the whole night, downing a cup of coffee and making our way towards Khoka in the chilly November morning, I and my two friends went to meet Mr.Ilahi as he greeted us with a polite smile.

We started off by asking him about his routine.

Q: How do you usually spend your day?

 A: Previously, I would sleep and wake up very late. I wanted to adjust my routine since it was messing my day up. Directing my biological clock to wake up at 6 am, I started rising to a clean, empty and quiet campus giving me a clear head to think. I have my breakfast and then do my readings outside with the music always playing in the background. Then my friends begin to wake up and I start wasting time (smiles!). By the end of the day, I go to bed early usually around 10 or 11 pm and even though it’s really hard, I still try to maintain this routine.

Q: What kind of literature do you like?

A: I used to read a lot of fiction but I am lucky in the respect that I really like the courses that I take. So, primarily, having just started my senior year, this is the first semester that I am really involved with my course packs. Usually, it would be me opening my books only during a mid or a final, but now it’s constant. So, whenever I am free and have to read something, I’ll do a reading of the course that legitimately interests me like philosophy or sociology. When I do have the time, I try to find novels and books suggested by friends. But I hardly have the time right now, so it seems to be just course packs.

Q: What about your childhood book-preferences?

A: It would be novels, crime stories, and detective stories. Even now, some of the favourite books that I go back to are fiction; which I used to read when I was really young. So, uh, it wouldn’t be surprising that I go back to those Famous Five books (we all laugh) that usually send me back to my childhood. But other than that, philosophy would be my preferred genre.

Q: What made you decide upon your current major?

A: I had an understanding that I would do Political Sciences but my father wanted me to have an open mind about choosing another major if it appealed to me. He personally wanted me to take Economics but, ultimately, he left the choice on me saying that I should analyze my penchant as well as my strengths and weaknesses. When I came as a freshman, I took a month or two to contemplate and then decided on doing Pol Sci and stuck with it. Despite that, even though I am a Pol major and its requirements aren’t very stringent, I promised myself that I’ll take up courses from other disciplines as well except for SDSB, which I had to take eventually as an out-group (the word ‘unfortunately’ was left unsaid). This really broadened my perspective as a whole.

Q: Apart from studying, what hobbies do you indulge in like sports etc?

A: I used to play a lot of football before I came to LUMS. For some personal reasons, I gave that up. It was hard because at that point football was the only thing I was really passionate about. So when I gave it up, I had to sort of find a replacement for it; something to keep me active in a way. Then by the end of my sophomore year and the beginning of my junior year, I found that spark in a specific branch of academics. Met with a couple of teachers who really inspired me to align my goals and ambitions. So if I had to choose now in retrospect, I’ll always choose this over football as it is something much more fulfilling and gratifying.

Since he mentioned music previously,

Q: What about your taste in music and did it develop over time?

A: Yeah, it did develop over time. If I had to go and pick one genre, it would be Blues. I have discovered some of the most incredible blues artists from the 60s and even early 30s. Other than that, since it’s in my blood probably, I have recently started to get really deep into Sufi qawwalis since almost all qawwalis do use spiritual and Sufi takes. As my Punjabi isn’t really good, I have sort of become a student of that. So, 50% it’s qawwali and 50% it’s blues.

Q: What are your thoughts on Iqbal since you mentioned that you respect his philosophy?

A: Well, I can’t talk about Iqbal without talking about society because even my own opinion is formed partly due to society. So when I was growing up, I understood Iqbal as how he was taught: “Qoumi Shayar hain” and “Unko Pakistan ka khwaab aya tha”; that’s all very nice and cute but in my junior year I heard about a course being offered called ‘Philosophy and Poetry of Iqbal’. This course was being taught by the only person I call my teacher, Sir Koshul. Since it required the consent of the instructor, the professor took my interview. I remember when he asked me why I wanted to take this course up, my reply was that one of the things my father used to talk about was my generation; that the most unfortunate aspect of our generation is that we haven’t studied Iqbal well and even if we have, we didn’t try to understand him. That really stuck with me. At that time I was trying to study Kant and Nietzsche on my own and, although it was fun, there was a thirst and a void inside me as if I was missing something. So, ultimately, I stumbled upon Iqbal and truth be told, that course changed my life. It was primarily the philosophy of Iqbal but the poetry of it cannot be separated as they complement each other.

