Campus Reopening: A U-Turn?

Pakistani politicans are not the only ones who take sudden U-turns, thereby decimating the public’s hopes and aspirations. The LUMS administration also meanders down these unforeseen curves, bends and U-turns, as it has become evident through the campus reopening debacle of January 2021. As the student body booked their tickets for Lahore, packed their belongings, and planned for an on-campus academic semester, their hopes were dashed by the administration’s latest email that trickled into their inboxes like some murky, ominous potion.

In the aforementioned email, the student body was regretfully informed that the admin would not be able to accommodate the majority back onto the campus, as per the new government directives which entailed that “in no case shall the total number of students permitted to come to campus exceed 30 per cent of the total enrollment.“ This dealt a significant blow to the student body who had only recently begun to restore their faith in the administration’s intentions and motives. It was also established that those who were previously notified about their imminent return back onto campus would unfortunately have to be turned away. This instigated massive fury, bewilderment and protest from the students who felt like they had been promised mere kernels of false hope by the administration. This email, sent on January 23rd 2021, was in direct contradiction with the cheerful, celebratory email sent on January 8th 2021. The previous emailed brimmed with promises of the campus reopening, ” If allowed, we intend to invite all hostel residents who have been assigned housing to return back to campus by February 1st.  Similarly, all day scholars from Lahore who are able to come back to campus will be welcomed once we have the permission from the government”.

With the university suddenly deciding to take back their decision of calling back additional people on campus, there came financial burdens that some students had to bear. Ones who had booked their tickets in advance were forced to cancel their flights, the costs of which are mostly non-refundable. According to one student who attended the Town Hall, the Vice Chancellor Arshad Ahmed stated that they would compensate students who have faced such costs. He is reported to have said that the university will reimburse the expenses accrued as a result of these travel tickets.

In addition to this, some students had already paid the hostel charges included in their fee as well. Given that the student body was notified so late that the university had no plans to open accommodation to everyone, the question was raised as to how students who had already paid their fees were going to be compensated. Those who had already paid were told to email Residence and inform them if they wish to have their money refunded or adjusted in future fee vouchers, and those who had not were told that their accommodation was to be cancelled and new vouchers are to be uploaded February 2nd.

Speaking of expenses, it is also worth nothing how per credit hour fees were increased without prior notice, as were the hostel charges. The question of how such rises are justified has puzzled students, given the fact that learning is still taking place online, and no additional facilities have been granted to hostelites which would help them understand why the hostel charges have increased. Some students, before the university decided to follow government directives, withdrew accommodation after seeing the high amount which was being charged.

The expenses may even be said to be two fold, firstly, the direct loss of money, and secondly, the emotional cost from steadily losing hope of returning to campus and living a normal university life. The student body expresses sentiments of hurt and confusion amongst deceit. They claim that the admin has not been straightforward with their motives, and has also refused to reconcile matters in a civil manner. The graduating batch of 2021 is especially disheartened by the sudden U-turn, as they consider the possibility of all their senior year plan disintegrating into mere ash.

Time’s Up @LUMS Admin

Earlier this week, hundreds flocked to a Facebook live session hosted by the LUMS admin. The hashtag was enough to spike an interest as clearly, a lot seems to be going on at LUMS. The hashtag was particularly intriguing since it had been making rounds on twitter the past couple weeks, at times making trends reflecting the resounding call of the student body to help address their concerns. In all these instances of the LUMS student body coming together, one thing was evident, the students are desperate to grasp the attention of the LUMS admin, some hailing the admin to care more about its PR than addressing legitimate student concerns. But what is it that is brewing at LUMS? After a cursory attempt at digging into the issue, this is what we found:

Despite most universities opening up throughout the country, the LUMS admin has decided to take the easier route by refusing to open the campus. It was found that only about 200 students will be hosted in Fall 2020-2021. This is a particularly burning issue in the wake of insensitive “welcome back” content making rounds on the LUMS Instagram page, another social media platform that was filled with student pleas against the injustices of the admin.

LUMS had recently been under fire as a result of an undue fee hike, that too in the middle of a pandemic when most people are losing jobs. The admin did a good job of “reverting” the fee hike, instead only to distribute the brunt across younger batches. Things took a turn for the worse when it was revealed that the LUMS admin would continue to take the same amount of fees despite not welcoming student backs. But it gets worse. It was found that the admin has no strategy or willingness to welcome students back on campus and has refused to invest in capacity building measures to at least ensure that students can be welcomed back in Spring.

Citing a deficit in overall finances as the reason to make students pay increasing amounts, a fact negated by the Not-for-Profit institute’s financial statements found online and the reckless spending on fountains and the previous orientation week, that too despite slashing down on student financial aid, is appalling, to say the least. The LUMS admin time and again has refused to address student concerns resulting in undue hostility where students are pressing towards rogue measures, some even citing a potential protest that could be underway.

The students feel that bad PR is probably the only thing that could get the attention of relevant authorities who are currently not even in the country, making insensitive decisions affecting the lives of those who have to deal with the negative consequences of an inadequate infrastructure such as internet connectivity and often home environments not conducive to learning. This is particularly problematic because there has been a significant decrease in the active coronavirus cases within Pakistan, and a recovery rate currently at 98%. But of course, you need to be on the ground and not in countries plagued by increasing deaths and an exponential increase in the number of active cases to be able to make sound decisions. The severe lack of communication seems to be making things worse. LUMS prides itself on the diversity of its student body with students hailing from a host of regions across the country, but they seem to only use that, in addition to the National Outreach Program, as a marketing gimmick to attract students and investors alike. Time is up LUMS admin. Stop playing with the lives of your student body.

#ReopenLUMS.

The Fall Semester in Times of Corona

The year 2020 has brought with it all sorts of unfortunate surprises for the world over. People from all walks of life have suffered greatly, not just in terms of their health, but also in their social, academic and personal lives. The class of 2020, for instance, missed out on what was to be one of the greatest days of their college experience. Four years of hard work feel incomplete without a convocation. However, all those still enrolled in academic institutions are also looking at an uncertain and grim year ahead. With the current situation in the country, the upcoming fall semester is most likely to be online. This sad reality has left many disheartened and has led many others to consider taking a gap year until life goes back to normal.

