Reflections on the Partition

Author: Hadi Ameer

The road to India is an inconspicuous one, at first. There are khokhas, regular fruit vendors, and the odd bank offices. The sun seems resilient on a warm Lahori afternoon, set against the backdrop of the GT Road’s semi-urban landscape. You drive on. The road gets a little bumpier. Vehicles are replaced by carts, engines by donkeys and mules, brick and mortar by green expansiveness, cacophony by quiet. The urban morphs into the rural.

You finally arrive at a military check-post, park your car and start walking. A stadium-like edifice welcomes you. A loudspeaker crackles, followed by a collective roar from the audience. The road goes through the stadium, ending at a gate. India’s on the other side. There’s something enthralling about the volumes and the sheer scale of the enterprise. These aren’t trained professionals screaming “Pakistan Zindabad” at the top of their voices. They’re just normal people, clamouring to be louder than the other side.

A similar scene is to be witnessed across the gate. This is the Wagah-Attari parade, a flag-lowering ceremony performed by collaboration between the Pakistan Rangers and the Border Security Forces (BSF).

*************

Pakistan was forged in the traumatic crucible of partition. Partition left us with a convulsion of sentiment; an unseemly concoction of anguish and jubilation. Some rejoiced at the making of the new nation, others were left to tend to their scars. The ceremony at Wahga is a regular reminder of partition: that Pakistan and India are two separate nations that came about from an active re-ordering of geopolitics. But the seventy years between now and partition have impacted the way we understand its legacy. The roaring voices are new. But they have been there for some time. It is easy to forget that they were not always there. The older ones were far less buoyant: the chugging sound of a corpse-filled train coming to halt at the Lahore Railway station, the steady tap tap of feet, both naked and covered as they moved across the designated Radcliffe Line, even the crackle of fire that echoed from where Muslims had danced at Hindu weddings and vice versa; from what had once been friendly neighborhoods.

Standing amidst the frenzy, a scene from Manto’s Toba Tek Singh comes to mind. The inhabitants of the asylum were conflicted. They did not know where to go or what to do. The participants of the ceremony are not. They know who they are. They think they know who they are not. The conviction is unwavering.

Bishan Singh stands at the gate. Manto stands with him. Faiz is there too. They look to their left and to their right, to India and then to Pakistan, negotiating a splintered identity in a no man’s land. In a world where identity is derivative of the nation, these are no-men: inhabitants of the no man’s land, inhabited by a split-self, appalled by a tainted freedom (ye shab-gazida sahar), despondent for what couldn’t be achieved.

In these moments of crisis, it is to these individuals that we can turn to. They challenge the unwavering conviction that the ceremony’s slogans exude and thus question our understanding of the past. Time’s concoction of deliberate forgetfulness and calculated emphasis has structured how we remembered the events that elapsed seventy years ago. Amidst the frenzy of nationalist sentiment, some voices speak to us. They remind us that the silence of partition’s traumas is anything but comfortable.

Much like the thunderous clamour at the Bab-e-Azadi, this silence too is deafening. With both, there is a story to be told.

*********************

Another day of green festivity is upon us. There will be sombre military parades and flashy news bulletins. In a few days, green flags will be hoisted on rooftops, draped over the bonnets of cars, found in the hands of jovial children, their cheeks painted green in the color of the nation, their eyes full of promise. In all these moments of elation, partition seems not a welcome guest at the table of independence. It appears as an oddity, a forlorn anomaly hesitant to enter the conversation. More alarmingly so, we are afraid to let it in. Why ruin the mood? Why soil a festive day with grim, dreary tales of depravity?

In the seven decades that have elapsed since, plenty has transpired. The vacuum of silence, left behind by separation, longing and firaaq has been filled in by the clamorous call to arms and dissociation from what was once ours. Traumas have been left unresolved, identities unfound, and madness unquestioned. Partition’s legacy comprises both new possibilities and its grief-stricken beginnings. Let us not forget that.

 

Featured photo credit: Partition Museum

Old Isn’t Gold, It’s Expensive!

Author: Muhammad Rafeh

Abdul Qadir Patel became Pakistan’s youngest member of the Sindh provincial assembly – aged 25 – in 1993. Covering almost two decades of political façade in the country since then, the number of persons under 30 in either the National Assembly or the Provincial Assemblies binds closer to zero.

Benazir Bhutto became the youngest elected Prime Minister of a Muslim state – aged 35 – in 1988. Continuing the legacy, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari became the youngest foreign minister of Pakistan – aged 33 – in the year 2022. While critics grew firm in the opposition to Pakistan’s foreign affairs predicament, having placed little trust in Bhutto’s command over foreign affairs, the benefits of having a younger foreign minister seemed lackluster to the general population.

In a world where countries seem to thrive on young leaders, including Finland under Marin’s leadership, Chile under Boric, and Georgia under Garibashvili, Pakistan has been ill-fated even to have the presence of youth in their assemblies. Imran Khan turned 66 when he presided over his office in 2018; Nawaz Sharif assumed his prime ministerial office, turning 64, whereas Yousaf Raza Gillani took office at the prime age of 56. These are nothing but only the plain records of Pakistan’s democratically elected leaders post-Musharraf.