Q: Why did Iqbal impact you so?

A: This course and Iqbal’s ‘Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam’, it struck me really deeply and my whole life was turned upside down.  Those questions that plagued my mind, Iqbal answered them.  Culturally specific and contextual, Iqbal is not just for Muslims only. He is beyond that; he is universal. Iqbal understood the fact that the need of the current day and age, and I hate using this word since it has an extensive debate behind it, is for us to reconcile things ‘rationally’. For instance, and I speak personally, growing up in a Sunni Muslim not-so-extremist family I would have questions about my religion and somewhat related aspects.  When I would look for the answers, religion would always say this is where you take a leap of faith.  Kind of like religious schooling in subtext. Whilst from my school to my university, the exact opposite coaching’s been done: to perceive everything rationally and build reasonable, sound arguments so it could all make sense. So you can imagine the conflict inside me and I notice this about a lot of people in my generation as well. The disparity has expanded so much that both of our domains do not even see eye to eye most of the time. It has thus created a perception-gap throughout because we have failed to understand the needs of our time. And Iqbal talks about this in the preface that the need of the time requires a method that is physiologically sound and mentally adequate or something along these lines. That is why Iqbal is so exceptional and made so much sense to me. Where religion told me to take a leap of faith and I couldn’t uncover any empirical or sort of logical reason for that, Iqbal resolved my conflict through his philosophy and I started seeing patterns in things as my observational sense got acute. I feel like he is truly misunderstood whenever I have this conversation, even with my friends. I apologize if this is getting lengthy (we didn’t mind at all), but Iqbal is a teacher of mine and I think everyone could learn from Iqbal regardless of what their personal inclinations are towards everything. Religion, faith, science, whatever belief you hold; I think if you respect the text and go to it as a student, you’ll take a lot from it in the end.

Q: How did these texts change your perception?

A: For that, I’ll talk about the point where I started to understand things or rather, I thought I started to understand things and that came from the fact that if I had a text in front of me, whether it be of Allama’s or any other’s, I had to treat it with respect. More than knowledge, it is the self-discipline that is necessary to understand something. My favourite movie of all time ‘Good Will Hunting’ has this powerful scene between Will and his therapist Sean where the therapist says: “You think I know the first thing about how hard your life has been, how you feel, who you are because I read Oliver Twist? Does that encapsulate you?” So whatever surface idea you garner, that’s probably the worst interpretation you can attain from a text. The text Sir Koshal is teaching us, he is still working on it and even now he goes back to his very beginnings. And it’s only due to self-discipline that you start forming your own conclusions which are very sound, probably by not endorsing anyone else’s opinion. When we come to the Quran, the stipulation in which the country is right now is most likely because people have reduced the text. They have reduced God. Had they grappled with the text, had they had the self-discipline; this country wouldn’t be suffering from the current repercussions. Not saying that I have that sort of self-discipline and this is perhaps the reason I haven’t picked up Quran’s translation till now. The other end of the spectrum is that you start understanding it and you begin discovering things that are fascinatingly tangible for your inner world. Then yes, your life changes, your company changes, your friends change and your relationship with the world changes. It’s because your understanding of the world has changed and if it is worth something, you will definitely change.

Q: You talked about having some questions growing up. What were those?

