Jaabirana Rajneeti

by Taha Iqbal

“We have taken this decision as a family. A new era has begun,” Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi proclaimed in an address to the nation on August 8, 2019. It is not lost on me that families are extremely important to the vast majority of South Asians. But, maybe sometimes irrelevant family members should shut up and allow individual members to make decisions about matters that affect them the most.

On Monday, August 5, 2019, Minister of Home Affairs and President of the Bharatiya Janata Party Amit Shah informed parliament that President Ram Nath Kovind had signed a decree effectively abolishing articles 35 A and 370 of the constitution. Article 370 allowed India’s only Muslim majority state to make its own laws in all matters except for communications, defence, finance and foreign affairs. Jammu and Kashmir was legally exempt from the Indian constitution. As a result, the state was able to establish a separate constitution and flag. Crucially, it enabled the Kashmiri government to deny property rights to outsiders. Article 35 A can be understood as an extension of Article 370. It allowed the state legislature to define permanent residents of Jammu and Kashmir. In doing so, the local legislature was given the authority to forbid outsiders from permanently settling, buying land, holding local government jobs or winning education scholarships in the region. Furthermore, female residents (and their future children) were barred from property rights if they married individuals from outside the state. In short, both these constitutional provisions allowed Kashmiris to decide how they wanted to govern themselves and enabled them to prevent demographic change that would compromise their ability to actualise the former. The Lok Sabha also passed the Jammu and Kashmir (Reorganisation) Bill, 2019 with 370 votes in favour and 70 against it. The Jammu and Kashmir state will now be divided into two “union territories” directly ruled by New Delhi. The Jammu and Kashmir union territory will include the Hindu-majority Jammu region and will have a legislative assembly. The Buddhist-majority Ladakh region, which has a considerable population of Shia Muslims, will also be a union territory, but without the privilege of its own assembly.

Before Monday’s decision, prominent Kashmiri leaders were jailed or put under house arrest. Reuters reports have put the number of arrested at approximately 500. Internet and communication services along with cable networks were also shut down in anticipation of widespread unrest. An additional 38,000 troops were deployed in the region. Reports suggest that Indian law enforcement used tear gas and pellet guns to disperse a crowd of 10,000 protesters that had gathered in the state capital of Srinagar. One can write a book on how Kashmiris are caught up between the interests of different states that are unwilling to hear what they have to say. However, amidst the overblown ultra-nationalistic and at times jingoistic responses to the new status quo from either side of the border, there is an urgent need to examine the justifications given by the Indian government for the steps taken and the more obvious reasons for why this was done. The Bharatiya Janata Party led government coalition claims that articles 370 and 35A have resulted in Kashmir becoming a breeding ground for separatism, nepotism and corruption. All of this has led to Kashmir being left behind the nation in terms of development.

Our general assumptions about the state largely fall in line with this government argument. In the popular imagination, Kashmir largely resembles a less intense war zone with regular occurrences of spontaneous or planned violence. The only difference between the imaginaries of populations across the border seems to be about which actor is responsible for the violence: the Indian military or Pakistani supported terrorist militias. However, dear reader, you might be surprised about how developed Jammu and Kashmir actually is. According to census data, the state’s poverty rate stood at 10.35% in 2011-12 compared to the national average of 22%. Bihar, Assam, Uttarakhand, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra and Gujarat (where Mr. Modi hails from) all had poverty rates higher than Jammu and Kashmir’s. Per capita income in the region is also higher than that of Bihar, Assam and Madhya Pradesh. The state does even better in terms of social indicators. Life expectancy in Kashmir is 73.5 years while the national average is 68.7 years. Kashmir does better than all of the states mentioned earlier in this category. The infant mortality rate in Kashmir is also significantly lower than the national average and is lower than the states mentioned bar Maharashtra. 8.7% of women between the ages of 20 and 24 years were married before the age of 18 years, compared to the national average of 26.8%, according to data from the National Family Health Survey IV. In Bihar, this figure was 42.5%, and in Gujarat 24.9%, data shows. Mr. Amit Shah also alleged in his speech that Kashmiri children were being denied an education because of the state legislature’s decision to not accept the Right to Education Act. However, he failed to mention that children in the state are provided free and compulsory education until Class 8. The gross enrolment ratio in senior secondary schools is also higher than the national average. Jammu and Kashmir has 23 colleges per 100,000 residents which is much better than Bihar’s 7 and Assam’s 14.

Mr. Shah is correct about two things though. The state does have a high government debt burden and fares poorly in attracting private investment. However, both of these are a consequence of the security situation in the region. The state has to borrow capital from the central government because of its huge security expenditure. Private investors are also weary of entering a market that is plagued with violence-induced uncertainties. What is apparent at this point, however, is that Kashmir is not necessarily underdeveloped and even the areas in which it is lagging behind have nothing to do with Article 370 and Article 35A of the constitution. So, what about separatism then? There are many reasons for why separatist tendencies exist in the Kashmiri population. The first and most obvious one, is oppression at the hands of the Indian state. According to Mr. Modi himself, 42000 people have died in the last 3 decades due to violence alone. There are reports of illegal detention, torture and rape at the hands of security forces. I won’t explore this issue further because of precisely how well documented this is. What is relevant is that members of the population resort to violence against the state because of the actions of the state and the unwillingness of the state to change its behaviour and hold criminals operating within it accountable. Pakistani support for violent groups is also a reason for why members of the population become terrorists. Pakistani patronage gives violent dissidents access to resources that they otherwise would not have had. Notice however, that not only do both these broad reasons have nothing to do with both articles of the constitution, they will only be exacerbated further in response to the Indian government’s actions. With most of their political leaders in some form of state-mandated confinement and a crackdown on media, communication services and any form of peaceful organisation, the separatist sentiment in Kashmir will only get worse. This will also increase pressure on the Pakistani government to do something, given how important Kashmir is to Pakistani identity and therefore the Pakistani population and may lead to further support being given to these groups if the states current attempts at taking the issue up at international forums fails.