A critical look into the absence of Pakistan’s youth from legislative assemblies and politics also asks us to consider the youth wings of political parties. In fact, a deeper dive into the mechanics of such existing youth wings ironically highlights these absences. PTI’s youth wing leader in Punjab before the 2018 general elections was Zubair Khan Niazi, who not only did not qualify for youth but also fared through Khan’s bloodline. PMLN’s youth wing performed no different with its current President being Captain (R) Safdar – currently aged 58 and the legal spouse of Maryam Nawaz Khan. The only upside that Pakistan People’s Party hopes to appoint is Asifa Bhutto as the Youth Wing leader of PPP. However, the irony is visible to the naked eye.

Various op-eds have mentioned the need for Pakistan’s youth to vote in the upcoming general election of 2023 – or sooner. The populace of youth between 15 and 30 stands at around 64%. The issues that the nation faces today – in terms of global competition, social security, etc. – fall directly under the youth of Pakistan. A potential voter aged twenty-four could possibly turn into a definitive voter if they were voting for an individual within the same age gap rather than for a Babuji.

While one may present ideas as Khan does, such as pleading the youth to vote and save Pakistan from the irony of heinous invaders unlike himself – a better way to make the youth vote is to ‘make the youth vote for the youth.’ Only if the youth was provided party tickets to PTI than be pleaded to by the former Prime Minister to join their task force in persuading individuals to walk out of their homes and vote for the 2023 general elections.

Sociology consistently points towards the idea that for a person to understand another’s problems, they need to relate to the individual in question. Hence, there seems no way possible other than the way of making the youth vote for the youth in the upcoming elections. While the process may not fare entirely well, even gathering 70% of the 64% population of Pakistan to vote in the national elections of 2023 compared to the 30% who voted in 2018 would be a win for a country whose leaders repeatedly claim for democracy.

Franklin D. Roosevelt famously said, “We may not be able to build the future for our youth, but we may be able to build the youth for the future.” In a country where dynasty politics runs rampant, and the future leadership of PTI is destined to go haywire, it is necessary for the youth to be mobilized into politics and provided party tickets. It may not be time to say goodbye to the old notaries for now, but it will be soon.

Eik Qaum Ek Nisaab and the Curious Case of Number 18

Author: Muhammad Rafeh

“Eik Qaum, Eik Nisaab” echoed through the hallways of Pakistan’s education commission as policymakers put their heads together to integrate the Single National Curriculum into the scheme of studies of all schools across the country. The incumbent government thought that a nationwide curriculum change would bring equality, if not equity, to the nation’s educational sector. However, what they did not realize is that a parent does not pay PKR 100,000 a month to Aitchison so that they can receive sub-par education. The issue here is not the implementation of the Single National Curriculum; it is the ridiculous policy that the government has put forth.

From the Children Rights Commissions to the Educational Boards and Legal Analytics, all have been vocal against inequality in the provision of education in Pakistan for several years. Our dearest Prime Minister, Imran Khan, promised a ‘Naya Pakistan’ where education would become one of the most thriving sectors. Three years later, after keeping that promise unfulfilled, the government now wants to implement a risky strategy to change the education sector of the country. There are two problems that need to be addressed. Firstly, through the channel of SNC, the government is trying to address a problem in the education sector that only very few have an issue with, while bigger problems are left unsolved. Secondly, the authority to implement a nationwide curriculum is no longer in the hands of the federal government.

If one has a conversation about the history of Pakistan with our present leaders, it would go something like this:

Reporter: Can you please trace the constitutional history of Pakistan?

The government: Musharraf left in 2008 and then 5 years after that are a bit blank for us. Then, Sharif came into power in 2013.

The government, at this point, is probably unaware that the number 18 even exists; for Sindh, however, the 18th has somewhat become their favorite number. Many have claimed that PTI is the first national party of Pakistan while the others are in the favor of provincial. Those who agree have failed to realize that Pakistan is not just one nation, but it is provincial with provincially delegated subjects. Education, for instance, is one such subject. Where the government had a viable opportunity to open multiple schools across Pakistan, they decided to do something that wasn’t even in their control anymore; this is somewhat of an ‘at least we tried’ attitude. The problem is, just trying is not enough. In a country where the PM takes pride over the fact that the rate of youth leaving Pakistan rises every year, one cannot help but question if the government was trying to improve the educational structure at all in the first place.

Many of my colleagues who are supporters of PTI have often told me that this is just the beginning and that the government is planning “Eik Qaum, Hazaron School”. I cannot help but wonder if our current government is planning to carry this out within the two years left in power, or are they fully confident that they will be running the show until 2028? Even then, the fact that the authorities do not remember the number 18 leaves a big question mark.

Even when the government is planning to implement the SNC, there is a present shortage of the newly printed SNC books in Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. In such circumstances, one might also wonder why the educational institutions were closed for a week in these same areas, especially when the implementation of the SNC was in process. Assuming that this is just a conspiracy theory, even if the SNC is implemented in Punjab and KP and not in Sindh (from the looks of it), does that not deepen Pakistan’s problem of inequality in education? Imagine a country where two provinces and the Capital follow one syllabus and the other two provinces follow their own.

Failing to uphold Article-25A of the Constitution of 1973 is set to be a cause of further disparity in a country where inequality is already deep-rooted when it comes to the provision of education. “Ek Qaum, Ek Nisaab” is a catchphrase until the government recalls number 18. When they do, the result would be “Ek Qaum, Hazaron Nisaab” instead of what should have been “Ek Qaum, Hazaron School”.