A: There were a lot of questions that plagued me. I’ll talk about three of the most primary ones here. One of them was the biggest contradiction that I and most people find in religion: predestination and free will. If everything is pre-decided by God then where is this supposed free will? It bothered me a lot not being able to comprehend why I can’t understand my religious conviction. The second thing that troubled me was the nature of time. There are a lot of ways to understand time but how I perceived it was through observation. The earliest memory I have is of my mother picking me up as she prepared breakfast for me and my siblings when I was very little. Now, it’s the same mother and it’s the same Haider but when I am climbing stairs with my mum, she asks for my hand to help her ascend. This is how I understand time: seeing parents age, seeing myself grow and watching myself as I change. Thirdly, I started questioning death. I have seen death very closely and well everyone is subject to it; this developed a curiosity inside me to discern the nature of death in its truest form. So, these were the queries that I had growing up and the most intriguing thing is that many philosophers have presented these questions with answers of their own but none of them really stuck with me. That’s where Sir Basit Koshul came into the picture; he taught me about 150-200 pages of Iqbal thoroughly and that sort of lead to a mental progression for myself.

Q: The way you perceive different aspects of your life probably vary from that of your peers. Did you ever feel the need to make them understand your point of view?

A: The beauty of life is that every person lives his life in a unique way. Again Allama when he talks about human ego, call it a soul, a spirit or whatever, he says that every individual is a unique ego and everybody is looking at life with a different intellect. Doesn’t mean that somebody’s way of perceiving it is better than any other’s or only one way is the True way. These are just general rules for surviving on this Earth; a necessity if you may. It’s essential even to look at things in your own way and be respectful of how others are looking at them and then exchange ideas among yourselves. So when I am with my friends, this is the only sort of conversation that I have. Better to understand another than to gossip about someone else. Be respectful, be kind and you will start to realize that even though you might be looking at things through a different lens, you will be able to see the beauty in it. It’s really exciting if you and your friend perceive the same thing completely differently. And nothing is more beautiful than when this difference allows you to achieve the essence of that very thing.

Q: Did it change your perception of the institute that we study in?

A: I don’t want to scare you guys but I am sure that you all must have heard a lot when you first started studying here like there is freedom of inquiry, free objectivity and well the very best of education you could get in the entire country. After three and a half years, I would say it’s been probably the exact opposite. Because if LUMS is claiming this, then there sure are some conflicts within this claim. And for that, I will have to talk about rationality, something I am very cautious to talk about since we have understood it in a very restricted way. Weber gives four modes of rationality: theoretical (computative and analytical), formal (cause and benefits), practical (actions and reactions) and value (judgment mostly). What the university does and what science and each of its discipline do is endorse only formal rationality. This is the only form of rationality that they accentuate and consider to be ‘true’. According to them, the other three modes never existed. This approach is nothing but similar to a donkey whose eyes are blindfolded and is told to tread the path (this cracked me up since it was primarily apt).

“Never reduce your texts, your approach or your vision.”

And make no mistake about it; religion does the exact same thing with value rationality. So you need to reconcile the conflicts within by broadening your spectrum as these assertions make you question your courses, your chosen discipline, your degree and even the very claims that lead you to spend giant amounts of money in these four years. It is my right as well as my duty to question what this has given me in the long run. The point is that there is always more to a picture than someone would tell you. The university is, in my opinion, swindling you. That is why you need to be critical in your approach and question things. But they never address these issues because if they did, they are most likely screwed.

Q: How can we overcome such dishonest ways in your opinion?

A: Primarily by starting talking about it as it can’t go on forever. This has to change. So, talk about it and hopefully, someone with courage will stand up against it. This is all about progression. You play your part and hope that the next person plays their part for there will always be a next person. There shouldn’t be any despondency regarding this. Just keep playing your part and imparting something from it onto someone else so they can make their own choice by looking at the evidence and thus furthering the process. The change is sure to transpire. One thing I would say is that there is too much deception in this world; a lot of mirrors around creating an illusion of reality. So travel, it cleanses your mind. Take some time to yourself; take a step back to sort of escape that tornado of life. Breathe. Think. Analyze what is happening around you and to you. This is very necessary and I am kind of becoming an extremist in this (chuckles). This is how I start and end my day and I wouldn’t want it any other way since it is innately very enjoyable. If it’s chaotic inside, it will be chaotic outside and if it’s peaceful inside then it will be peaceful outside. Write if you need to. Because writing has given me a channel to express my inner-self through words and resolve the inner workings of my mind which, to be honest, has been a lot of help in bettering my life.