Why would the Modi government do this then? Jammu and Kashmir has been a focal point for Hindu nationalism ever since Partition. While Jinnah and the Muslim League considered that being a Muslim-majority state it should have been part of Pakistan and that Partition would remain unachieved so long as the whole of Kashmir remained under Indian rule, for the Hindu nationalists the state was inseparably a part of India. The transfer of one more state to Pakistan would make it stronger and India weaker. The Bharatiya Janata Party has a history of opposition to Article 370. In 1953, Syama Prasad Mukherjee, died in a jail in Srinagar where he was detained by the Sheikh Abdullah government for protesting against Kashmir being an autonomous republic within India. A year before his death, Mukherjee was the president of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh – the predecessor of the present day Bharatiya Janata Party. He saw it as a threat to national unity and famously proclaimed, “Ek desh mein do Vidhan, do Pradhan aur Do Nishan nahi challenge.” There is a strong element of territoriality within the ideology of Hindu nationalism and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. Hindutva is not only based on ethno-religious categories but also on the belief that India occupies a sacred land whose frontiers matter as much as religion and language. Hence the demand for Akhand Bharat (complete, undivided India), which emerged in the 1950s and which implied that Partition should be undone to restore the natural extension of the sacred land that is Bharat. Such measures inevitably allow the BJP to secure its more hard-line electoral base. These actions will also appease party activists and politicians who lean towards the extreme right. Splitting Jammu and Kashmir into two union territories can be viewed as a unique attempt at gerrymandering to prove electoral outcomes for the BJP. We would be remiss however to exclusively focus on the Hindu right wing as has been the case with most coverage on the issue. Commentators have pointed out that this may also be an attempt by the BJP to divert criticism from India’s lack lustre economic performance. India’s economic growth cooled sharply in the first three months of this year. Gross domestic product increased 5.8 per cent from the same quarter the previous year, down from the 6.6 per cent growth rate recorded in the last quarter of the 2018 calendar year. The Indian economy also faces three huge problems: an ever-increasing population, deteriorating infrastructure and public sector corruption. Therefore, economic growth does not necessarily translate into a better quality of life for the vast majority of Indians. Triggering controversy in Kashmir takes media and public focus away from this difficult conversation and enables the BJP to dominate positive headlines. And yes, most headlines are positive. Comparing the Indian media to the work of Pewdiepie would be a disgrace to Pewdiepie (although he too has given shout outs to fascist organisations). There is also a crackdown on dissenting voices. The founders of NDTV, a channel that has been quite critical of the Modi government were prevented from leaving the country because of a “money-laundering” case. Videos published by the BBC have been called “fake news” by elected officials. As a result, most Indians are currently accessing news that portrays this as a move that was long overdue and will be in the national interest.

We must remember that Kashmiris are the primary stakeholders in this situation. They have been historically discriminated against and oppressed. They have not consented to Article 35A and Article 370 being revoked. They have been denied access to information, which is a fundamental right in any democracy. They have been stripped off their right to protest against this decision by a government that is framing its actions as necessary for the prosperity of these people. What has happened to Kashmiris historically and what is happening to them currently is unjustifiable. No actor has cared about their dignity as human beings, has respected their autonomy or stood up for their right to self-determination. We should all be outraged by what is happening in Kashmir. But we must also remain cognisant of our own shortcomings. Because there are parts in Pakistan where citizens disappear never to be seen again. There are elected representatives of vulnerable communities who have been jailed for simply trying to make things better. There are criminals amongst those responsible for protecting all of us who have not been held responsible for their actions. We must criticise the actions of oppressors, but we must also introspect, lest we have our own version of Kashmir soon.

 

 

 

Pakistan: A Censored Democracy

*Disclaimer: The views expressed in articles are entirely that of the writer. PLUMS does not necessarily mirror these views.

Censorship and democracy are in their truest selves incompatible. Article 16 and 19 of the constitution of Pakistan unequivocally confer respectively, the freedom of assembly and of speech upon the Pakistani population. One institution that these provisions however, have failed to exert their authority upon is the military. For the entirety of this nation’s 71 years of existence, the venerated, almost holy status of the armed forces has allowed it to dictate, both overtly and covertly, how the country is run.

 

Manzoor Pashteen is a Pashtun man in his late 20s who commands the confidence of thousands that form part of the Pashtun Tahafuz Movement (PTM). The PTM is a very explicitly peaceful organization of protests and rallies against the extra-judicial killings and abductions that the army has become famous for in FATA and Balochistan. Pashteen and his protestors’ fame was short-lived due to a total media blackout of the movement. However, the real crackdown on these demonstrations took place just prior to the PTM’s plan to stage a rally at Mochi Gate in Lahore, when several leaders of the PTM and the Awami Workers’ Party were arrested.

 

Cyril Almeida, a Lahore University of Management Sciences alumnus, has also been targeted for straying away from this narrative of censorship. On the 6th of October 2016, Dawn published the infamous piece that landed him in the trickiest of situations. His article not only implied that the military was in bed with Jihadi Groups, but also intensified tensions between the civilian government and the military. Regardless of what it implies however, the story infuriated the army, which resulted in Almeida being placed on the Exit Control List, barring him from leaving the country.

 

An exciting angle to this discussion may be to analyze what one has to lose in the political arena by being a staunch adversary of the army. Enter the notorious, not sadiq and not ameen, Nawaz Sharif. By trying to claim control over foreign and defense policies, the army’s strongholds, Sharif put one foot out of the door early on. Trying to improve ties with our infamous neighbors and allegedly accusing the army of sheltering terrorist groups obviously didn’t work in his favor either. Come election time and marching comes the army. Rana Iqbal Siraj, a candidate for the legislature in the Punjab Province, running on a Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz ticket claims that the military raided his warehouse, robbing him of his wealth and security. Imran Khan on the contrary, our flamboyant new Prime Minister, being a consistent proponent of the armed forces, won a 114 more seats than he managed to 5 years ago. Well, one may also attribute that to his flowery speeches.

 

The question that lingers still is, how does the military push this narrative of moral untouchability. One explanation for the insidious appeal that militarism carries is the depiction of those who lose their lives in the service of the nation. The commemorative ceremonies where the families of the deceased affirm their support for the military and hence construct themselves and the martyr as driven by a sense of nationalistic duty allow the army to perpetually extract emotions of loyalty and sympathy from the public. The Youm-e-Shuhada (Martyrs’ Day) ceremonies may serve this ulterior purpose. However, as a deliberate consequence of this, a false interchangeability is created between criticizing the military’s interference in the political sphere with disrespecting the foot soldiers that gave their lives in the army’s service. Also in relevance to this, gender is an important tool that the military can exploit to assert its paternalistic governance. In these orchestrated spectacles of grief, the helpless wives and mothers of the deceased are depicted as needing protection from the masculine institution that is the army. Moreover, families that lose their members in war also tend to maintain their friendly relationship with the military and promote the narrative of national sacrifice. This may be explained through a need to justify and attach value to the death that has occurred which transcends the guilt that comes with sending one’s child into the military out of economic desperation.