Caretakers of Islam: Throwing Caution to the Wind

Author: Muhammad Rafeh

The highest law of our land reads ‘The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan’. In Pakistan, the caretakers of Islam are often called mullahs or maulvis, and they wield immense power. This is not because they are politically or socially well-known, but because they are the flag-bearers of Islam, something they use as a pin in the board for every political, social, or economic move they make.

The founder of Pakistan, Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, claimed, “there is no power that can undo Pakistan.” However, in recent times, one is compelled to wonder that while the founder’s words may hold true when it comes to external attempts of undoing, the same surely cannot be assumed in terms of internal undoing.

The pages of Pakistani history are painted red with the atrocities that its citizens have faced solely because of the power that these self-proclaimed Islamic caretakers hold. From religious cadres sealing off the country’s roads in protest of a woman being legally acquitted of blasphemy to wreaking havoc on the Aurat Marches across Pakistan, these religious fanatics have done everything but take care of the religion that preaches humanity before anything else.

After pondering on the subject, several questions come to mind. Do these people deserve to be called the caretakers of Islam? Are they worthy of being regarded with the reverence this community bestows upon them? Perhaps one can argue that every man who wears a cleric’s cap and grows a beard is not a maulvi, and that the people who engage in such cruelties do so of their own independent will, not because their religion commands it. This was seen following the ruckus caused by TLP earlier this year when members of the party openly dissociated themselves from the protestors clamoring on the streets and claimed that they were members of another party, charged with the task of discrediting TLP. It is easy to wash the blame off your hands in this country, especially when you know the state will never hold you accountable and will always end up caving in to your demands. This is what our incumbent government did by releasing the arrested TLP leader, Saad Rizvi.

Since the beginning of Prime Minister Imran Khan’s term, it has been clear that he secured premiership through the support of the entire country. It was expected of him to not socially exclude any faction if he intends to stay in power. Like his predecessors, Khan knows his politics; when he is to remain silent and when to take action. Recently, however, he has quite openly voiced his opinions on rape which mirror those of the country’s misguided mullahs. Time after time, he has suggested that women are raped because their “immodest” dressing entices men. One is then compelled to believe that perhaps he has the same mentality as those he remains silent for.

Not long ago, one of the Islamic caretakers openly admitted and justified the act of raping a child in a seminary. The video was preceded by another, filmed by one of the students at the seminary which shows the maulvi raping the child. The video rankled many to their cores and offered a terrifying glimpse into what happens behind the pristine, Arabic-engraved walls of seminaries. While the perpetrator has been arrested, the problem is far from solved.

Now that the extent of influence exercised by mullahs is out in the open, is Khan going to address the mounting issue? Is the government going to go back on vitalizing the status of mullahs through the implementation of the Single National Curriculum? Is it reasonable to expect such a U-turn, a concept this government is very familiar with, on the only educational policy this party has produced in its 3 years of power? For how long will these mullahs be allowed to torture, ridicule, and rape children before parents truly become aware of the trauma they inflict on minors within these madrasahs? Perhaps, it is safer to teach the Quran to your child yourself than have a potential predator lurking in your house.

What the common folk needs to consider is that the “caretakers” of Islam enjoy these sin-with-impunity rights because of us. They are made by us. We seek spiritual and religious guidance from them, often forgetting that they themselves are misguided. We put them on a pedestal, revere them as guardians of Islam because of their self-proclaimed proximity to the Holy Book, and blindly trust them with the life and well-being of our children. While Khan may be reluctant to pick a bone with these maulvis in an attempt to secure as many votes as possible for the 2023 elections, we, as a society, need to take more responsibility for the plight of our children under the care of mullahs. At the same time, the PTI government needs to reevaluate its priorities. They need to be aware of the potential consequences of remaining indifferent about a confession that has plunged our society into uncertainty and insecurity.

Whether the Prime Minister cares more about his people or his seat, only time will tell. However, it is about time we learn that while not all maulvis are morally and socially corrupt, it is better to give caution to the wind than have #NotAllMaulvis trend on Twitter.

 

Government Action Against TLP: too little, too late?

Every political party in Pakistan, before coming into power, has made questionable alliances with the religious right parties, the most recent example being PML-N’s alliance with Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (F). Making these alliances eventually results in these parties having to give some political power to the religious right they allied with to fulfill their promise, and gives the right a platform to promote intolerance, sectarian violence, and a complete disregard for minorities’ rights.

Previously, the TLP claimed that they had reached an agreement with the government wherein the government was supposedly accepting all their demands including expulsion of the French ambassador within three months, releasing already arrested TLP workers and not arresting any more TLP workers (Dawn). After the TLP leader Saad Hussain Rizvi was arrested on 12 April, the TLP carried out extremely violent protests with the intention of “jamming the entire country”. Rizvi is carrying forth the legacy of his dead father, Khadim Hussain Rizvi, who died in November 2020, by demanding the deportation of the French ambassador after the Charlie Hebdo cartoons incident. From their inception, TLP has proudly worn their extremist agenda like a badge; a senior TLP leader claimed in 2018: “When it involves the honour of the Prophet Muhammad, the finality of his Prophethood or the dishonouring of his person, then every Muslim will become an extremist” (Al-Jazeera).

TLP has repeatedly caused civil unrest and opposed key reforms, and government action is long due. Party workers and supporters have participated in violent protests across the country for the past three days now, and their hostile acts have resulted in the injuries of 340 people and the deaths of around 4 people, including two policemen as some TLP supporters decided to arm themselves and were well trained in this respect.