Quoting one of his favourite verses of Iqbal;

نوا پیرا ہو اے بُلبل کہ ہو تیرے ترنّم سے
کبوتر کے تنِ نازک میں شاہیں کا جگر پیدا

To Karachi, with Love

I often wonder, can you fall in love with a city the way you fall in love with a person? Because I think I have. Exploring a city’s lanes and secluded corners, like you would of a lover as you would lay with them, on sunny afternoons, etching new words upon their skin with your fingers. You would stare your lover, noticing all their quirks and building fantasies around them. Imaging the winters and the summers, and the autumns, while lying down next to them upon the grass during spring. You would talk to it, like you tell all your secrets to your lover and designate a few hours just to them, as if they belong to no one except you. You feel an inexplicable safety in knowing that this is the only city that would hold you and your secrets safe in its soul and would never reveal them to anyone, thus forging a bond that could never be breached by anyone else no matter what.

I struggle every time I plan to write about Karachi. It is so oxymoronic, so juxtaposing; like it infuriates and amazes at the same time. It continues to blow my mind with its mesmerising sights. I cannot help but stand on different vantage points and just continue gracing my eyes with its architectural excellence realizing how this structure along with the others around, have seen several instances of love, hate, naivety, success and failure between people of all ages. Its streets always lead me to a world crazier than the one I have come from, and one can never know what adventure awaits them in the moments to come. You just carelessly walk along the streets knowing that there is a world stranger than the one outside it – a world where anything can happen and that anything has the capacity of increasing the value of your life exponentially.

Out of all the metaphors I could use on you, I choose a tortured one. I want to call you a neglected mother, who openheartedly welcomes her children regardless of who they are as people or what they do. Every day you have millions of people coming in to you, learning how to survive and getting a bit closer to their dreams while growing up a little in the process. Some mover further away, some choose to stay, but you stand where you are – welcoming everyone with open arms even though the space keeps getting smaller and your buses may accommodate three passengers per seat. Karachi, I hate to admit but you are on the verge of dying, but there is value in your dying breath. The recording of each breath is worthy and hopeful and not opportunistic at all. I surely know that you will rise against all your challenges and will dance to the beat of your own drum because that is how it has always been, mad and crazy. And for someone like me, yours is the only understandable madness. The only chaos I can love unfathomably.

The history and significance of New Year festival

Contrary to popular belief, New Year’s wasn’t always celebrated on January 1st. Historically, it had been celebrated at many different times. The Egyptians, Phoenicians, and Persians began their new year with the fall equinox, and the Greeks celebrated it on the winter solstice while the Mesopotamians had been celebrating it on March 1st for centuries before that. The custom of celebrating the new year began in 45 B.C when Julius Caesar created the Julian calendar, moving the first day of the year from March 1st to January 1st. The practice fell out of custom in the Middle Ages as it was decreed as “unchristian” due to its supposed ties with paganism. It was then celebrated on 25 December instead. However, it was resurrected when the Gregorian calendar was implemented in 1982 and the date was given significance as ‘the day of circumcision’ following the Jewish tradition of circumcision and naming a child 8 days after its birth. Since then, New Year’s Day has been celebrated around the world and has recently gained considerable popularity in Pakistan too.

Festivities usually include gathering your loved ones and toasting to the upcoming year. A distinct feature of the event is fireworks and general fanfare to welcome the new year. The customs on New Year’s Day vary from country to country. A particularly significant event is of course the ball drop in New York City, which is a long standing tradition and seems to grow in its magnificence every year. In Greece, it is customary to turn off the lights at midnight and eat basil pie. This strange tradition does have a purpose – there is a hidden coin in the pie and whoever finds it is said to have good luck for the rest of the year! And the Greek aren’t the only ones with a strange custom. The Spanish eat 12 grapes at midnight to symbolise 12 months of fertility, and the Canadians and the Scandinavians, despite the extreme cold, plunge themselves in cold water!