 

Although the non-coercive instruments of censorship represent only half the picture, they are important to consider in that they are often internalized by the larger part of the population, and hence not recognized. We should hence commit to memory the words of the recently departed, outspoken lawyer and activist, Asma Jahangir who once said; “If the army gets itself involved in politics, fingers will be raised. We will continue to stand against their weapons with pens in our hands and we will not stop raising our voice for the rights of people”.

 

 

 

Godspeed, PLUMS! A Farewell Note by the Vice President

Like you, I also feel a social pressure to write something cool, but for a moment, let’s be ourselves. Let’s bravely face our humble, real selves and leave our cool masks on the shelf. We, millennials, associate our identity with  plenty of artefacts; social media, pop culture, Netflix and the stories they tell. We know these distant, detached stories told to us; those that we can only see or hear through a device, but not touch or smell. We know less of our own selves and the immediate surroundings which can be seen, heard, touched, smelt and felt – realities that are more certain than the former. We all carry an urge to be “cosmopolitan middle class individuals through indulging in transnational consumerism of things, ideas, ideologies and cultures”. But imagine that internet or cable networks cease to exist today; then what are you? Who are we? How will we have conversations? The consequences will be horrendous: our Johnny self will become Jamshéd and will fall short of “pickup lines”.

“World will always look for unstable, impulsive, hormone-imbalanced youth to further its propaganda on one hand, and grumpy, old, arrogant lot on the other.”

Our identities depend on these distant stories so much that if they cease to exist, we would be nothing. This is our weakness. We have built the world around us, but there is nothing inside.

پڑھ پڑھ علم  ہزار کتاباں،  کدی اپنے آپ  نوں  پڑھیا  نئیں

جا جا وڑھدا اے مندر مسیتی، کدی من اپنے وچ وڑھیا نئیں

We must link the immediate with the distant. As our sense of reality is dislodged from our immediate surroundings, we are pushed to a conundrum of expectations that inculcate a façade of a “certain” future. But that “future” never happens. You’ll be asked to connect the dots, but the expectations will align them in a way that the line goes in a direction that the “expectors” wish. When we pursue life with a detached sense of reality, we deceive and lie to ourselves about the “is” through “ought”. The world disappoints us each time; and unlike our numb “reality”, these contradictions are felt bitterly through all our senses! As what is, exists independent of what we think is, and we do not run over the bus when we have our arms crossed, the bus still runs over us.

I’ve been believing in something so distant,
as  if  I  was human!

I’ve been denying this feeling of hopelessness,
in  me;  in  me!

So much in this world, ultimately, tends to move from instability to stability. Perhaps that explains our need for certainty and meaning. But to reach the highest level of certainty, we need to conjoin all our senses to know, than relying on only seeing and hearing through devices. We are only exposed to the ‘distant’; detached from the ‘immediate’. We are an unstable generation plagued with a weaker sense of certainty than our ancestors. Perhaps this is the “instability” that reflects as mental illnesses, among other reasons?

I have built this as a foundation to encourage you towards “originality”, and “being yourself” in your creative projects, which you must understand in terms of eliminating the problem I have  put  forth.  We  are  a society, a community that has a common goal: writing. All our departments work together to produce this end, learning manifold skills in the process. As I see a promising future of this newspaper, it is imperative  that we preclude this ‘millennial problem’ of detached reality, disconnected from our immediate surroundings, in our writings. Let’s link the distant to the immediate. Right now, for instance, we are students at a university. What being a “student at LUMS” means, is for us to define; not just the administration or faculty; not Google; not Instagram, not JSTOR and certainly not Netflix.

کوئ  دور  رہ  کے  قریب  ہے

کوئ قریب رہ کے بھی دور ہے

Should we be “critical”? A popular concern found in the students’ culture these days, is of “thinking out of the box”. What we don’t realise is that when we go out of the box, we jump into another box and stay there. Should we, then, keep jumping through the boxes persistently to facilitate inquiry? I never really understood that. If you wish to “deconstruct”, you find yourself in Jacques Derrida’s box—you may choose to stay there, perhaps because it’s a “French” box.  But following the earlier logic, no matter how much we jump, we are tempted to make a box around us; of certainty; of stability; and stay there even when it starts corrupting with contradictions. And do you see, we have the audacity to see this world in a “horse shoe”? If we realise our surprising abilities, no horse shoe will be able to theorise us.

If we believe that there are no absolute right or wrong – or no “box” – we will still be tempted to generalize our personal right and wrong to the world. Maintaining a façade of acceptance of others’ values counts to nothing if, by practice, we still move towards the absolute in many respects. Just because we say or believe that we are not, does not change the practical reality and its consequences. Isn’t that we are tolerant in being, tolerant in sayings, but intolerant in doings? Though we have grown apparently elastic in it, we still compete to be the demagogue.

As this society is relieved from resource dependencies, you will witness this newspaper leaning towards such direction, which will be an existential threat. I already see certain factions running after it like wild hounds. There is apparently a consensus among the academics that being completely value neutral is impossible. For a person, I find it true to a vast extent, but not for the institutions. For a newspaper that hosts a constellation of persons, using this consensus to justify propaganda is precarious; it can compromise free speech, result in compelled speech and a lack of diversity. You will see dominance of one narrative and exclusion of others. The contrarians will be discouraged to write or enter the society altogether. The newspaper will attract a label and facilitate cult formations on either sides, which is a catastrophe. We don’t want to see an “Intellectual Dark Web”, do we? Cults are, by definition, exclusive; when you make one cult, four more cults will be formed around you. Would you wish such a campus?

I declare this society open for all kinds of students—Northerners and Southerners alike, brand schoolers and non-brand schoolers alike—if they can think originally and be themselves. For how long can we hide behind an arbitrary grandiose of city, or a brand name of a social engineering factory? We are someone else too, without association to these jewels; someone more than a market niche. We must not be eager to replicate the tyranny of the world inside the campus. The world outside is, but a huge ego-sizing contest. In reality, their ego is the same; it is the gazing of the shadows that misguides them. Thus, those who are farther from the light, see  bigger shadows of their egos, and those who are closer, know their place and that of humanity very well. I encourage you to be the latter, and not the former.

The media in the world too, is accused of showing a distorted reality to facilitate narratives. They have to, but we dont. As I depart, I recommend the Editorial Board of PLUMS to maintain as much value neutrality in the editorial policies as it is possible, and to avoid implicit and explicit association with any ideology or narrative that must govern all writers. As I stated earlier, we will be tempted to turn populist, towards any side of the spectrum. But the highest level of maturity is when we strictly observe that what we are tempted to do is not always what we should do. Though it generally happens in the world outside, it is not best for us students. We are here to learn acceptance of differences, not activism and propaganda; the former is harder to learn; the latter is, or soon will be, instilled in us by the logic of the world anyway; as we let it.