 

The French embassy within Pakistan has directed French nationals and companies to leave the country for a while, with the embassy running with limited staff. The actions of TLP are straining key relationships of Pakistan with important European allies. The TLP has endangered the lives of people through these violent riots amidst a pandemic which is only worsening, and these extremist actions have caused deaths. The recent government orders have banned the party under Rule 11(b) of the Anti-Terrorism Law of 1997. Police reports have also been filed against individuals from TLP who were active participants in the riots.

But is this government action too little, too late? Laws that could charge the religio-political parties with several misdemeanors have been established for quite a while now, but the government has only chosen to take action now. Not only the incumbent government, but past governments have also failed to act decisively when TLP and other religio-political parties caused unrest in the nation with their divisive ideologies meant to actively incite violence. This is linked to the alliances made with these parties as a desperate move to gain more votes.

The state urgently needs to address the problems of sectarian violence, riots, terrorist attacks, and the lack of rights granted to minorities in the country. All of these problems can be linked to the far right opposing any and all laws that could possibly result in some peace in the country for the average citizen. It is not only the democratic political parties that have granted the religious right a platform for their extremism, but also the military governments which have used religion as a source of legitimacy for their undemocratic rules in a democratic state and thus unwisely involved maulanas in the policy-making process. The objectionable actions of previous governments are still haunting the nation, and the current  government’s move to ban TLP should not stop with this party, but should be applicable to religio-political parties everywhere in Pakistan, especially violent ones because their existence is simply unconstitutional. Toleration of these parties by the state has only resulted in more violence; there can be no tolerance of intolerance.

Aftermath of Charlie Hebdo cartoons

September 2020 saw the French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo reprinting cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad, and subsequently, an attack was carried out by Islamic extremists outside the former headquarters of the magazine. Charlie Hebdo has a long tradition of using caricatures as a way of countering the rhetoric of political and religious authorities. This assault comes five years after an attack on the same magazine for the same reasons. Following these events was a beheading of a middle school teacher who had shown these cartoons to his students, in a class on ‘freedom of expression’.

Muslim countries in the Middle East and South Asia, along with Turkey, have witnessed protests against France and a ban on French products. This ban would extend to French multinational stores as well, including the Carrefour supermarket chain, Total and its petrol products, and fashion and cosmetic products from the brand L’Oreal, among others. The question arises, who is the ban for? It is clear that a strong European economy such as that of France will most likely not suffer from a boycott by countries in the Global South. The consequences of this ban may not be felt by the French economy; instead, only serve to fulfill the wants of far-right groups in Pakistan and restrict consumer choice.

This ban on French products is hypocritical if the Uighur Muslim crisis is taken into account. While PM Imran Khan of Pakistan has strongly condemned the cartoons and admonished President Macron for “attacking Islam”, Khan has not denounced the concentration camps in China for Uighur Muslims. This act highlights the politics that underlie the condemnation of France, while China remains unquestioned and unaccountable: whereas France is far removed from Pakistan in terms of political geography, China is an immediate neighbor with whom Pakistan wishes to keep good relations. The expected boost to Pakistan’s economy from the ongoing project of China–Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) is too profitable an opportunity to squander in favour of opposing human rights violations by the very country upon whom the success of this venture depends.

Moreover, a political battle of wills has ensued as tensions rise in both nations following the controversy. France’s idea to have ID numbers for children led to Pakistan Minister for Human Rights, Shireen Mazari, likening it to Hitler’s ideology of anti-Semitism, only this time it was so-called Islamophobia. Mazari was forced to withdraw her statement after France clarified their position, saying this identification form would not apply to only Muslim children, but to all children in France. This identification is related to a recent move on part of the French government to make sure that all French children are attending schools, and to prevent “radicalization at home”.

By far the most concerning thing to happen on local ground is the mass protest carried out by TLP, which called for completely severing ties with France and banning French products; and in doing so fueled the ideology of the far-right Islamist political party. The fact that the government allowed these protests to take place, that too in the midst of a worsening pandemic, is highly unsettling. Violence ensued at the protest and riot police had to resort to using tear gas and rubber bullets. Additionally, it exposed many to the threat of COVID-19, and the leader of TLP also succumbed to the virus on November 19th.

What is especially worrying is the fact that such far-right politico-religious parties are allowed to exist in the first place and that their activities are not sanctioned by the government of Pakistan. Parties such as the TLP, JUI, and JI, in all their years of existence, have only managed to polarize the citizens of Pakistan even further, and have constantly fought against rights for women and minorities from a supposedly “religious” stance. It is clear that they are using religion as a means to an end: the end being power over a heteronormative patriarchal society based on a version of religion that constantly oppresses women and minorities in order to silence dissent.

These instances show Pakistan’s hypocritical and uninformed stance on French legislation related to Muslims. However, France has not been doing itself any favors in the present moment, or in the past, when it has carried out controversial bans on hijab, niqab and burkinis. The United Nations Human Rights Committee has asserted that this ban violates women’s freedom of religion and it could have the effect of marginalizing them by obstructing their access to the public sphere. The French Interior Minister has also attacked stores selling halal meats, claiming that this serves “separatism” in the community.