With eighty thousand plus cases of coronavirus country wide, the future does not look very hopeful. While the government has lifted the lockdown in light of economic factors, academic institutions remain closed. It is still extremely unsafe to go out as the spread of the virus is seen to be accelerating every day. In this situation, opening academic institutions is considered dangerous by most. With similar conditions in the UK, the University of Cambridge has announced its plans for the fall semester. All lectures by the university will be held online. Students will only be allowed to meet up at the campus in very small gatherings, following all precautions to protect themselves from the virus. Similarly, State universities in California have also announced their upcoming quarter to be fully online and have communicated to their international and American students that the priority is staying home and staying safe.

At the same time, some reputed institutions such as the Purdue University in the US have decided to opt for an in-person semester with online alternatives available to all students. The university administration has said that “Covid-19 poses close to zero lethal threat to young people”. However, the administration is keen on taking preventative measures in view of the virus. These measures which, according to the Purdue administration, make it possible to re-open campuses in times of Corona include spreading out classes across days and times to reduce their size, having options for online instruction for on-campus students, requiring people more at risk of the virus to work remotely, and tracing contacts for those who test positive and requiring them to self-quarantine for 14 days.

With the government passing statements such as “the people will have to learn to live with the virus” it is very likely that the measures taken by the University of Purdue are eventually adopted by universities in Pakistan as well. Though, as of now, academic institutions remain closed and most universities are still quite unsure about the possibility of an in-person semester, at least this fall. Universities in Pakistan will have to consider factors such as the unavailability of internet access to most students, if they decide on continuing with an online mode of teaching. On the flip side, however, if campuses are to re-open there must be satisfactory access to medicinal equipment, protective gear and testing kits for all students along with the option to continue studying online if someone is more at risk of being infected.

LUMS is also still debating over the possibility of an on-campus semester. In an unofficial email Dr. Ali Khan, the newly appointed dean of HSS has said that “it is very unlikely that the fall semester will be a face to face one”. This, according to the LUMS administration, is due to the fact that if campus re-opens, containing the virus will become impossible and any sort of spread would lead to closure. However, there is a possibility of “phased openings” that will include allowing students on campus, one batch at a time. It is understandable that the administration, like most universities across the world, is still unsure about how to continue teaching in the fall semester.

Like the university administration, students too are still deciding on whether an online semester is worth it. With the Spring Semester 2020 abruptly changing into an online one, students are not satisfied with their experience. Online teaching has not been able to deliver the same quality of education to students as an on-campus education did. Significant factors such as class participation, class environment, socialization, in-class presentations and group projects are severely compromised in the online mode of teaching. LUMS is known, in Pakistan, for its thriving campus life and it is this aspect that adds value to the LUMS experience. For many, missing out on campus life is too big a sacrifice and hence taking a gap year in hopes of returning back to normal is a better option than continuing with an online semester half-heartedly. Another factor that is to be considered this fall semester, especially for those studying at LUMS, is the extra fee that is expected to be paid despite there being major cut offs in the quality and method of delivering education.

The stance of the government and the response of most universities worldwide gives us an insight into what the upcoming semester will look like for students across Pakistan. The minister for school education in Punjab, Murad Raas, has announced that all private institutions must remain closed till the end of the pandemic. While the All Pakistan Private School Federation has been demanding to reopen schools by following SOPs, the government has warned that any violation of the orders to keep schools closed till the end of the pandemic will result in strict action.

The virus is growing exponentially, with up to four thousand new cases a day. Like most countries, Pakistan is not equipped to handle this outbreak due to a severe shortage of medical supplies and hospital beds. According to many expert epidemiologists, the country is yet to reach the peak of the outbreak. The government has even told the people to prepare for more deaths. In these tragic conditions it does not seem likely, nor does it seem wise, that students will return to normal campus life anytime soon.

 

 

 

 

LUMS Under Fire for Callous Fee Hike

In one highly controversial and shockingly unprecedented move, the LUMS administration has managed to turn the entire student body on its ear. A few days prior, LUMS announced its new fees structure that revealed an astronomical 41% increase in semester charges. This was an action thrust upon an unaware and critically unprepared student body – but most importantly, one that could not have come at a worse time.

As the news spread like wildfire, so did massive panic and distress.

In order to contest this decision, students took to Twitter to fight their campaign under the hashtag #LUMSFeeHike that now has nearly 7,300 tweets by students and assorted supporters.

Moreover, a poll has recently been created among students in order to gauge support for a complete boycott of the summer semester, for which enrollment starts tomorrow. A LUMS student has also written a heartfelt letter of complaint to the administration, published by ProperGaanda. The student describes her parents’ precarious financial situation and the lengths her family is compelled to go to so she can attend LUMS – a university that was already considered expensive by most standards.

In terms of addressing student concerns, administrative bodies have demonstrated a display of acute inadequacy verging on outright dismissiveness.

They claim it is only a step away from the previous “blanket fee” structure that allowed students to pay a uniform amount, within the constraints of a specified credit hours bracket. However, the new policy discards this “blanket fee” allowance: an action which many students are arguing will create a disincentive to take courses outside of their majors due to the exponential cost of doing so.

Moreover, it is no secret that LUMS has a poorly designed, inefficient enrollment system which results in students not getting their courses as they had planned. Out of desperation, many students end up having to opt for twenty credit hours in their junior and senior years to complete their degree on time. The university has made no attempts to subsidize students who have no other option but to enroll in more than 12 credit hours.

Whereas an increase in financial support and aid would have been the empathetic response for such a highly revered institution, students were met with the precise opposite.

This sudden shift towards a credit-based fee structure will also result in increased disparity on campus. Students in better financial circumstances will be able to enroll in sufficient courses to complete their degrees on time while those who cannot afford to do so will suffer greatly and may even have to forego completing their minors along with the option of exploring courses not linked to their degrees.

LUMS’ official statement regarding this issue has dashed any and all hopes the student body harbored that this issue would be cooperatively ironed out. Perhaps most disappointingly, LUMS has declared that this fee hike was planned out prior to the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, in light of the difficulties this crisis has posed, there is a pressing need for the administration to consider revising its pre-set policies. Instead of responding empathetically, LUMS has taken an alternative route.