Another reason why I deplore propaganda through the newspaper and its unapologetic affiliation with a narrative is to keep us students from being used. We get used by the things we don’t know how to use. We don’t control the narratives that we are a mouthpiece of, someone else does; who doesn’t love us as much as we begin to. How does religious fundamentalism use us, tapping into our beliefs, which they don’t themselves respect? How does right capitalism use us, taking advantage of our greed, avarice and vanity; feeding us theories of individual agents, then treating us as collective? And how does neo-Marxism and postmodernism use us, capitalizing on the “millennial weaknesses” these days? Karl Marx or Karl Mask? Taking a moral high-ground in the comfort of the blanket about the complicated world (immediate reality) that we never interacted with! Have we read a book called the world? What we say, remains in our throat, as we say so to be sublime characters, online or otherwise. It was all a meaningless hashtagging and posting, until they said it can change the world, and we adopted it impulsively to get meaning, stability and certainty in what we were habitual of doing meaninglessly. Can it really change the world? We were never critical of its premises, as what the world is and which direction of “change” it must follow, are not questions devoid of narratives, shortcomings and interests. The list above is not exhaustive or literal, be imaginative! We are in a world of defenseless lawyers and diseased doctors. All in all, we are not the end for them all, but a means to an end unknown to us.

Some cover their propaganda under cunning “rationality”, others facilitate demagoguery by a façade of compassion and piety. Serving humanity in saying, could be feeding our vanity in doing. They are a “public consent” away from a vulgar dictatorship that they had been hiding all along. Seemingly benign, inherently sinister!

Faking compassion for politics, rather; harms the very regime of it, by making the public skeptical of its discourse whenever it is signaled—failing to distinguish the fake from the genuine. Let the postmodernists disagree.

ہے علم جسے ہو حاجتِ  اندازِ بیان، محض رعب
پاک علم ہو گرچہ سادہ، کرے شعلہ بیان زدوکوب

Yet another choice is edginess, but that too is meaninglessly endless. You get edgy, edgier, edgiest and then what? You “walk over the edge”?

Though I am a big fan of feminists, as they say “men are trash”, I rather contend; why are they so lenient? How about the whole world is trash? Why is there a food-chain? We complain about the game theory, but why are the
resources scarce? Isn’t water running out, in our immediate reality? What will we do? If the world is this trash, does that imply we must adjust and be trashy ourselves? Or that we must manage to make it less trashy? How do we do it? Resource allocation? Modernization? Eliminating grand narratives? Revivalism? Hedonism? World abnegation? Self-purification? Which is the best answer? No one is sure. Façade of certainty! We are all internally scared and insecure; and we hide this behind the veil of vanity. Some get to shout and hurl through a pedestal; others get to sit with a European leg-cross at an NGO’s event. Their sayings are not doings, and doings are not what they speak of; their thinkings are not feelings, and feelings are not for what they think; their beings are not what they are, and what they are, they don’t want to be! They are distant, and all alike. They will bring us nothing, but make us become like them. You’ll be swimming through life somewhere, but your heart will float elsewhere; the heaviest of its pieces will be drowned, others will go here and there.

حق نوں آکھ کہ ہک کرے

ترا    ٹوٹا    پھوٹا     دل 

But the world will always look for unstable, impulsive, hormone-imbalanced youth to further its propaganda on one hand, and grumpy, old, arrogant lot on the other. We must spare ourselves from this game, at least as long as we are in the university or in the learning stage – or in a hormonal imbalance, for that matter.

Growing up is not a choice, but a necessity, for if we act like a pre-pubescent kid, the world will treat us like one; that treatment will less resemble that of our parents and more so of pedophiles. We would never know when, where and how were we ripped off.

Yet I’m militantly against pessimism, though I know that my words reek of it. But it only reeks to those who have learned to be governed by it; I have conjured all optimism in my Urdu poetry; those who cannot read it, missed out on it.

ٹھانی تھی دل میں اس نے اک آرزوۓ عروج

کہ  کردار   باکمال   ہو ،  شجاع   خوب  خوب

کروں  میں کچھ ایسا  کہ عالم حیراں   ہوجاۓ

ٹالوں  میں  وہ  بلا،   کسے  ٹالی  نہیں  کبھو

ملے  اسے    جلال  و  اضطراب  و  استطاع

مگر    بلا   نہ   آئ ،   بلا    ٹالتا    وہ   کیا

جب  کام  ہی  نہ  تھا    تو  کامیاب   کیا  ہوتا

نہ  تھا کوئ  فرعون  تو  موسیٰ وہ  کیا  ہوتا

جانا، کہ   مصیبت  بھی   ہے  اک نعمت  خدا

مانا،  کہ  اہم ہیں   یہ  فتن ، فِسق  اور زبوں

نہیں  ہے  دنیاۓ عفریت و عزازیل بلا  مقصد

دجال   نہ    فضول،   نہ   یاجوج  وَ ماجوج

The only acceptable activism is one that originates from yourself; from your immediate reality, that is: you are a student at a university—which is just one shallow instance. What concerns do you face being a student? Ask yourself! Would you not speak of non-profits shifting from social service provision to a mere donation collection; from “altruism” to “greed”? Do you see your peers implicitly excluding NOP scholars and then rant on LDF about mutual acceptance? Do you  recognize imposters amongst you, who talk of feminism, tolerance and piety, but do the opposite? But first sweap your own house, as the most immediate is, yourself. For us, it is less terrible, as this is our age of making mistakes; though it’s over for those who sit in offices. It is when you are aware of the immediate reality first, you are good to talk about the distant matters, while maintaining a link. And for that, you do not need to follow an ideology or a school of thought. No PhD knows more than you, what being a student at this university today feels like. You own this domain. You have the right and legitimacy to speak out through the platforms that PLUMS provides. Lastly, be critical, but not in the manner described earlier.

Words never erupt out of a newspaper to grab anyone’s collars. I have no right to obligate you to listen, nor have you, to constrain me to explain. As through this, I do not seek the limelight; I never wanted to be noticed. But I humbly put these words out, so the consequences that are not consistent with them, are off my shoulders. Mera Ranjhan hun Koi Hor!

If Harvard Crimson can last more than a century, this newspaper can last as long as LUMS itself, and it will (IA). With this hope, I bid farewell, both, as the Vice President of PLUMS (EC’19) and as a student at LUMS. Khuda Hafiz!