Clearly, France needs to take a more nuanced position when dealing with the threat of extreme Islamism in their secular nation: “…what is concerning is the lack of nuance from the government that results once again in Muslims feeling as if they are guilty until proven innocent,” says Sarah Alouane, a French legal scholar and expert in religious freedom (The Washington Post). On local ground, it must be demanded that the government of Pakistan also take a stand, not only against international threats, but against native threats posed by far-right political groups which misuse religion as a tactic to gain power and cause civil unrest.

How the Catastrophic Storms in Karachi are Making Life Unliveable?

2020 has been a tough year for Pakistan so far. The unexpected wave of Coronavirus caused numerous casualties and brought life to a complete halt. Now when people had only started to recover and return to normal life, a series of continuous rainfall befell the country – causing havoc in Sindh especially. While the rest of Pakistan enjoyed the drop in high temperatures, the past two weeks were devastating for Karachi: the city of lights had turned into an abyss of darkness and despair amid heavy downpours.

Heart-wrenching images have been circulating on the internet that provide a glimpse into life in Karachi: an old man carrying his sewing machine (the only source of his income), struggling shop owners desperately looking for intact items so they could salvage some of their life’s work, and kittens drowning in rainwater. Roads and underpasses are filled with water to the brim. The vehicles of those who saved for ages to buy a car are now submerged and forever lost, and the destruction of houses has left people without any place to seek shelter.

The residents have been deprived of electricity for days. Many civilians have not only lost their homes and livelihood but their loved ones too. The rainwater has mixed with sewage water which is a great threat to the health of many. In areas like Malir, the water is increasing to a dangerous level every day, leaving the residents in a state of helplessness and desolation. The desert areas of Tharparkar have received plenty of rainfall which has destroyed the residents’ mud-houses as well as their crops, forcing them to migrate to unknown areas with their animals and without any assistance from the government.

In these difficult times the people have come out to help one another: a few NGO’s namely Al-Khidmat foundation, Chippa Welfare Association and Edhi Foundation have been working to rescue the citizens.

While many of the residents are struggling to save the lives of their family members and desperate for a place to seek shelter, people living in the posh areas actually seem to be enjoying the multicolored hues of the skies and a change in the weather. While many have nothing to eat, the other side of Karachi has been ordering food online from eateries whose workers put their lives in danger by commuting through the rainwater to earn something for themselves in these desperate times.

This highlights the disparity between the classes and the plight of the underprivileged- a scene from the movie ‘Parasite’ come to life, a stark and sobering contrast between the haves and have nots.

The monsoon rains this time have broken an 89-year-old record with an increase of 306 MM as compared to the monthly average for August. With more rainfall expected in the coming weeks, the city is likely to be hit by more flash floods which will further disrupt the lives of the people.

The city is now in a dilapidated condition and the question which arises here is that who is to be held responsible for all this destruction – the Government which has once again failed the citizens of Karachi or the management authorities who have failed to repair Karachi’s infrastructure and unclog the city drains in preparation for the monsoon?

The truth is, no one is willing to take responsibility for Karachi’s welfare. In the face of such calamity, all anyone is able to do is watch Karachi sink deeper and deeper still.

 

 

 

 

What the PK-8303 Crash Tells Us About Ethical Reporting in Media?

The horrors of this year seem to be never-ending. 2020 already feels like an apocalypse. If it wasn’t for the ongoing Coronavirus that led to a staggering 4800 cases in the past 24 hours, then the crashing of PK-8303 certainly shook the nation to its core. Two days prior to Eid, when the joy of seeing one’s loved ones kept everyone up at night, no one anticipated the tragic fate that laid ahead. One hundred and seven passengers on board, sixty seconds from the runway, but the destination was not to be Jinnah International Airport. That is precisely what makes the vagaries of our life unthinkable: a lapse of just a few seconds.

While the whole country mourns the devastating loss of precious lives, the media was quick to exploit the adversity for their gain shake. Moments after the crash, TV channels and social media were filled with unverified news about the number of casualties, names of passengers, and the cause(s) of the crash. Journalists and keyboard warriors were ahead in the perpetuation of this unauthentic reporting through their dubious analysis of the situation, when on the other hand, aviation experts had chosen to momentarily remain silent on the issue.

It comes off as no surprise that journalism in our country has always been contentious for all the wrong reasons. Any tragedy that leaves the people distressed and broken has further spillover effects by creating an aura of anxiety and fear. Yet, at a time when words of consolation are essential, our media makes the worst use of the pitiable state of its viewers. News coverage becomes a cascade of the gross depiction of the disaster through an inadequate, albeit exaggerated choice of words coupled with horrifying images from the site. Much to say, during the reporting of the PK 8303 crash, no attention was paid whatsoever towards the privacy of the victims and their families. For example, minutes after the crash, the list, and photos of passengers were widely seen circulating social media. When one searched for a glimmer of hope amidst the chaotic times, the sensational reporting by most TV channels overlooked the importance of confidentiality and the right to privacy. Additionally, the catastrophe was not free from the unnecessary blame-game, that primarily made the Head Pilot, the central target of the discourse. The captain was accused of failing to follow the instructions from the Air Traffic Control that hence led to the unfortunate mishap. What may have eventually led to the tragedy is beside the point. The incumbent of concluding the cause lies only with the investigation team and it would have been more appropriate to pay some respect to the pilot’s family during a situation that must have left them deeply disturbed.