It is only providing unsatisfactory justifications in a situation which requires an open and honest approach, as well as a concrete plan involving negotiations and concessions.

A few hours ago, there has been an effort via email on part of the Provost and Vice Chancellor to bring some clarity. They are insisting the fee increase is not as exponential as reports claim and will be revised once more later on in the summer. They continue to hold fast to the claim that the new fee structure is actually benefiting students as it allows those with less credit hours to be charged a lesser amount, and also distributes the workload evenly throughout the 4 years. A concession has been offered to senior and super-senior students who wish to take 20 or more than 20 credit hours in their final semesters in order to complete their requirements. In such cases, the extra charges for each credit hour after the obligatory 16 will be waived. However, the issue still persists for the other enrolled batches.

It cannot be forgotten that at a time where the world is virtually on the brink of economic and social collapse, LUMS has only managed to do more harm than good.

With economists constantly warning the virus is likely to lead to a global recession, administrative systems around the world are planning to transform their approaches to business and commerce. Employees in all economic sectors are being laid off. People are unsure of how to make next month’s rent. Everyone is facing tough, wrenching crises that have virtually no path of resolution.

LUMS, however, is an island amidst this chaos. In one fell swoop, it has alienated both itself and the student body, while also creating a deep and burgeoning rift between the two.

Sadly, no amount of concessions can reverse the damage done. There is a loss of trust, and alongside it, ramped up suspicion regarding the university’s motives. The continued insistence that the new policy is not as detrimental as students think is not helping to bridge the divide. Even now, online platforms are teeming with talk of boycotts, formation of student unions, and mass student protests. There is no telling how all this anxiety and sense of betrayal will be ultimately channeled. The student body is determined to stand together and see this through to the end – whichever end that may be.

https://twitter.com/LSCLums/status/1257761692748054528?s=19

Authored by Manaal Shuja & Marium Mazhar

Smog: The Silent Menace

Winter is upon us, and what that unfortunately means is that the sky is going to turn into one large soup of chemicals and dirt. And as much as we like to think of LUMS as a bubble, there is no protection this time. Statistically, things are worse than ever. Lahore is part of the elite company, having one of the worst rates of air pollution in the world. We breathe in air that is considered ‘dangerous’ by EPA standards and that isn’t even the worst part. Smog causes some terrible conditions including but not limited to a bad case of allergies, respiratory problems, skin conditions, and eye infections. With the already distressing finals and tons of assignments coming up, this can set one back further, culminating in a sad state of affairs. For people with chronic conditions such as asthma and COPD, smog can be particularly dangerous, so getting through the winter should be a top priority for us all.

Now, we aren’t going to solve this problem entirely, but we can protect and equip ourselves with some useful weapons against this force of destruction. Here are a few general and specific guidelines to follow:

  1. Avoid the outdoors. Sure, the outdoors can be fun and the weather is nice enough, but it comes at a cost. Just imagine, every time you breathe in the smoggy air, you’re breathing in millions of dust and dirt particles. That usually does the trick. This doesn’t mean you can’t go outdoors. If you feel the absolute need to, a facemask works well. Avoid having a run around midday; that’s when ozone levels are peaking.
  2. Don’t contribute. If we all support the Climate March, then surely we can bring some degree of change to our ultra-consumerist lifestyles. Use public transport for a change (some neat buses are running throughout Lahore). Don’t burn wood or trash in the outdoors, if you’re into that type of stuff.
  3. Stay hydrated. While this isn’t so apparent, hydration does wonders to your blood and acts as a detoxifier against the smoggy air. Plus, being hydrated just feels nice and comforting.
  4. Stop indoor pollution. Place some nice potted rubber plants or lilies in your room. They keep the air fresh and clean. And please don’t smoke indoors.

Also wild fact: If we all were to replace our regular light bulbs with compact fluorescent light bulbs, we would eliminate 136 kilos of carbon dioxide that would otherwise join the atmosphere.

Some amazing books to read – so you don’t have to rush through them for classes!

 

Calling out to all the newbies coming to LUMS, welcome to your freshmen year! I know the zeal and excitement at this time of the vacations is soaring – while some are awaiting their acceptance letters, there are others who are casually beaching away and chilling with a good book or a movie. So for those who want to know more about life at LUMS but are too lazy to go check out the internet, worry not, I’ve got you covered.

Following are some of the books, which are a must-read for honestly every person, no matter what major you’re thinking of pursuing. Some of these have phenomenal plot-lines and have served as guidance for many contemporary best-sellers too. So without further ado,

 

Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad:

This has to be the most widely taught book in classes at LUMS. Be it a class of African Literature, British Fiction, an anthropology class or a history class on colonialism and imperialism – this book will be studied! Personally speaking, even though the book is really good and impactful, it is not for everyone since it contains a lot of nautical jargons and elaborate, dense language. It definitely isn’t my cup of tea, but I wish someone had told me earlier to read it. It would have saved me all the trouble in classes.

So, I highly recommend reading this book beforehand since it will make you familiar with the text and language, making it easier for you to understand it on a second read.

Courses this would be useful for:

  • African Literature
  • Post-colonial history course
  • British/Irish Fiction

 

 

1984 by George Orwell:

Seriously who hasn’t heard of this really creepy, too-good-to-be-true dystopian novel? Required reading for students since it was published, it ranks among the most terrifying novels ever written. Published in 1949, the book offers political satirist George Orwell’s nightmarish vision of a totalitarian, bureaucratic world and one poor stiff’s attempt to find individuality. The brilliance of the novel is Orwell’s prescience of modern life—the ubiquity of television, the distortion of the language—and his ability to construct such a thorough version of hell.

Courses this would be useful in:

  • British/Irish Fiction
  • Socio/History course on totalitarian regimes and politics (mention this book to gain that extra CP point!)