 

 

 

Pakistan’s Freedom Struggle: The Promised Dawn is Yet to Come

یہ داغ داغ اجالا یہ شب گزیدہ سحر

وہ انتظار تھا جس کا یہ وہ سحر تو نہیں

یہ وہ سحر تو نہیں جس کی آرزو لے کر

چلے تھے یار کے مل جاۓ گی کہیں نہ کہیں

On a cold winter night, despite security threats, student activists gather on the streets of Lahore to protest yet another abduction of a fellow Baloch activist. He was young, ambitious, zealous. He was fighting for the rights of his people, for human rights. Like many others, he was picked up by unidentifiable men. Like many others, they did not know if he would return. So they did what they could. They demanded from the state responsible for protecting these rights.

Faiz Ahmad Faiz had warned us decades ago of the disillusionment of 1947’s ‘triumph’. Pakistanis had acquired some freedom but there was still a long way to go.

Almost seventy years later, we still have a long way to go.

For Pakistan, one of the largest obstacles to freedom are enforced disappearances, with no external force posing this threat and perpetrators and victims both belonging to the country.

Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK) suffer prominently in this terrorizing system of repression. Witnesses of these disappearances described them as often occurring in the night when unknown men enter target homes and pick up family members they deem problematic. Many cases have even occurred in broad daylight. Parents have lost their young children, siblings have been estranged and wives left widowed. The loved ones left behind in the wake of this terror spend their remaining lives chasing an unattainable justice; from the police station to the Supreme Court, they knock every door for some reprieve. Stranger phone calls sometimes give them dishonest reassurances of their loved ones returning. The false hope worsens the anguish of the families, especially when their beloved turns up in a dumped bag, or as part of a mass grave or simply never turns up. Those who do return, as one Baloch said, “don’t remember who they are, much less their families. The torture they endure erase their identities”.

Disappearances originated with the Balochs’ political movements after 1971, which demanded political, economic and social rights. Rich in natural resources that provide for Pakistan and beyond, Balochistan is the largest and least developed province of the country. Poor living conditions prevail, with 46.6 percent of Baloch households having no electricity and 59% of Balochistan without natural gas, its main energy source. Economic exploitation and little provincial autonomy aggravate the situation. Corruption in development projects add to Baloch grievances. Continued ignorance and suppression of legitimate demands has led to unrest and even outright insurgencies in the past four decades.

The Pashtuns have a similar story. Many have been picked up and killed as part of a policy to curb the region’s militant threat, such as that from the Taliban. Naqibullah Mehsub was one such Pakhtoon who lost his life in the cross-fire of Karachi Authorities’ militancy resistance. The widely publicized case led to the “Pashtun Long March” where thousands protested for the protection of ethnic rights. The march soon grew into a nation-wide protest called the Pashtun Tahafuz Movement. Throngs of people, united by their collective pain, came out on the streets to demands reparations from the state.

Enforced disappearances are no longer a Baloch or Pakhtun problem, they are a Pakistani problem, with people now being abducted from all provinces. The terrifying reality of the ‘others’ is now our reality. That there is something beyond provincial politics here is evident when protesters are made up in large numbers of the more vulnerable groups in society; women, children and senior citizens. What drives these people out of the safety of their homes and into the streets is the reality of their lives – that their homes are no longer safe. They know the terror has reached there. How long will it take us to realize that it has reached our homes, too?

The situation is aggravated by the mass media’s restricted reporting of the daily repression these people face. State censorship is largely but not solely responsible. Ejaz Haider, a prominent Pakistani journaslist, describes the constraints local journalists face in this case, “if you are not taking sides, reporting in certain cases can be very tricky. Take, for example, Balochistan. Journalists there have to deal with the state’s sensitivities as well as threats from Baloch terror groups. A half-hour conversation in the Quetta press club with reporters brings this reality into sharp salience. It was the same for journalists in the erstwhile tribal areas when most of those administrative units were controlled partially or fully by Taliban groups. Traversing such a landscape is like walking through a minefield”.

There are indeed violent actors amidst the protesters but they constitute a fragment of the larger movement. Meanwhile, the state’s oppressive response to these violent elements is indiscriminate. The human tragedy that occurs as a consequence is now part of everyday life in Balochistan and KPK. One year later, Mehsud’s murderer, Police Superintendent Rao Anwar, still roams free. Thousands of Pashtuns are still gathering on the streets in protest. If the state continues to respond militarily to a political problem, we may see costs as grave as those incurred in 1971.

What could we possibly do about this? Baloch and Pakhtun student activists are not very different from us. They engage in activities and share interests similar to ours. However, they described life as that of constant threat because of their struggle for the protection of Pakistanis. According to them, the least we can do is to become informed and help make others aware. Information is available despite the limitations. Speaking with activists and using the internet for reliable sources are ways to educate ourselves. Human Rights Watch devised a report in 2011. Sources cited in this article are also a good starting point. We must begin speaking up. We must prove false that “in Pakistan, preservation counts for more than compassion”.

Millions envisioned the dawn of a free Pakistan in 1947. Perhaps with our collective struggle we will one day witness that promised dawn.

ابھی چراغ سر رہ کو کچھ خبر ہی نہیں

ابھی گرانیٔ شب میں کمی نہیں آئی

نجات دیدہ و دل کی گھڑی نہیں آئی

 چلے چلو کہ وہ منزل ابھی نہیں آئی

Politics In Verse: Inquilab Zindabad

The subcontinent, both pre and post partition, has never been without the public’s political discontent as can be made evident by a look through its history of mutinies, martial law, and disobedience movements. Discontent, moreover, is a phenomena easily romanticized, especially with its enticing allure upon the subordinate as well as the adolescent segments of a society. Poetry, therefore, principally that which has political subtexts, has never found itself wanting of inspiration in this part of the world. The fame of poets including Nazeer Akbarabadi, Khwaja Mir Dard, Bahadur Shah Zafar, and of those more contemporary including Habib Jalib and Faiz Ahmed Faiz is indicative of this perpetual inspiration.

Ben Learner, in his book, “The Hatred of Poetry”, portrays “contempt” as inseparable from the success of poetry. However, he does not attribute to poetry the potential to aggravate change. Similarly, many would argue that the form is merely a peripheral influencer of the consensus, an apolitical concept, and the importance given to it is reflective of both elitist sentiments and naïve intuition.