On another similar occasion, a recreated animation from an apparent simulator game was falsely attributed as the actual demonstration of the crash. Before it could even be checked for authenticity, the post pervasively found itself on various social media platforms. Despite users pointing out that the video had been uploaded on YouTube a year back, no action was taken in any capacity by PEMRA or other regulating authorities.

The recreated simulation image of the crash

Many questions were asked, and several justified doubts were cast on the authenticity of the media in our country. Most inhibitions pertained to the ineffective training of the newsroom staff, reporters, and journalists to ethically handle sensitive situations. The mischievous race towards attaining the maximum rating comes at an evident cost of an invasion of privacy, factual inaccuracies, and unwarranted sensationalism. If one media station sensationalizes the issue, other competitors are forced to follow suit to avoid losing ground on the target audience. The obvious consequence is a blatant disregard for professionalism and an aggravation of the crisis by manipulating the sentiments of the viewers.

In a country of 190 million people, the media, as a social institution, has been nefarious and bitter. For years, the impartiality of the industry has been contested for propagating the interests of a particular segment of society. And to fester the already damaged image of the institution, the credibility of reporting has further problematized the notion of neutrality. It is about time we realize the precarity of the issue and demand a greater focus on ethics and professionalism from our media.

 

Smog: The Silent Menace

Winter is upon us, and what that unfortunately means is that the sky is going to turn into one large soup of chemicals and dirt. And as much as we like to think of LUMS as a bubble, there is no protection this time. Statistically, things are worse than ever. Lahore is part of the elite company, having one of the worst rates of air pollution in the world. We breathe in air that is considered ‘dangerous’ by EPA standards and that isn’t even the worst part. Smog causes some terrible conditions including but not limited to a bad case of allergies, respiratory problems, skin conditions, and eye infections. With the already distressing finals and tons of assignments coming up, this can set one back further, culminating in a sad state of affairs. For people with chronic conditions such as asthma and COPD, smog can be particularly dangerous, so getting through the winter should be a top priority for us all.

Now, we aren’t going to solve this problem entirely, but we can protect and equip ourselves with some useful weapons against this force of destruction. Here are a few general and specific guidelines to follow:

  1. Avoid the outdoors. Sure, the outdoors can be fun and the weather is nice enough, but it comes at a cost. Just imagine, every time you breathe in the smoggy air, you’re breathing in millions of dust and dirt particles. That usually does the trick. This doesn’t mean you can’t go outdoors. If you feel the absolute need to, a facemask works well. Avoid having a run around midday; that’s when ozone levels are peaking.
  2. Don’t contribute. If we all support the Climate March, then surely we can bring some degree of change to our ultra-consumerist lifestyles. Use public transport for a change (some neat buses are running throughout Lahore). Don’t burn wood or trash in the outdoors, if you’re into that type of stuff.
  3. Stay hydrated. While this isn’t so apparent, hydration does wonders to your blood and acts as a detoxifier against the smoggy air. Plus, being hydrated just feels nice and comforting.
  4. Stop indoor pollution. Place some nice potted rubber plants or lilies in your room. They keep the air fresh and clean. And please don’t smoke indoors.

Also wild fact: If we all were to replace our regular light bulbs with compact fluorescent light bulbs, we would eliminate 136 kilos of carbon dioxide that would otherwise join the atmosphere.

The Inescapable Hurt Locker

A Hindu student should have ideally written this article. No one should have to silence themselves for fear of being attacked by zealots. No one should have to live in an atmosphere where they fear not only the zealots outside this campus but also their peers on it. No one should have to beg people to listen to the plight of their community. The state exists to protect and it has failed the Hindu community of Pakistan as we have failed our Hindu peers on campus.

On September 14, 2019, a first information report was lodged under Article 295(c) against the principal of the Sindh Public School Mr. Nautan Daas on the complaint of Mr. Abdul Aziz Rajput, who happens to be the father of the student who alleged that his principal had committed blasphemy in videos that went viral online before Facebook graciously decided to take them down. The following day, a mob of “true” Muslims took upon themselves the responsibilities of judge, jury and executioner. The protesters took to the streets to demand the arrest of the “blasphemer” and called for a shutter-down strike. That those responsible for defaming Islam were held accountable was absolutely certain of as the protesters proceeded to vandalize a Hindu temple and the school. Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) MNA Mr. Ramesh Kumar Vankwani, also the head of the Pakistan Hindu Council, alleged that the protesters ended up doing much more damage. According to his count, the protesters vandalized three Hindu temples, a private school and houses belonging to members of the Hindu community.

Jahannum ki aag feat. True Muslims at Ghotki

As often happens in these cases, Muslims from neighbouring areas soon found their conscience as well. Surrounding towns like Mirpur Mathelo and Adilpur also saw demonstrations demanding the arrest of Mr. Nautan Daas, who as of this moment is “safe” in police custody. The police have, their credit, attempted to do their job. While they failed to protect citizens of the state from being attacked for no other reason than belonging to a specific creed, they have registered three cases against the rioters. The first FIR was filed under Sections 295 (injuring or defiling place of worship, with intent to insult the religion of any class), 147 (punishment for rioting) and 149 (every member of unlawful assembly guilty of offence committed in prosecution of common object). 45 people were nominated in the FIR, out of which 22 people were named while 23 were listed as unidentified.