 

 

The Great Gatsby

Yes, you must have seen the famous movie on Netflix with the same name, starring Leonardo Dicaprio as Jay Gatsby; and if you liked the lush setting of the movie (which was truth be told not even close as to what’s described in the text), chances are you’ll love this book! Thanks to its evocative setting, rich themes and masterly prose, The Great Gatsby has secured its standing as a reading-list staple as well as one of the greatest American novels ever written. Here, the moneyed East meets the modest Midwest, and Fitzgerald’s memorable characters — Jay Gatsby, Daisy and Tom Buchanan, Jordan Baker — perpetuate a lavish lifestyle that, alas, doesn’t offer much of a life. The enigmatic Gatsby has the best parties, but it’s Daisy he really wants. He may have no shortage of party guests, but he’s sorely lacking in funeral attendees. A book about loss, longing, identity and the false ideals of American Dream, this book is a must for all introductory level classes.

I know it is really overrated, but it’s better to read and appreciate it at your own pace rather than rush through it in one class. Plus, I can’t say it enough but every-time you read classics, there is always a new perspective that that book has to offer.

Courses this would be useful in:

  • Intro to Literature

 

 

Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte

Here’s the thing about this book: Even if you didn’t like classics you’d probably love this book. It is unique as far as 19th century women fiction goes, but still as relatable today. The language is fairly easy to understand, there is no subtle meaning behind texts (although low-key and very subtly it is screaming feminism feminism!!). It’s a romance, yes, which: extremely normal. But it’s a romance between two characters who are not conventionally beautiful, which is unbelievably rare.

It’s also not a romance or marriage that acts as basically the sole option for its female character. I love Pride & Prejudice, and I think Lizzie Bennet is a feminist (and awesome) character, but there’s no way for that book to end, really, that doesn’t include marriage for her. Three of the five Bennet sisters get married over the course of that book. It either that or the maid status. But not Jane Eyre, here. She does not allow marriage to be the only prospect for her. She goes away and makes a life for herself and then decides whether she wants to follow that path. We don’t even see that in every 21st century romance!

There are other topics also explored like religion, ‘unconventional’ jobs for women (is there really such a thing, even?) and female independence.

Good for you, you’ll be reading this in a few classes this semester (hopefully!) and even if you’re not taking any English courses, I think every woman should read this book atleast.

Classes this will be useful for:

  • Intro to Literature
  • The Victorian Novel: Charles Dickens to Thomas Hardy

 

 

One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

The brilliant, bestselling, landmark novel that tells the story of the Buendia family, and chronicles the irreconcilable conflict between the desire for solitude and the need for love—in rich, imaginative prose that has come to define an entire genre known as “magical realism.”

Lucky for you, there is ACTUALLY a “Magical Realism” course being offered this semester and guess what – this text is required reading!! But even if you’re not one to believe in anything remotely close to ‘real and magic’ (haha, it is quite ironic), this book is one of those which has an unquestionably beautiful prose, painted with exquisite imagery and a timeless plot and characters. The most wonderful thing about this book is, that even though it is about human interactions, lost love and heartbreak (which is very much real), the text is so blissful, it feels heavenly!

I highly recommend reading this book since it will give you a grasp on what Marquez books are all about. It’s possible you may not read this in every class, but you shall always read a Marquez short story in a class or two.

Courses this would be useful for:

  • Magical Realism
  • Word and the World (although you won’t read this book exactly but you will definitely read Marquez)

 

 

Beloved and The Bluest Eye – Toni Morrison

It is no exaggeration to say that Toni Morrison is one of the greatest living literary voices of our time. In every single work published, Morrison has made a point to reveal the complexities of Black lives, whether captured through poetic period pieces, passionate love stories, or shocking dramas. Even if you don’t exactly read this book, I think Toni Morrison is one of those authors whose books you will most definitely read before graduating.

“Beloved” is one of Morrison’s most well-known novel. It tells the story of Sethe, a former slave who escaped to Ohio in the 1870s. But despite her freedom, he finds herself haunted by the trauma of her past. In 1998, there was a film adaptation of the book starring Oprah (I have yet to see the movie though)

Another of Morrison’s book which lands a place on my top 10 favourite books is “The Bluest Eye”. It tells the story of a young black girl named Pecola and her life following the years after The Great Depression. As a black girl, she grew up thinking that there are only one set standards of beauty: fair skin, blonde hair and blue eyes. The story marks her struggles to keep up with her “ugly self” and not only finding her personality and identity through her skin – but also being confident and proud of it. The text is so raw and emotional that once you start reading it, you will be utterly engrossed in the book. The best part is that it is a relatively short book so you can easily finish it within a day or two.

Courses this would be useful for:

  • Magical Realism (again!)
  • African Literature/ Post-colonial Literature
  • Contemporary Short Stories
  • Early 20th Century American Fiction

 

For courses this would be useful for, I have listed the ones that have been offered before and the ones in which I have already studied the said book. Maybe the instructors would choose to tweak the course outline a bit, but one thing’s for sure: these texts will provide you with a sound understanding on good prose, plot and characterization and they are just really good books to read even if you just want to curl up in your bed with a book and tea.

 

Pakistan: A Censored Democracy

*Disclaimer: The views expressed in articles are entirely that of the writer. PLUMS does not necessarily mirror these views.

Censorship and democracy are in their truest selves incompatible. Article 16 and 19 of the constitution of Pakistan unequivocally confer respectively, the freedom of assembly and of speech upon the Pakistani population. One institution that these provisions however, have failed to exert their authority upon is the military. For the entirety of this nation’s 71 years of existence, the venerated, almost holy status of the armed forces has allowed it to dictate, both overtly and covertly, how the country is run.

 

Manzoor Pashteen is a Pashtun man in his late 20s who commands the confidence of thousands that form part of the Pashtun Tahafuz Movement (PTM). The PTM is a very explicitly peaceful organization of protests and rallies against the extra-judicial killings and abductions that the army has become famous for in FATA and Balochistan. Pashteen and his protestors’ fame was short-lived due to a total media blackout of the movement. However, the real crackdown on these demonstrations took place just prior to the PTM’s plan to stage a rally at Mochi Gate in Lahore, when several leaders of the PTM and the Awami Workers’ Party were arrested.