These many many customs aren’t the only thing New Year’s has carried with it, it is accompanied by a long standing debate on whether or not the celebration has any use to society at all.

From a Marxist perspective, the festival is utter capitalist ploy. For Marx, mankind has been ruled by ‘historical materialism’, where every phase of civilized society had the fundamental characteristic of class inequality. The poor serfs or labour were made to work long and hard while the landowners and factory owners got the profit. For Marx, history can easily be viewed as an effort of the bourgeoisie to subdue the proletariat and control the means of production. He had predicted that one day the workers would realise this, gain class consciousness, and hence work to overthrow the capitalist structures. Clearly, this hasn’t happened till now. To explain this, neo-Marxists like Althusser devised the Ideological State Apparatus theory. This explains how media, religion and the state all propagate the capitalist ideology so that class consciousness is impossible to achieve. Our consumerist culture is of course a direct result of their efforts. Simply put, we now express ourselves in objects, constructing our identity around what we own and what we can afford. We express love by buying presents and anger by taking away items. We are addicted to buying more and more in order to fulfill the void that capitalism has created. Gradually, we are isolated from our peers because we are so consumed in our self preservation and reach the stage where everything without a price tag is meaningless. We are taught to work hard and continue working until we are able to afford all the luxuries that are flaunted in front of us all day, everyday. From this perspective, New Year’s Day is just another cog in the system. Nowadays, all festivals seem like nothing but capitalist constructs to get us to spend more and more, on food entertainment and gifts, than we did at the last occasion. Taking just one example, the whole month of December is laden with sales and advertisements to get us to spend our savings and end-of-year bonuses on lavish new year parties and dresses. On a psychological level, the significance of New Year’s eve comes from the way it delivers a sense of hope to the masses. The new year seems like an opportunity to bring change to one’s lifestyle, and for some, a chance to start over from scratch – a clean slate! For Marxists, this is merely a clever illusion to give people a false sense of control in their life. Organise your life with new drawers, buy new clothes to revamp your look for the new year, throw away old belongings to declutter your new life and the list goes on. They build a facade of control in our life, and very subtly shift the focus away from the people who are actually in control. We then believe we are the reason for our poverty or lack of success and not the sheer inequality of the capitalist society.

On the other hand, functionalists believe that everything in the status quo has a function. Durkheim founded the theory on ‘value consensus’ of a society. He believes that in order for society to function seamlessly, everyone must agree on the norms and values of the society. Once that has been established, every action of its members is to preserve and pass on those norms. For Parson, a society needs 4 things to function: an ability to adapt to the everyday challenges and changes of time, a collective goal, a mechanism to pass on values and a system to integrate its members. From this perspective, New Year’s eve has a distinct purpose. Festivals can be events to reinforce the collective identity and value consensus of a society. New Year’s showcases the culture and customs of a society, thus integrating its members and also passing them to the new generation. The Spanish custom of eating grapes or the American one of watching the ball drop all serve the same function. It is a moment for people to come together and celebrate their coexistence in harmony. The occasion celebrates life and our connection with one another. We feel connected not only to our society but to the rest of the world as well as we all step back and watch the countdown to a new year. In that moment we are reminded that we are all.

The history of new years is steeped in tradition and custom that is impossible to disregard. Even if it is just another holiday hijacked by the capitalist propaganda, it’s importance cannot be ignored.  It is up to us how we choose to spend the day and what significance we are willing to give it. Perhaps the real legacy of new years is its ability to make us reflect on our actions and give us hope for the coming year.

 

Removing the Taboo One Conversation at a Time

The sunlight dances its way into the room through the huge windows as soft music plays in the background, yet the atmosphere inside remains tense. A young woman clad in a burqa sits on a sofa, clearly distressed. I cannot see her face, but her eyes water up as if in pain. Her voice falters as she proclaims, “Zindagi buri lagti hai…khatam karnay ka dil karta hai” (Life itself seems to be horrible, I sometimes want to end it). Across from her sits Dr. Fareed Aslam Minhas.