The writings of Faiz Ahmed Faiz, an Indo-Pakistani leftist poet however, stand for exactly what this critique of poetry denies. As an answer to Zia’s repressive usurpation of power, the poet created one of his most powerful works, ‘Hum Dekhain Gey”. With Faiz imprisoned, bootleg cassette tapes with recordings of a performance of this work by Iqbal Bano in her controversial black sari were smuggled throughout the country. A particular interpretation of his verses attributes to Zia, the great sin of associating himself with God, and hence his words aim to awake the consciences of the suppressed classes and do away with the prevalent mirage of amity.

It is a theory that the intimacy associated with a scrutinized reading of poetry is a materialization of the elitism it inherently emerges from. It suggests that as a poet must discover his audience, the reader must also identify a poet that he or she resonates with the most. To put it bluntly, poetry has its own niche, not suited to the masses, rather to a distinct type of individual who retrieves from the poetry a mutuality of ‘frequency’. As it happens, the distinct type referred to often alludes to the affluent.

Habib Jalib, however, another Indo-Pakistani poet, born in East Punjab, may indeed be, in the words of the aforementioned Faiz, “ the poet of the masses”. He wrote in a straightforward language, encompassing the plights of the working class. When Bhutto’s policies diverged from the essentially socialist manifesto of the PPP, Jalib took notice and spoke against the government in support of the Pakistanis who suffered at the hands of this divergence. He was jailed for what was not his first term in prison at the hands of a ruler uncompromising and unwilling to face opposition.

Passivity and apathy describe the level of animation of the Pakistani citizenry and are extremely uncharacteristic adjectives for Iqbal’s poetry, verses to which we owe the inspiration of the Pakistan Movement. If poetry is really food for the soul then it is poetry which must extend the promise of revolution to Pakistanis that must become hungry for their liberation. After 71 long years of coups, corruption charges, and media blackouts, poets such as Jalib and Faiz should be recognized for their tenacity and resolve when it came to sketching for the public, the moral destination that Pakistan has to progress to. They created visionary works accessible to more than just the crème de la crème of Pakistan, works unstained by naivety.

Come, gather your possessions,

O people with injured hearts.

Come, O Friends,

Let us go and get killed.

Bhutto’s legacy in hot waters

https://www.facebook.com/lumspublications/posts/2014496772005172

The financial scandal following the JIT report has found the Zardari family along with the PPP and Sindh Government to be in hot waters. With the undertakings by the current federal government under the regime of Imran Khan has seen a renowned party in Punjab go through the charges posed on them. Therefore, it comes with no doubt that the fate of PPP will suffer if not same, but pretty relevant consequences alleged as far as the JIT report is concerned.

The money-laundering case as per the report has definitely thrown a turmoil in the Sindh government and a political storm seems inevitable as for now. However, the most tarnishing point following this scandal is the political future of Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, which hangs by a weak thread, in addition to the fate of the former president.

This has, in turn, kept the followers in fear that their last hope to carry on the Bhutto legacy might be lost in the scandal. Although always under the political shadow of his shrewd father, Bilawal has made a significant impact on parliamentary politics. But his involvement in this financial scandal could adversely affect his politics.  For the charges imposed are indeed critical and would result in a prolonged legal and political battle which would restrain Pakistan People’s Party’s political participation and its progress in general.

While these allegations might be imposed and the unruly statements by Federal Information Minister Fawad Chaudhry, who referred to Sindh being run by ‘goons’ may seem to reflect the Sindh government being overthrown. It is not really that easy to manipulate or destabilize the provincial government. For this in itself would be disastrous for the system, especially at a time when it is faced with economic and political challenges. Politics of confrontation is not an option at the moment.

Coming to the other side of the picture, the role of the federal government, PTI is a stark contrast to their slogan for the sacredness of vote. These allegations and dethroning are not entirely due to the incompetence or corruption charges against the Sindh government but are also in the will to establish a one-party system. And PTI has become a key player in this game, continuously reminding us of such previous attempts in the 1990s, where the governments were installed or removed overnight.

Nevertheless, the political dynamics of the province have changed owing to PTI becoming the second largest party in the province in addition to its electoral victory in Karachi. This along with a strong financial background has given PPP a tough challenge in its own province and has led to a politics that might end up marring the province in the end.

As of now, there is no need to create intimidation or any power syndrome. As this will only ensure a strong uno or a weak center. The sense of national integration at this point is of utmost importance and so is the separation of the accountability process with that of the politics. However, the government’s actions only act to reinforce angsts; they need to find a way to cure the political tension and instability.

 

71 Years Later

“I want you to keep your heads up as citizens of a free and independent sovereign State. Praise your Government when it deserves. Criticize your Government fearlessly when it deserves, but do not go on all the time attacking, indulging in destructive criticism, taking delight in running down the Ministry or the officials.”

Quaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah’s reply to a welcome address at Edwardes College, Peshawar on 18th April 1948.

“Quaid Ka Pakistan” is a term we hear more than often, but only to say that we we are far from being near to it. It is unfortunate that Pakistan is 71 years old but it has not been able to become the land that the Quaid envisaged. Not long after the birth of the state of Pakistan on 14th August 1947, it found itself grappling with issues of war, security, infrastructure, economy, water and princely states; the most concerning being Kashmir. To top it all was weak administration and leadership, and on 16th December 1971, Dhaka fell and East Pakistan became Bangladesh. A dark day in Pakistani history, it was marred with bloodshed, violence and rape. Series of military coups and unstable tenures followed and the nation became accustomed to seeing an impairing of democracy and feeling vulnerable, betrayed and sad. However, such a past cannot be an excuse as to why we as a nation have become so angry and cynical. We have indulged ourselves in the blame game for quite some years, and so now we should acknowledge our own weaknesses and ponder over how much we have tried to be close to Quaid’s Pakistan.

Sitting governments of democratic countries all over the world are at a disadvantage of incumbency. However, in nascent democracies such as Pakistan, where democracies have not had the chance to fully develop and create democratic traditions, it becomes easier for those in power to sway the masses. Factors such as inequality, extreme poverty and illiteracy also contribute to the acceptance of oppression by the majority. Weak democracy allows opposition to disparage the sitting government to the extent of creating political instability. In Pakistan, intense anti-government campaign is a by-product of every general election and is practiced for all the remaining tenure; all for one’s own greed for political power. Politicians’ refusal to learn from previous mistakes and put aside personal motives has not only disrupted socio-economic progress but also risked national security.

In Pakistan, politics is a bureaucratically managed affair. It has failed to rid itself of social cleavages such as gender, class, ethnicity, religion, race and creed. Organs of popular will and collective action are vilified and demonized. Student unions and trade unions are banned, and media is censored. Politics is not an open and active sphere. The masses are unable to hold their destiny in their own hands because the reins of power are controlled by a small portion of elite who works to strengthen the long established power structure and entrenched status quo. As a result, people feel skeptically alienated, and from that stems cynicism.