 

Cyril Almeida, a Lahore University of Management Sciences alumnus, has also been targeted for straying away from this narrative of censorship. On the 6th of October 2016, Dawn published the infamous piece that landed him in the trickiest of situations. His article not only implied that the military was in bed with Jihadi Groups, but also intensified tensions between the civilian government and the military. Regardless of what it implies however, the story infuriated the army, which resulted in Almeida being placed on the Exit Control List, barring him from leaving the country.

 

An exciting angle to this discussion may be to analyze what one has to lose in the political arena by being a staunch adversary of the army. Enter the notorious, not sadiq and not ameen, Nawaz Sharif. By trying to claim control over foreign and defense policies, the army’s strongholds, Sharif put one foot out of the door early on. Trying to improve ties with our infamous neighbors and allegedly accusing the army of sheltering terrorist groups obviously didn’t work in his favor either. Come election time and marching comes the army. Rana Iqbal Siraj, a candidate for the legislature in the Punjab Province, running on a Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz ticket claims that the military raided his warehouse, robbing him of his wealth and security. Imran Khan on the contrary, our flamboyant new Prime Minister, being a consistent proponent of the armed forces, won a 114 more seats than he managed to 5 years ago. Well, one may also attribute that to his flowery speeches.

 

The question that lingers still is, how does the military push this narrative of moral untouchability. One explanation for the insidious appeal that militarism carries is the depiction of those who lose their lives in the service of the nation. The commemorative ceremonies where the families of the deceased affirm their support for the military and hence construct themselves and the martyr as driven by a sense of nationalistic duty allow the army to perpetually extract emotions of loyalty and sympathy from the public. The Youm-e-Shuhada (Martyrs’ Day) ceremonies may serve this ulterior purpose. However, as a deliberate consequence of this, a false interchangeability is created between criticizing the military’s interference in the political sphere with disrespecting the foot soldiers that gave their lives in the army’s service. Also in relevance to this, gender is an important tool that the military can exploit to assert its paternalistic governance. In these orchestrated spectacles of grief, the helpless wives and mothers of the deceased are depicted as needing protection from the masculine institution that is the army. Moreover, families that lose their members in war also tend to maintain their friendly relationship with the military and promote the narrative of national sacrifice. This may be explained through a need to justify and attach value to the death that has occurred which transcends the guilt that comes with sending one’s child into the military out of economic desperation.

 

Although the non-coercive instruments of censorship represent only half the picture, they are important to consider in that they are often internalized by the larger part of the population, and hence not recognized. We should hence commit to memory the words of the recently departed, outspoken lawyer and activist, Asma Jahangir who once said; “If the army gets itself involved in politics, fingers will be raised. We will continue to stand against their weapons with pens in our hands and we will not stop raising our voice for the rights of people”.

 

 

 

GETTING THROUGH THE SUMMERS SEMESTER @LUMS: 10 TIPS TO KEEP IN MIND!

The Spring Semester always has a bitter-sweet ending. On one hand, you have the graduating batch, with their sleeves rolled up, ready to step out of the LUMS bubble into the practical world. Arguably it’s not always a very pleasing sight to witness. Scroll down any of your social media accounts, for instance, flooded with utterly sad posts reminiscing on the wonderful yet nostalgic time at the Khoka, regretting every missed Khoka-chilling opportunity available. LUMS is(was) like a home for the graduating seniors and it seems as if the wounds of nostalgia might never heal.

On the contrary, you have another group of people who seem somewhat displeased with spending some additional time at the university! There might not be one single reason to belong to this particular group but usually, individuals enrolling for summer semester make up the largest proportion. As if watching all of their friends leave off for vacations wasn’t enough, the scorching heat of Lahore did much to fester their grievances further.

Talk about walking from the free parking to the classroom amidst 40 degrees mid-day temperature! Perhaps that the time when these individuals feel the guiltiest wondering why they had to force themselves through this misery. Life would have been much easier had they thoroughly followed the handbook guidelines (or not failed a course…….ooops!)

From what seems to be the case: summers at LUMS doesn’t sound much appealing. Blazing Lahori heat coupled with no friends to hang out with is not what most LUMINITES would approve of. But understandable at the same time, when enrolling in a summer semester is the only viable option available for timely graduating.

Having said all of that, there are fortunately ways you can go about to overcome your Summertime Sadness at LUMS. Following these tips perhaps may not make your stay an utterly enjoyable memory, but they will definitely get you through the season.

Here are some essential tips I came up with:

  • Try enrolling in morning courses: Yes, by that I mean 8 AMs! It might seem very arduous to get yourself out of bed but trust me you avoid the unbearable scorching afternoon heat. Early summer mornings are reasonably pleasant, and you can easily walk your way to class.
  • Take a swim at the aquatic center: There can possibly be no better way to beat the summer heat than taking a dip in the swimming pool. Added advantage? You burn an extra number of calories without your clothes drenched in sweat! Try utilizing the morning or afternoon slots to avoid the rush evening hours. Fortunately for your cause, the pool temperature is set around 25C which is perfect for a summer swim.

  • Get to know your peers: The summer semester offers you a great opportunity to interact with other people around you mainly because most are pretty much in the same boat as you are in.
  • Say NO to daytime Khoka chillings: Khoka chillings seem very tempting irrespective of the season, but you have to learn to say NO to your chiller friends (particularly during daytime).
  • Sit somewhere cold: If you really have a compulsive urge to chill with your new friends then look out for a place better than the Khoka. You have student lounge as one viable option, Jammin as another. Or if you are someone like me who loves experiencing the tranquility of the library, then that place too has its doors open.

  • The Summer Essentials: By Summer Essentials, I mean a whole lot of things! Let’s start with your attire. Wear anything as long as you feel comfortable in them. I would personally prefer and recommend Shalwar Kameez, not just because the dress evokes patriotism, but it keeps your body a whole lot cooler. Buy a sunscreen with the right SPF to avoid burns and skin damage. Sunglasses and cap are always a plus!
  • Sleep in the common room: The dorms do not have a personal air conditioner for every room. You can have the air diffusing out of the huge central chiller into your room only if you keep the door open. For a number of reasons, that’s a No! Lock your stuff up, take your mattress and lay down in the common room. There are two air-conditioners installed on the parallel sides of the wall and funnily enough, at times, it gets unbearably chilly
  • Keep yourself hydrated: I can recall numerous instances at LUMS where people have passed out due to severe dehydration. While, it’s hot right now, in a matter of a few months, the weather is going to get utterly humid. Consequently, the humidity will make you sweat a lot. Therefore to replenish your body’s water requirements, it is imperative that you keep yourself hydrated at all times.
  • Schedule a summer trip: If you have been able to successfully fit in with the other summer semester peers, plan out a summer trip to strengthen the friendship bond. Over the course of the season, you will notice numerous trips being arranged to the northern areas of Pakistan. The temperature in these places tends to remain well below 20C. This coupled with splendid natural scenery is a perfect way to relax on the weekend.