Dr. Minhas is a psychiatrist- perhaps one amongst a limited number in Pakistan. As he welcomes me into his clinic during the afternoon on a Monday, I get a quick look into what is my first ever visit to a psychiatrist in Pakistan. The office itself seems to defy my expectations of the typical whitewashed doctor’s office filled with the distinct smell of medicines and blood veiled by antiseptics. One side looks into the garden outside with big windows stretching up to the ceiling. A watercolor painting of a cat faces one of the many comfortable seats lying around. An armchair sits in one corner, behind it the wall is covered by huge wooden cabinets that hold papers and books.  The doctor himself sits in the center, in a swivel chair that he moves around in as patients come and go. He is impeccably dressed in a black suit, a bright pink tie loosely fastened around the collar.

“I think I was in my third year of medical school when I learnt about a woman who was operated on twice- yet it was later discovered that her ailment was mental and not physical. It was then that I realized how psychological and social factors in illness are neglected in our country.”, says the doctor, as he explains his choice of profession to me. Born in Rawalpindi to a large family with 6 siblings above him, Dr. Minhas breaks into a smile as he tells me he had eight parents to supervise him growing up. He moved on to do his MBBS from Rawalpindi Medical College, where he specialized in Psychiatry. It has been a long road since then, and 30 years into his practice he tells me that psychiatric disorders are not only misunderstood by the community, but also by the medical profession in Pakistan.

“Either there are physical problems or there are medical problems, but people by and large tend to disregard mental illnesses due to the belief systems our population has”, he tells me, taking off his thinly framed glasses. Dr. Minhas has throughout his successful career, tried to raise awareness about mental illnesses. Having remained the head of the Institute of psychiatry at Rawalpindi Medical College and the Head of the Department of Psychiatry at Benazir Bhutto Hospital, he has overlooked various projects that work on removing the taboo from mental illnesses in Pakistan, while improving the facilities available to both psychiatrists and patients. It has not been an easy journey.

“You do get problems from time to time. There are certain people who find it difficult to leave treatments, and that is when sad incidents take place. I’ve been hit by my patients several times; my colleagues have faced the same. The people we are dealing with don’t understand what is right and wrong- they lose that sanity, that control over their behavior and actions”, he says.

As patients walk in, the doctor gets up to greet them, remembering their names with ease and greeting them in different ways. He disarms them with his warm smile, making the occasional joke and letting them rant about their problems. As a couple walk in, the woman complains about her husband to the doctor, who responds by jovially remarking “Wo shohar hi kya jo tang na karay” (What sort of a husband is he who doesn’t bother his wife at all). The patient almost at once falls into ease, smiling at his response. Expecting him to use medical jargon, I am left surprised at the way he translates the diagnosis he has for his patients:

“Imagine that you have to go to Siachen from Rawalpindi- you can either walk or take the plane. The plane will get you there faster. These medicines were supposed to be that plane you took on your route to faster recovery. However, we will take the longer route now- but we will still get there.” he says as he reassures a worried patient whose medications are not having the desired effect.

As we fall into a conversation about the recent cases of child abuse in Pakistan, he remarks sadly that child sex abuse is so common in the Pakistani society that around 1 out of 5 patients that he gets have suffered from child abuse at some point in their lives, which has affected their behavior as adults.

“Unfortunately, we live in a very hypocritical society. We choose not to talk about these things- the things that need to be talked about. All the players who matter are involved themselves in the sad events that take place during child abuse. That is how I view my society as a psychiatrist”.

As our meeting moves towards an end, I ask the doctor about his views on the media and its portrayal of mentally ill patients- who are (usually) sadly portrayed raging lunatics, with poorly crafted stories of supernatural control over these patients. Dr. Minhas seems to be upset about this. “The portrayal of mental health in the media is itself stigmatizing the cause of mental health in this country. They simply don’t seem to care- they are more concerned about what news brings in more money”. He does, however, remark that the media too can help join the fight against mental illnesses by showing them as they are and not creating a warped image of people who are victims of various mental illnesses just to create content that the public enjoys at the expense of others.