Cynicism is an attitude or state of mind characterized by a general distrust of others’ motives. Political cynicism results from unfulfilled expectations regarding politics or government, which create feelings of disillusionment and betrayal. In Pakistan, cynicism has become the dominant ideology of response. However, it is a dangerous disciplinary mechanism because it leads to political helplessness and withdrawal. It is a deplorable characteristic that our tragic past has given us. We have lost all pride and faith, and how cliché it may sound, but we have forgotten the sacrifices our forefathers gave to achieve this independent land that we can call home.

We need to learn to maintain the balance. Being grateful to be born into an independent country without having to face the gruesome partition of 1947 is one thing, and feeling upset about all the wrongs and speaking up against them is another, and both of them are equally important. If we relinquish the former, we are left with pessimism and cynicism. Living in today’s Pakistan, we should be grateful but not content. We should never stop asking. Above all, we should not forget that the only anti-dote of cynicism is hope, and when we are presented with the slightest ray of hope, we should hold on to it with unity and positivity. Our government officials are corrupt and deceitful and so our criticism is natural. But when they take a step that is for the good of the people, they should be praised. Unsubstantiated defamation and personal attacks should be avoided.

As Muhammad Ali Jinnah said, we should own up to our land in complete totality, and it is only after doing so, that we can criticize. Once there is renewed sense of belonging and vigorous passion for the betterment of our country, we will find it easier to draw the line between criticism and cynicism. We should start from ourselves, and from our homes. From small things like not littering on the roads to putting an end to the ridiculous culture of “maids and ayas are not allowed beyond this point”, we should make an effort in bringing the change that we talk about while sitting in air conditioned rooms as maid girls serve chai and biscuits to us, or that which we type out on our expensive gadgets which we got as a present for clearing an exam; not to forget that sitting in that exam was also a privilege that only few enjoy in this country. We abuse our politicians for being dishonest but the next minute, we lie to someone on the phone by saying that we are out of city, or that we have caught a severe viral cold, and we manage to escape work. We deplore the expensive and classist lifestyle of our leaders, but we do not care, let alone pity, on our maid who fails to show up one day because her son fell sick, and since her husband was probably drunk with his friends, she could not leave him alone. There are numerous examples of when we can prove to be different than those we blame, but the harsh reality is that we all misuse our power in our own capacity. More so than anything else, if our politicians are so devoid of honesty and integrity, why do we elect them? We should understand and acknowledge both our weaknesses and our strengths, and work on eliminating the former while capitalizing on the latter, for a better and stronger Pakistan- Quaid’s Pakistan.

Why Jibran Nasir’s campaign is important for all of us

The day after the attack on APS Peshawar, Jibran Nasir and four others held a candlelight vigil in front of Lal Masjid, Islamabad, protesting against then-chief cleric Abdul Aziz for refusing to condemn the massacre. After Mr. Nasir proliferated the campaign on social media, the number of people drawn to the premise rapidly increased. Soon, a sizeable number of demonstrators were found camping in the blistering cold outside of Islamabad’s oldest mosque, calling out Abdul Aziz for his statement and Taliban apologists in general. They belonged to various segments of society, including politicians, activists, students, and ordinary citizens. Eventually, an FIR was registered against Mr. Aziz for threatening the protesters. More significantly, perhaps, Lal Masjid’s deputy khatib and other clerics joined the protesters in condemning the Peshawar attack.

This incident illustrates a key feature of Mr. Nasir’s campaign – grassroots advocacy. He has frequently used approaches involving community-based education and collective action of the ordinary citizens to challenge the status quo, addressing a number of social issues. Many of these, including marginalization of Ahmadiyya, women empowerment, and rights of religious and ethnic minorities, tend to be avoided by most politicians seeking the support of more conservative and right-wing voters. Nevertheless, Mr. Nasir has repeatedly refused to compromise on his outlook to attract more voters from this base, leading few to question his integrity.

Altering the status quo in Pakistan is a notion strongly entwined with Mr. Nasir’s campaign, and is evident in his other ventures. As a lawyer, for example, he is a part of the counsel for Khadija Siddiqui, for the father of Naqeebullah Mehsud, and against Shahrukh Jatoi. Likewise, in a recent, widely reported incident, Mr. Nasir was arrested and allegedly beaten for refusing to give way to a judge’s protocol, citing ‘VIP culture.’ This stand has culminated into a strong base of support. To many, he is essentially a candidate representing greater involvement of the middle class and a stronger voice for the marginalized groups in society.

NA-247 is a highly competitive constituency this year, with MQM leader Farooq Sattar, PSP’s Fauzia Kasuri, PTI stalwart Dr. Arif Alvi, and Mr. Nasir all campaigning for a seat in the National Assembly. The constituency encompasses Defence Housing Authority, Clifton Cantonment, Saddar and Civil Lines, and part of the old city, Kharadar, cutting across socio-economic classes. The residents report facing a multitude of concerns, including a water shortage, improper sanitation, inadequate education for underprivileged children, and for the Christians and Hindus, few, if any, public places of worship.

There is no questioning that each candidate has a strong understanding of the political and socio-economic dynamics of the issues present in this constituency. Nor can it be reasonably denied that each has a resolve and manifesto to solve or mitigate said issues. However, it is not enough to meet these challenges without integrating the marginalization and neglect, in varying structures, of many of the citizens of the constituency. Innovation and development can no longer come from building upon the political, social, and economic reform for specific citizens, but at least raising the standard for all. Unless the underlying hindrances, the status quo being a part, are not committed to being overcome, no development is adequately progressive.
Though this may be understood by all party candidates, experienced politicians that they are, they are essentially limited in taking action by their party’s policies and perspectives. Take Imran Khan’s recent undermining of feminism and religious minorities, or MQM’s history of political instability. Or the fact that, again, few politicians go against the status quo. The less likely they are to change it, ultimately. Given that Mr. Nasir has already been heading in a different direction, the importance of this will be the deciding factor in a vote for him.

The candidate has risen to prominence following the Lal Masjid protest, with his work gaining greater attention. His endorsement by a number of celebrities, as well his policies, which have appealed most significantly to both leftists and moderates, have made him a serious opponent for his fellow candidates in this year’s elections.
While Jibran Nasir may, as an elected candidate, be unable to carry forward several of his resolutions, that is not the rationale behind his campaign or the support for it. Few serve to represent and enhance the progressive movement in Pakistan, on the national legislature. Grassroots campaigning will primarily be a step in the direction of reforming the social constructs that establish the status quo.