And finally

  • Do not forget about the monsoon season: The monsoon rain in Lahore can come out as pretty harsh! The roads often get flooded which becomes a hassle if you are a day-scholar. Additionally, be mindful of any power outage that might result and lead to a complete blackout. Keep an emergency light in your room along with a rechargeable fan. It’s good to have weather updates on your phone so you know exactly when you need to carry an umbrella.

Godspeed, PLUMS! A Farewell Note by the Vice President

Like you, I also feel a social pressure to write something cool, but for a moment, let’s be ourselves. Let’s bravely face our humble, real selves and leave our cool masks on the shelf. We, millennials, associate our identity with  plenty of artefacts; social media, pop culture, Netflix and the stories they tell. We know these distant, detached stories told to us; those that we can only see or hear through a device, but not touch or smell. We know less of our own selves and the immediate surroundings which can be seen, heard, touched, smelt and felt – realities that are more certain than the former. We all carry an urge to be “cosmopolitan middle class individuals through indulging in transnational consumerism of things, ideas, ideologies and cultures”. But imagine that internet or cable networks cease to exist today; then what are you? Who are we? How will we have conversations? The consequences will be horrendous: our Johnny self will become Jamshéd and will fall short of “pickup lines”.

“World will always look for unstable, impulsive, hormone-imbalanced youth to further its propaganda on one hand, and grumpy, old, arrogant lot on the other.”

Our identities depend on these distant stories so much that if they cease to exist, we would be nothing. This is our weakness. We have built the world around us, but there is nothing inside.

پڑھ پڑھ علم  ہزار کتاباں،  کدی اپنے آپ  نوں  پڑھیا  نئیں

جا جا وڑھدا اے مندر مسیتی، کدی من اپنے وچ وڑھیا نئیں

We must link the immediate with the distant. As our sense of reality is dislodged from our immediate surroundings, we are pushed to a conundrum of expectations that inculcate a façade of a “certain” future. But that “future” never happens. You’ll be asked to connect the dots, but the expectations will align them in a way that the line goes in a direction that the “expectors” wish. When we pursue life with a detached sense of reality, we deceive and lie to ourselves about the “is” through “ought”. The world disappoints us each time; and unlike our numb “reality”, these contradictions are felt bitterly through all our senses! As what is, exists independent of what we think is, and we do not run over the bus when we have our arms crossed, the bus still runs over us.

I’ve been believing in something so distant,
as  if  I  was human!

I’ve been denying this feeling of hopelessness,
in  me;  in  me!

So much in this world, ultimately, tends to move from instability to stability. Perhaps that explains our need for certainty and meaning. But to reach the highest level of certainty, we need to conjoin all our senses to know, than relying on only seeing and hearing through devices. We are only exposed to the ‘distant’; detached from the ‘immediate’. We are an unstable generation plagued with a weaker sense of certainty than our ancestors. Perhaps this is the “instability” that reflects as mental illnesses, among other reasons?

I have built this as a foundation to encourage you towards “originality”, and “being yourself” in your creative projects, which you must understand in terms of eliminating the problem I have  put  forth.  We  are  a society, a community that has a common goal: writing. All our departments work together to produce this end, learning manifold skills in the process. As I see a promising future of this newspaper, it is imperative  that we preclude this ‘millennial problem’ of detached reality, disconnected from our immediate surroundings, in our writings. Let’s link the distant to the immediate. Right now, for instance, we are students at a university. What being a “student at LUMS” means, is for us to define; not just the administration or faculty; not Google; not Instagram, not JSTOR and certainly not Netflix.

کوئ  دور  رہ  کے  قریب  ہے

کوئ قریب رہ کے بھی دور ہے

Should we be “critical”? A popular concern found in the students’ culture these days, is of “thinking out of the box”. What we don’t realise is that when we go out of the box, we jump into another box and stay there. Should we, then, keep jumping through the boxes persistently to facilitate inquiry? I never really understood that. If you wish to “deconstruct”, you find yourself in Jacques Derrida’s box—you may choose to stay there, perhaps because it’s a “French” box.  But following the earlier logic, no matter how much we jump, we are tempted to make a box around us; of certainty; of stability; and stay there even when it starts corrupting with contradictions. And do you see, we have the audacity to see this world in a “horse shoe”? If we realise our surprising abilities, no horse shoe will be able to theorise us.

If we believe that there are no absolute right or wrong – or no “box” – we will still be tempted to generalize our personal right and wrong to the world. Maintaining a façade of acceptance of others’ values counts to nothing if, by practice, we still move towards the absolute in many respects. Just because we say or believe that we are not, does not change the practical reality and its consequences. Isn’t that we are tolerant in being, tolerant in sayings, but intolerant in doings? Though we have grown apparently elastic in it, we still compete to be the demagogue.

As this society is relieved from resource dependencies, you will witness this newspaper leaning towards such direction, which will be an existential threat. I already see certain factions running after it like wild hounds. There is apparently a consensus among the academics that being completely value neutral is impossible. For a person, I find it true to a vast extent, but not for the institutions. For a newspaper that hosts a constellation of persons, using this consensus to justify propaganda is precarious; it can compromise free speech, result in compelled speech and a lack of diversity. You will see dominance of one narrative and exclusion of others. The contrarians will be discouraged to write or enter the society altogether. The newspaper will attract a label and facilitate cult formations on either sides, which is a catastrophe. We don’t want to see an “Intellectual Dark Web”, do we? Cults are, by definition, exclusive; when you make one cult, four more cults will be formed around you. Would you wish such a campus?