Another case was lodged against 150 people, 27 named and 123 unidentified, for blocking roads. Lastly, the third FIR pertaining to rioting and theft was filed against 23 people, including 11 unidentified persons, over allegations that protesters had stolen goods from multiple shops in the Shahi Bazar. In the meanwhile, Prime Minister Imran Khan used his investigative expertise to locate the real conspiracy at the heart of this affair: was intentionally done to sabotage his upcoming address to the United Nations General Assembly.

Earlier this month, Ms. Nimirta Amarta Maher Chandani, a final year BDS student at Shaheed Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto Medical University, was found dead in her hostel room. The cause of death was initially presumed to be suicide. The findings of an initial autopsy report were inconclusive and members of Nimrita’s family alleged that something far more sinister was at play. Her brother, Dr. Vishal claimed that there were cable marks on Nimrita’s neck and hands, marks that could not be made by the “dupatta” allegedly used by her to commit suicide. Furthermore, he said that he had talked to her fairly recently and everything was as normal as could be. She did not express any signs of distress according to her brother. Civil society and the Hindu community in particular were quick to take to the streets. Protests were organised at Teen Talwar (Karachi), Chandka Medical College (Larkana) and Tando Jam Agriculture University. Many demands were made of the powers that be, the most important of which was recently accepted: a judicial inquiry into the incident. The provincial government had initially requested the session court for a judicial inquiry. The session judge then went on to ask the Sindh High Court for permission to grant the government’s request, which was granted on Wednesday.

Ms. Nimirta Amarta Maher Chandani

These incidents are not one offs, as not too long ago this year, two minor Hindu girls were forcefully and converted. It would be bizarre to assume that these incidents are rare occurrences. However, one would not be at fault for not knowing the specifics of the oppression that the Hindu community has historically faced and continues to, to this day. According to the US based Sindhi Organisation, 1000 Sindhi Hindu girls between the ages of 12 to 28 are forcefully converted to Islam every year. 40 to 60 Sindhi Hindus undergo forceful conversion every month. The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) reported that 7,430 girls were abducted and forcefully converted between January 2004 and May 2018. These figures do not account for all the cases that go unreported because of threats of violence and law enforcement issues.

There is a pattern that keeps repeating itself here. The victims tend to be triply underprivileged in the sense that they are Hindu girls and women who often belong to low income families. In most cases the victim is abducted and is then subjugated to sustained emotional and physical abuse often involving threats of violence towards their loved ones. The issue is symptomatic of multi-layered state failure. The state has in the past failed to socio-economically uplift the Hindu community and has kept them from acquiring power that would enable members to protect themselves. Political parties have voiced support for bills seeking to protect members of minority communities but have not been able to pass any concrete legislation on the matter. MNA Dr. Ramesh Kumar Vankwani from the ruling Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) submitted the Child Marriage Restraint Act (Amendment) Bill 2019 and the Criminal Law (Protection of Minorities) Act 2019 in the National Assembly in the wake of an alleged kidnapping of two Hindu girls and their forced conversion to Islam, earlier this year. Both the bills were accompanied by a 5 point resolution which specifically called for the immediate passage of the bill against forced conversions, which had been unanimously passed by the Sindh Assembly in 2016 and then reverted due to pressure of extremist elements, from all the legislatures. Political parties must prioritise the safety of vulnerable communities over the loss of potential voters and fears of backlash from the religious right. Furthermore, law enforcement has failed to protect minority communities and courts have failed to dispense justice for victims. Religious institutions have also allowed girls and women to be converted with relative ease. Lastly, media organisations have failed to hold law-making, law-enforcing, judicial and religious institutions to account for their respective failures.

HRCP reports that the police often turn a blind eye to reports of abduction and forced conversions and thereby create an atmosphere of impunity for perpetrators. The police often either refuse to record a First Information Report or falsify information. FIRs are necessary for taking cases forward and in the absence of those, most cases don’t even get registered. False information makes cases weak and allows perpetrators to win cases even when they get registered. The police forces, which are overwhelming Muslim, generally sympathise with the goal of converting religious minorities and therefore actively assist perpetrators. On the rare occasions when police do want to investigate and perform their duties, powerful local leaders exert considerable pressure to prevent any action.

The courts have failed to follow proper procedure as well. As often happens in cases involving religious elements, the judiciary are often subject to fear of violence from extremist elements. Even when this pressure from extremists does not exist, the judges’ personal religious beliefs, ties to the local community and deeply entrenched patriarchal socio-cultural norms influence them into easily accepting claims made by the man that the victim involved converted and married of her own free will. Often there is no investigation and a conversion certificate is accepted as being sufficient evidence of consensual conversion. This obviously ignores the fact that most of the girls involved are under the age of consent and even when they aren’t, are subject to threats that render their consent inapplicable. Worse still, the victim is largely left in the custody of her kidnapper throughout the trial process (as happened in a case involving Mian Mithoo) where she is subject to further threats to force her into denying her abduction and rape and claiming that the conversion was .

One must understand more processes of the legitimation of this barbarity that are at play. For one, none of this can happen, without the existence of a culture that legitimises and celebrates forced conversions. Religious organisations happen to be responsible for that. Religious institutions like local mosques and seminaries, routinely fail to investigate the nature of the conversion or question the age of the bride.  Even when they demand proof of age, they are satisfied by a simple affidavit from any member of the locality. These institutions mostly accept the word of the kidnapper and produce a conversion certificate. This is subsequently used by police and the courts to excuse violations or to grant bail. The documentary “Thrust into Heaven” names Sharif Abdul Haq (Mian Mithoo) of Ghotki and Pir Sarhandi of Umerkot as two of the most powerful clerics who facilitate these conversions.