At the end of the meeting, Dr. Minhas remarks that it is his ability to affect people’s lives for the better with the knowledge he has, that motivates him every single day. As I leave his clinic, I take with me a changed perspective on the world of psychiatry in Pakistan and a renewed hope in the state of the psychiatric care in Pakistan, through the commitment of individuals like Dr. Fareed Aslam Minhas who leave no stone unturned in their fight against mental illnesses.

 

 

 

 

Restoration of Basant Festival

Restoration of Basant Festival

“Punjab Government recently announced its decision to celebrate Basant festival in the second week of February thus lifting the 12-year ban on this celebration which marks the advent of spring”

This news was met with joy especially by the people of Lahore, Gujranwala, Sialkot and adjoining areas where even the ban could not suppress the people from displaying their love for flying large colorful kites. The past governments had banned the celebrations in order to avoid injuries and deaths caused as a result of the festival but since the supreme court clarified that there is no restriction on celebrating Basant as long as it remains under the extent of law and boundaries defined by the government. Coated with abrasive materials, kite strings often become the cause of injury and death of people, to avoid such mishaps, Punjab’s information minister told reporters that a committee comprising of Punjab’s law minister and other administrative people would deliberate and propose plans to avoid such sad incidents from taking place.

Basant festival has its roots in our culture. In every culture, people welcome spring with celebrating different festivals. The celebration of Basant can be traced back to the era of Ranjeet Singh who declared holidays for as long as ten days to appease the masses. The festival holds great importance for Hindus who celebrate the creative energy and power of goddess Saraswati. While for the majority of muslim population of Pakistan, Basant is still considered a cultural heritage, a festival which is celebrated for the positive synergy it creates amongst the common people.

Banning the Basant Festival had affected many in an adverse manner as a great many people who had their livelihoods linked with providing kites, strings and similar products found themselves out of work. Not only would the restoration of Basant boost economic activity but it will also promote tourism and increase goodwill among the people who long to have such events where they can experience festivities, and socialize while, in this case, enjoying the view of a sky full of color and competition.

In the words of a luminite, Shehreyar from Gujranwala, “I can’t wait to go back to my village and feel the adrenaline by flying kites with everyone”. While this may not be the case for many but it is easy to say that a lot of people have positive albeit dormant memories of the festival, the revival of which will make a lot of them happy.

The Twilight Zone

*Originally published in the December Edition of the PLUMS Dispatch*

My childhood has been a war between reconciling two levels of cultural religiosity. I have reached a (perhaps still incomplete) judgment; being a Shia’a puts you on a spectrum that is constantly at a tug of war between culture and religion. My friend Amna Haider is as Shia’a as they come. With the first of Muharram, the colored clothes go in and the Alams come out, but she does not subscribe to religious practices like fasting or praying. Asad Zaidi, on the other hand, focuses more on the basic tenets of religion, treating them as central rather than the specialized traditions of the sect. Although there are exceptions, I have largely noticed that Azadaari is more a preservation of a cultural identity especially for Pakistani Shia’as, who see it as an act of resistance from the oppressive state not dissimilar to Husssain’s (RA) defiance to Yazid.

Although Partition brought Shia’a and Sunni groups together in the Muslim League, after Independence the Sunni majority established a monopoly on issuing religious legitimacy at the expense of minorities like Ahmedis and Shia’a. It might be interesting to explore why Aga Khanis were not subject to the same level of persecution, perhaps because of the political and economic importance of the Aga Khan. The bloody history of sectarianism is evident with the Hazaras in Quetta, protesting terrorist attacks by sitting with the corpses of family members in the biting cold. This history is evident in my maternal uncle, a doctor, getting death threats and eventually leaving the country. It is evident in never being allowed to go to Majalis because my father was in the government and our expression of our faith was a threat to the powers that be. However, these experiences do not get the same coverage in mainstream media which reduces these issues to meaningless statistics. We are just an “attack on Shia’a mosque leaves 20 dead”.