I declare this society open for all kinds of students—Northerners and Southerners alike, brand schoolers and non-brand schoolers alike—if they can think originally and be themselves. For how long can we hide behind an arbitrary grandiose of city, or a brand name of a social engineering factory? We are someone else too, without association to these jewels; someone more than a market niche. We must not be eager to replicate the tyranny of the world inside the campus. The world outside is, but a huge ego-sizing contest. In reality, their ego is the same; it is the gazing of the shadows that misguides them. Thus, those who are farther from the light, see  bigger shadows of their egos, and those who are closer, know their place and that of humanity very well. I encourage you to be the latter, and not the former.

The media in the world too, is accused of showing a distorted reality to facilitate narratives. They have to, but we dont. As I depart, I recommend the Editorial Board of PLUMS to maintain as much value neutrality in the editorial policies as it is possible, and to avoid implicit and explicit association with any ideology or narrative that must govern all writers. As I stated earlier, we will be tempted to turn populist, towards any side of the spectrum. But the highest level of maturity is when we strictly observe that what we are tempted to do is not always what we should do. Though it generally happens in the world outside, it is not best for us students. We are here to learn acceptance of differences, not activism and propaganda; the former is harder to learn; the latter is, or soon will be, instilled in us by the logic of the world anyway; as we let it.

Another reason why I deplore propaganda through the newspaper and its unapologetic affiliation with a narrative is to keep us students from being used. We get used by the things we don’t know how to use. We don’t control the narratives that we are a mouthpiece of, someone else does; who doesn’t love us as much as we begin to. How does religious fundamentalism use us, tapping into our beliefs, which they don’t themselves respect? How does right capitalism use us, taking advantage of our greed, avarice and vanity; feeding us theories of individual agents, then treating us as collective? And how does neo-Marxism and postmodernism use us, capitalizing on the “millennial weaknesses” these days? Karl Marx or Karl Mask? Taking a moral high-ground in the comfort of the blanket about the complicated world (immediate reality) that we never interacted with! Have we read a book called the world? What we say, remains in our throat, as we say so to be sublime characters, online or otherwise. It was all a meaningless hashtagging and posting, until they said it can change the world, and we adopted it impulsively to get meaning, stability and certainty in what we were habitual of doing meaninglessly. Can it really change the world? We were never critical of its premises, as what the world is and which direction of “change” it must follow, are not questions devoid of narratives, shortcomings and interests. The list above is not exhaustive or literal, be imaginative! We are in a world of defenseless lawyers and diseased doctors. All in all, we are not the end for them all, but a means to an end unknown to us.

Some cover their propaganda under cunning “rationality”, others facilitate demagoguery by a façade of compassion and piety. Serving humanity in saying, could be feeding our vanity in doing. They are a “public consent” away from a vulgar dictatorship that they had been hiding all along. Seemingly benign, inherently sinister!

Faking compassion for politics, rather; harms the very regime of it, by making the public skeptical of its discourse whenever it is signaled—failing to distinguish the fake from the genuine. Let the postmodernists disagree.

ہے علم جسے ہو حاجتِ  اندازِ بیان، محض رعب
پاک علم ہو گرچہ سادہ، کرے شعلہ بیان زدوکوب

Yet another choice is edginess, but that too is meaninglessly endless. You get edgy, edgier, edgiest and then what? You “walk over the edge”?

Though I am a big fan of feminists, as they say “men are trash”, I rather contend; why are they so lenient? How about the whole world is trash? Why is there a food-chain? We complain about the game theory, but why are the
resources scarce? Isn’t water running out, in our immediate reality? What will we do? If the world is this trash, does that imply we must adjust and be trashy ourselves? Or that we must manage to make it less trashy? How do we do it? Resource allocation? Modernization? Eliminating grand narratives? Revivalism? Hedonism? World abnegation? Self-purification? Which is the best answer? No one is sure. Façade of certainty! We are all internally scared and insecure; and we hide this behind the veil of vanity. Some get to shout and hurl through a pedestal; others get to sit with a European leg-cross at an NGO’s event. Their sayings are not doings, and doings are not what they speak of; their thinkings are not feelings, and feelings are not for what they think; their beings are not what they are, and what they are, they don’t want to be! They are distant, and all alike. They will bring us nothing, but make us become like them. You’ll be swimming through life somewhere, but your heart will float elsewhere; the heaviest of its pieces will be drowned, others will go here and there.

حق نوں آکھ کہ ہک کرے

ترا    ٹوٹا    پھوٹا     دل 

But the world will always look for unstable, impulsive, hormone-imbalanced youth to further its propaganda on one hand, and grumpy, old, arrogant lot on the other. We must spare ourselves from this game, at least as long as we are in the university or in the learning stage – or in a hormonal imbalance, for that matter.

Growing up is not a choice, but a necessity, for if we act like a pre-pubescent kid, the world will treat us like one; that treatment will less resemble that of our parents and more so of pedophiles. We would never know when, where and how were we ripped off.

Yet I’m militantly against pessimism, though I know that my words reek of it. But it only reeks to those who have learned to be governed by it; I have conjured all optimism in my Urdu poetry; those who cannot read it, missed out on it.