Mian Mithoo was involved in the high-profile Rinkle Kumari conversion case in 2012. His “wife” and her family alleged forceful conversion and marriage, especially given the fact that her birth certificate showed she was 16 at the time of marriage. Even after Rinkle begged the Ghotki court to let her go back to her parents, her “husband” was allowed to take her home. Rinkle then went on to repeat her request in the Sindh High Court and the court graciously allowed her to live in a shelter home. After threatening staff at the shelter home, Mithoo’s son who I’ll call Mithoo Jr. (Mini Mithoo was almost used here), met Rinkle. What happened in that conversation doesn’t require Picasso-esque imagination. After this, the Pakistan People’s Party decided it was finally time to let Mithoo go and he was expelled from the party. He had won the previous election in 2008 with 59,000 votes. He lost the 2013 edition by gaining a grand total of 69.

Apt innuendo there if you ask me. If only he had spent time campaigning as opposed to converting young children. But, Pakistan is the land of the pure as we all know. So, in 2015, the purest of them all asked Mithoo to join the project of Naya Pakistan. Fortunately, even the PTI has standards and the public outcry at his possible inclusion into the party forced the leadership to drop him. Don’t be happy yet though – he is still an influential religious figure and has immense political power. Unsurprisingly, he was involved in the Ghotki riots mentioned at the start of this article.

Prime Minister Imran Khan thinking about Riyasat-e-Madinah with Mian Mithoo in 2015

The buck doesn’t stop with Mithoo though. The Bharchundi Sharif Shrine is renowned for converting Hindu girls. The Muslim cleric who leads it, Mian Abdul Malik, stated, “there’s no such thing as forced conversions in Islam and in Pakistan.” Similary, Pir Waliullah Sarhandi, leader of the Sarhandi shrine in the Umerkot district claimed to have converted thousands of Hindu girls and has claimed that, “When a girl is brought before a qazi for conversion to Islam, the qazi must comply immediately. If he delays the conversion even to say his prayers, he himself becomes kafir.” Some organisations, like the Minhaj-ul-Quran, actively encourage the practice of converting members of minority communities by offering rewards for successful conversions. They say that it is the equivalent of Haj-e-Akbari, or the greatest religious duty to Muslims.

The Pakistani media contributes to discourse that encourages the conversion of religious minorities by celebrating conversions without investigating the circumstances. Television programmes, especially Ramadan shows hail converts to Islam by interviewing them and inviting them. Sometimes conversions are televised in religious programmes. While I sympathise with the media industry given the vast amounts of freedom it has historically enjoyed in Pakistan, it has been criminally silent on the issue of forced conversions. English-language newspapers reported only 286 cases of forced conversions between January 2012 and June 2017. Bear in mind the fact that approximately a thousand such cases happen every year. Cases often involve influential religious and local leaders who pressure media organisations to not report cases. Reporters do not investigate forced conversions due to fears of violence being committed against them and their families. A little birdy once told me however, that one of the most important jobs of the media was to hold powerful people to account and inform voters about social and political issues.

It is unfair however to only focus on external media when we have media societies that operate within LUMS itself, especially because the societies and individuals are not as vulnerable to threats of violence as other media organisations and reporters. Search the word “Hindu” on the PLUMS website and you will find six articles. The articles are about the similarities between Pakistan and India, the importance of Jibran Nasir’s electoral campaign, Shia persecution in Pakistan, Basant, Diwali and the Kashmir issue. None of these articles were written by a Hindu student and only one of them (Diwali) puts Hindus at the centre of the conversation. An article not included in this list mentions a request by a Hindu student for a religious room to show why the administration is wrong for removing prayer mats from the Academic Block. This is not to say that PLUMS is an evil organisation, but to point out that our privilege blinds us to the problems of those around us, to the point that sometimes we use their problems to highlight our own or even dare I say, feel good about ourselves. The first step in solving a problem, is recognising there is one and the fact that this can accept and publish criticisms of itself will hopefully help us take that first step. LUMS is a supposedly safe, liberal and diverse space. If we won’t raise these issues here, how can we expect people on the outside to? No Hindu peer has come up to me to request my aid in their attempt at revolution, all they have asked for is for us to inform our families and friends about an issue that nobody wants to report on. There is another print news society in LUMS that I will not mention because I have submitted my article to this paper, but if you’re really interested you can try finding something about this issue on their website as well.

We must do more than going to vigils for minority communities in small numbers. We must hold our political representatives to account for their negligence at best and active involvement at worst. We must push for legislative change and we must push for stringent law enforcement. But above all, we must hear members from minority communities. We must listen to them. And when there are no voices to be heard, we must ask ourselves why? We must seek out those voices instead of expecting those voices to come to us. And when we find these voices, we must give them platforms such that their voices are amplified. There are two demands by members of the Hindu community that I am aware of at the moment: inform yourselves and those around you about this issue and help us get our religious space. Let us fight for these. And to the student who helped me write this: God bless you brother, it takes immense courage and bravery to do what you have done and what you continue to do. Mr. Jibran Nasir spoke powerfully at the vigil, but I find fault in his claim that, “hamara rishta Pakistaniyat ka hai”. This gives too much power to those that get to define who is and is not Pakistani.

Hamara rishta Pakistaniyat ka nahin, insaniyat ka hai.