It’s actually called an Imam Bargah. The growing disenchantment just fuels a reclusion by Shia’a groups into their Garrison towns which become oasis communities defined by their distinct culture. My only surviving grandparent, Nano, reminisces about how when she was young, her Hindu and Sunni friends and neighbors would take part in the festivities of Muharram. Their door would be open to all, with people flocking in to try her mother’s handmade Niaz. The subcontinent accepted these culturally driven traditions outside the confines of religion and saw them as an open experience for all rather one divided on religious grounds. In Lahore still, Hindu communities in Mochi Gate participate in Muharram processions and show a great reverence for the history behind it. Perhaps, persecution despite all its evils does one good thing of bringing minorities together in a shared resentment of their oppressor. These narratives of inter-minority relations are missing from discourses surrounding sectarianism.

Now, Azadaari in my Nano’s house has crept back behind closed doors and selective invites. The microphone is kept at an optimum level where the Salam can be heard in the other room but not to the passersby outside in the street. The Niaz still tastes great, but it has become a relic. An attempt to preserve what used to be, rather than to celebrate a belief grounded in religious history. An attack on culture is tackled by further strengthening the cultural bonds. Interestingly, I have encountered many people who attempt to write our story for us. Well intentioned individuals assume that by reading articles online or doing a basic Google search about the bloody Maatam that makes their insides squirm, they understand our traditions and by extension get to comment on what they do not like about these. Without relating these actions to the horrific history of persecution and the consequent symbolism attached to these traditions they do a disservice to the communities they attempt to understand. What they need to do is to listen. Leave your depersonalized screens micromanaged by censorship laws and listen to individual stories which give you a sense of private experiences that are lost to popular discourse. This article cannot possibly claim how to eradicate sectarianism completely but it can contribute to a few more open individuals. Having more personalized discussion on individual experiences of sect can attempt to bridge the gulf between groups. That is what builds a community which incorporates the white in the flag

Diwali at LUMS

Often called the festival of lights, Diwali commemorates the return of Rama, the seventh incarnation of the god Vishnu, to his people after being exiled for 14 years, during which he fought and won a battle against the demons and the demon king, Ravana. It symbolizes the spiritual victory of light over darkness, good over evil and knowledge over ignorance. The five-day holiday is annually held in autumn during Ashwin, the seventh month of the Hindu calendar and typically falls between the middle of October until the middle of November, which is also the time of harvest, and so represents wealth, prosperity and wisdom.

Last night, the LUMS community joined their Hindu friends on campus to celebrate Diwali, which was organized by the Hum Ahang society at LUMS. The Central Courtyard was decorated with traditional earthen diyas (candles) and colorful rangoli artworks- patterns created on the floor using colored rice or powder, and was lit up with colors, lights, and music. The event began with a short video about what the LUMS community associated with Diwali. For many, it meant happiness, enjoyment and harmony. Shortly afterwards, members from Hum Ahang performed on Dhol Baje, London Thumukda and a Dhandiya dance. This was followed by volunteers from the crowd taking the floor to sing a song or poetry, or dance to mehndi medleys or attan; the latter of which was none other than the request of our attan fanboy student council president. Students ate mithai, danced with bhangras, and took happy pictures in their desi attires.

Diwali is being celebrated on campus since the past three years, for which Hum Ahang is to be accredited. There is a significant number of Hindus who are a part of the LUMS community, and many of these are students who are unable to go back to their homes and celebrate this religious festival with their families. Therefore, it is essential for others to practice empathy, inclusivity, and inter-faith harmony, and create an atmosphere of festivity for them on campus, which is their home away from home. Moreover, in times such as the past week which created an air of anguish, loss and sorrow, it is necessary for us to keep reminding ourselves to not give up. The Diwali celebration helped us recollect ourselves, our moods, and our spirits.