ٹھانی تھی دل میں اس نے اک آرزوۓ عروج

کہ  کردار   باکمال   ہو ،  شجاع   خوب  خوب

کروں  میں کچھ ایسا  کہ عالم حیراں   ہوجاۓ

ٹالوں  میں  وہ  بلا،   کسے  ٹالی  نہیں  کبھو

ملے  اسے    جلال  و  اضطراب  و  استطاع

مگر    بلا   نہ   آئ ،   بلا    ٹالتا    وہ   کیا

جب  کام  ہی  نہ  تھا    تو  کامیاب   کیا  ہوتا

نہ  تھا کوئ  فرعون  تو  موسیٰ وہ  کیا  ہوتا

جانا، کہ   مصیبت  بھی   ہے  اک نعمت  خدا

مانا،  کہ  اہم ہیں   یہ  فتن ، فِسق  اور زبوں

نہیں  ہے  دنیاۓ عفریت و عزازیل بلا  مقصد

دجال   نہ    فضول،   نہ   یاجوج  وَ ماجوج

The only acceptable activism is one that originates from yourself; from your immediate reality, that is: you are a student at a university—which is just one shallow instance. What concerns do you face being a student? Ask yourself! Would you not speak of non-profits shifting from social service provision to a mere donation collection; from “altruism” to “greed”? Do you see your peers implicitly excluding NOP scholars and then rant on LDF about mutual acceptance? Do you  recognize imposters amongst you, who talk of feminism, tolerance and piety, but do the opposite? But first sweap your own house, as the most immediate is, yourself. For us, it is less terrible, as this is our age of making mistakes; though it’s over for those who sit in offices. It is when you are aware of the immediate reality first, you are good to talk about the distant matters, while maintaining a link. And for that, you do not need to follow an ideology or a school of thought. No PhD knows more than you, what being a student at this university today feels like. You own this domain. You have the right and legitimacy to speak out through the platforms that PLUMS provides. Lastly, be critical, but not in the manner described earlier.

Words never erupt out of a newspaper to grab anyone’s collars. I have no right to obligate you to listen, nor have you, to constrain me to explain. As through this, I do not seek the limelight; I never wanted to be noticed. But I humbly put these words out, so the consequences that are not consistent with them, are off my shoulders. Mera Ranjhan hun Koi Hor!

If Harvard Crimson can last more than a century, this newspaper can last as long as LUMS itself, and it will (IA). With this hope, I bid farewell, both, as the Vice President of PLUMS (EC’19) and as a student at LUMS. Khuda Hafiz!

 

 

 

YLES 13th Edition Report

The following report highlights key fact and relevant information regarding the 13th edition of the Young Leaders’ and Entrepreneurs’ Summit

  • Dates: 23rd December – 27th December (5-day event)
  • Held right after the final exams (one of the biggest challenges for this year was to prepare for the summit during the dead week and final exams)
  • Introduced a new delegation system where participants were not divided as ‘head delegates’ and ‘delegates’, but rather were assigned the following roles at time of registration:
    • Managing Director
    • Finance Director
    • Marketing Director
    • Operations Director
    • Communications Director
      • This system inculcated a sense of responsibility within the delegates and also ensured equal participation across a team as a different round put varying levels of responsibility on different position holders

The theme for this year was ‘be inspired’ – the logic behind this was to portray that one must have some source of inspiration before they can venture out onto their entrepreneurial journey. Each delegate was also given the following card to note down their goals and important learning points over the course of YLES:

A new format was introduced for the networking night – firstly there was a panel talk in the academic block courtyard, led by Hina Rabbani Khar and Ahmed Khan (founder and CEO of cheetay). Secondly, there was a networking session in the academic block courtyards where panels of 4-5 mentors (comprising of CEO’s and industry experts) were placed in each aud and participants were divided amongst the auds to go to their respective panel and receive feedback on their business idea (that they will be using for their idea junction round). This was very well received by both the mentors and the students – who received valuable feedback on their ideas.

Present at the networking night was also our Official Incubator Partner – ID 92, which is another milestone for us. Not only did ID 92 set up a stall at our networking night and provide delegates with feedback but they also provided us with CEO’s and industry experts to judge the final round of Idea Junction. Currently ID92 is in contact with the top 3 position holders in the idea junction round to offer them potential incubation as part of our partnership this year. This was a big deal for us as the ultimate purpose of an entrepreneurial competition is to provide exposure and support to the business ideas being presented at it. The Co-founder of ID 92, Nabeel Qadeer also gave a presentation at our opening ceremony where he talked about the entrepreneurship ecosystem in Pakistan.

  • YLES this year also had an official app, which was used for the following purposes:
    • Navigating across LUMS (and posting the venues for rounds)
    • Posting scores
    • Advertising sponsors
    • Assigning internal duties
  • The YLES host team ramped up its academic prowess by writing original case studies, all in all we wrote the following cases and rounds:
    • 5 cases on failing brands for the round Brand Rush
    • 12 cases on companies that face Public Relations crisis, for the round Plug It In
    • A market entry case on Starbucks for the round Strategic Business Management
    • A case on a hypothetical airline for the final round of Strategic Business Management
    • An extensive storyline based on a hypothetical country along with profiles of 10 different companies for the first round of Investomania *more on this later
    • A set of news updates for Investomania Round 2
    • 8 cases, adapted from those provided by Seed Out, for the first round of Social Enterprise
    • 3 cases for the final round of Social Enterprise

Investomania Round 1: A new concept was introduced for investomania Round 1 where a stock market simulation was created in a hypothetical country. This was done in person in the free parking where we had set up 10 stock broker booths and a news centre. The news Centre comprised of 2 SMD Screens where news updates were posted at regular intervals along with price updates. There were a total of 10 companies and the finance director from each company could approach any of the stockbrokers to buy/sell/trade shares. The Entech Project of LES created an entire ‘stockbroker’ application to allow transactions to be carried out in real time. This entire project and concept took over 5 months to develop and shows the devotion of the host team to enhance the quality of the rounds at YLES.

Investomania Round 2: This round built on the concept introduced last year and created a trading game where the finalists had to trade the following commodities in real time: oil, wheat and rice. Each team was given a PC in trade lab where they had to play the game on a java interface created by the Entech Project of LES. This was again a standalone application created just for this round.

  • 25th December: Christimas Carnival – a first of its kind social event held in LUMS. The Christmas night was held in the REDC lawn and it was a fun time with a lot of music, dance, and Christmas décor!
  • 26th December: Concert – YLES brought strings to LUMS for the 2nd time and it was perhaps the highlight of the entire event
  • Bilal Bin Saqib was the speaker for the closing ceremony and he talked about entrepreneurship and his start up Tayyabah
  • The Marketing and Corporate Relations Department of LES set a new record this year for the highest amount of sponsorship ever brought by a society
  • For the first time ever, YLES had international delegates – a total of 15 international students from Nepal and Afghanistan. Thus, growing our image internationally!
  • As part of our social outreach program we had to SOP teams compete at YLES this year for free. These students belong to schools from underprivileged areas and were provided mentorship throughout the event. For the first time ever, an SOP team won one of the winning prizes as they placed third in the Investomania Round