Puranay Masail Naya Pakistan

Now that the results of the General Elections are officially in, and it is clear that the Imran Khan-led Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), along with its allies, is going to form the government in the Center, Punjab, and KPK, people are waiting for the promise of change to materialize. It took Khan many years to get to the point where he is today. He has made big promises to the public regarding reforms in almost every area of governance including economy, health, education, police, judiciary, environment, trade and foreign policy. However, the fact of the matter is that the incoming prime minister isn’t going to have an easy time managing these things. The new government will face a lot of challenges.

The most important and severe of these challenges is the economic crisis. We are running an $18 billion Current Account Deficit (CAD), which means that we are losing $1.5 billion a month. This year’s CAD is 45 percent higher than last the year. The new government will have to rollover Rs 4 trillion worth of outstanding rupee debt over the following three-to-four months. Never in Pakistan’s history have we ever had a Rs2.2 trillion budgetary deficit. Given the magnitude of these numbers, Pakistan has to go to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for another bailout package – the 13th for the country since the 1980s. A recent report by IMF says that Pakistan’s external financing needs are expected to rise from $21.5 billion (7.1% of the GDP) in 2017 to $45 billion by 2023 (9% of GDP).

Another ordeal for the new government is the power shortfall. Lower power generation, because of less hydro-electric contribution and some state-owned power plants going off the grid due to faults, combined with a hot and humid weather and perennial line losses, have pushed the electricity shortfall up to 8,000MW. This has forced power distribution companies to observe around six hours of load shedding in urban areas, and over eight hours in rural areas across the country. According to the federal secretary of Water and Power Ministry, the situation worsened after some of its old power plants faced forced outages due to technical faults that these plants develop from time to time. This has caused a reduction in generation from 1,500MW to 1,800MW on average. Meanwhile, the maximum filling of Mangla reservoir, which normally completes by July or early August, didn’t happen, thus keeping generation restricted to 5,100MW.

Apart from these, another big task is managing the foreign policy, especially Pakistan’s relations with the US, Afghanistan, India, China, and Saudi Arabia. According to foreign policy analyst Moeed Yousuf, Khan’s victory wasn’t Washington’s preferred option. Much of what is said and thought of him is tied to his disparaging stance on the US war in Afghanistan and his sympathetic views towards the Afghan Taliban. Several columns written on him in the Western press since the elections have also tended to highlight his personal negatives. In this situation, handling the relationship with the US and being a mediator between Iran and Saudi Arab isn’t going to be easy for the incoming PM.

Other than this, ensuring accountability and ending corruption will also be a hard nut to crack. For this, the government has to empower institutions like NAB, FBR, FIA, and the police among others. Khan has vowed to make Pakistan a welfare state along the lines of Scandinavian countries. But given the country’s meager resources and the population explosion, this transformation will require bold and unpopular decisions, like wide-scale tax reforms, to actualize the promise of a welfare state.

Climate change is another frontier for the next government to fight on. On May 28, 2017, the temperature in Turbat, Baluchistan reached 53.5°C — an all-time high for the country and the world’s highest temperature for May — while the summer monsoon rainfall in the country was 22.5pc less than the long-term average. Acute shortage of freshwater, rising temperatures, shifting rain patterns, high risk of floods as well as droughts can affect millions and necessitate urgent action.

In addition, the education and healthcare systems are also in shambles. There is under-staffing and lack of proper training for the staff. It will require a lot of planning and effort to bring reforms in these sectors and make these services affordable for the public, while raising their standards. Another major issue is the management of civil-military relations which have not been so good in recent years. Khan will have a tough time dealing with the powerful military and its role in other areas including the foreign policy. Last but not the least, all these challenges come with a strong opposition comprising a multi-party alliance which is demanding a probe into alleged poll rigging. The new government does not have a simple majority and it can face trouble while taking unpopular decisions and carrying out reformist legislation. Khan will have to prove that he is different; a true reformer, political risk taker, bold, and as determined to change Pakistan as he has been in confronting the two political dynasties. Will he succeed? Only time will tell.

 

 

The writer is a student of BS Political Science at LUMS, Class of 2021.

Imran khan’s first speech as the PM

Twenty six years after winning Pakistan’s first and only cricket World Cup, twenty four years after building country’s largest Cancer hospital and ten years after founding Namal College, Imran Khan sat down a wooden chair with paper in his hand at his Bani Gala residence. It was a delightful day in Islamabad; PTI had clean sweaped the Federal Capital and Rawalpindi. PTI won from Lyari and nine zero in Karachi after winning a simple majority in KP.

Just like a jeweler puts pearls in a string, one after another to end up with a magnificent necklace, IK hopped from one issue to another ever so smoothly, to describe his vision for Pakistan. There was continuity, as if the words he was uttering didn’t require any thinking. It felt so natural and melodic. The pauses, the word stress, the highs and lows were perfect to milliseconds. He spoke from the heart. For a moment the whole nation was just happy to see such an eloquent person as their Prime Minister.

Eloquence is one thing, content is another. In his speech, Imran touched all the key issues facing Pakistan. And the values that the founding fathers had envisioned for this country.

For decades, Balochistan has suffered from oppression, poverty and terrorism. Pakistan finally got a Prime Minister who started his victory speech by remembering the brave people of this province. In an era, where the Muslim world looks perplexed in its own history and ideology, he reminded us of the Meccan welfare state. Pakistan finally got a PM who spoke openly for half of the population that lives below poverty line, a PM who emphasized on education, health and human development, a PM who emphasized on accountability and social justice. Pakistan finally has a Prime Minister, who has conveyed in his very first speech to the World that Pakistan wants peace. He extended a hand of friendship to India and talked about the real deal (Kashmir). A Prime Minister, who instead of falling in one camp, carefully balanced himself between Iran and Saudi Arabia while proposing a mutually beneficial relation with the US.

Earlier, he had started his speech by mentioning his twenty two year long journey from absolutely nowhere to the corridors of PM house; maybe he had been preparing this speech for twenty two years. How can someone so aptly squeeze the cure for seventy years of blunders in just one speech? Clearly, there is a vision, a purpose and most importantly a direction. Nations rise and nations fall, but too often they just need the right man at the right time with the right vision. Ata Turk, Jinnah, Mandela and the list goes on. Whether, Khan will make it to that illustrious list, we shall know soon. This speech will be remembered for a long time as a speech that gave hope to the nation in a hopeless time. Imran Khan has made it clear that this government will be rule of the common man; it will stand with the weak and hold everyone accountable of their actions.