Jaabirana Rajneeti

by Taha Iqbal

“We have taken this decision as a family. A new era has begun,” Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi proclaimed in an address to the nation on August 8, 2019. It is not lost on me that families are extremely important to the vast majority of South Asians. But, maybe sometimes irrelevant family members should shut up and allow individual members to make decisions about matters that affect them the most.

On Monday, August 5, 2019, Minister of Home Affairs and President of the Bharatiya Janata Party Amit Shah informed parliament that President Ram Nath Kovind had signed a decree effectively abolishing articles 35 A and 370 of the constitution. Article 370 allowed India’s only Muslim majority state to make its own laws in all matters except for communications, defence, finance and foreign affairs. Jammu and Kashmir was legally exempt from the Indian constitution. As a result, the state was able to establish a separate constitution and flag. Crucially, it enabled the Kashmiri government to deny property rights to outsiders. Article 35 A can be understood as an extension of Article 370. It allowed the state legislature to define permanent residents of Jammu and Kashmir. In doing so, the local legislature was given the authority to forbid outsiders from permanently settling, buying land, holding local government jobs or winning education scholarships in the region. Furthermore, female residents (and their future children) were barred from property rights if they married individuals from outside the state. In short, both these constitutional provisions allowed Kashmiris to decide how they wanted to govern themselves and enabled them to prevent demographic change that would compromise their ability to actualise the former. The Lok Sabha also passed the Jammu and Kashmir (Reorganisation) Bill, 2019 with 370 votes in favour and 70 against it. The Jammu and Kashmir state will now be divided into two “union territories” directly ruled by New Delhi. The Jammu and Kashmir union territory will include the Hindu-majority Jammu region and will have a legislative assembly. The Buddhist-majority Ladakh region, which has a considerable population of Shia Muslims, will also be a union territory, but without the privilege of its own assembly.

Before Monday’s decision, prominent Kashmiri leaders were jailed or put under house arrest. Reuters reports have put the number of arrested at approximately 500. Internet and communication services along with cable networks were also shut down in anticipation of widespread unrest. An additional 38,000 troops were deployed in the region. Reports suggest that Indian law enforcement used tear gas and pellet guns to disperse a crowd of 10,000 protesters that had gathered in the state capital of Srinagar. One can write a book on how Kashmiris are caught up between the interests of different states that are unwilling to hear what they have to say. However, amidst the overblown ultra-nationalistic and at times jingoistic responses to the new status quo from either side of the border, there is an urgent need to examine the justifications given by the Indian government for the steps taken and the more obvious reasons for why this was done. The Bharatiya Janata Party led government coalition claims that articles 370 and 35A have resulted in Kashmir becoming a breeding ground for separatism, nepotism and corruption. All of this has led to Kashmir being left behind the nation in terms of development.

Our general assumptions about the state largely fall in line with this government argument. In the popular imagination, Kashmir largely resembles a less intense war zone with regular occurrences of spontaneous or planned violence. The only difference between the imaginaries of populations across the border seems to be about which actor is responsible for the violence: the Indian military or Pakistani supported terrorist militias. However, dear reader, you might be surprised about how developed Jammu and Kashmir actually is. According to census data, the state’s poverty rate stood at 10.35% in 2011-12 compared to the national average of 22%. Bihar, Assam, Uttarakhand, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra and Gujarat (where Mr. Modi hails from) all had poverty rates higher than Jammu and Kashmir’s. Per capita income in the region is also higher than that of Bihar, Assam and Madhya Pradesh. The state does even better in terms of social indicators. Life expectancy in Kashmir is 73.5 years while the national average is 68.7 years. Kashmir does better than all of the states mentioned earlier in this category. The infant mortality rate in Kashmir is also significantly lower than the national average and is lower than the states mentioned bar Maharashtra. 8.7% of women between the ages of 20 and 24 years were married before the age of 18 years, compared to the national average of 26.8%, according to data from the National Family Health Survey IV. In Bihar, this figure was 42.5%, and in Gujarat 24.9%, data shows. Mr. Amit Shah also alleged in his speech that Kashmiri children were being denied an education because of the state legislature’s decision to not accept the Right to Education Act. However, he failed to mention that children in the state are provided free and compulsory education until Class 8. The gross enrolment ratio in senior secondary schools is also higher than the national average. Jammu and Kashmir has 23 colleges per 100,000 residents which is much better than Bihar’s 7 and Assam’s 14.

Mr. Shah is correct about two things though. The state does have a high government debt burden and fares poorly in attracting private investment. However, both of these are a consequence of the security situation in the region. The state has to borrow capital from the central government because of its huge security expenditure. Private investors are also weary of entering a market that is plagued with violence-induced uncertainties. What is apparent at this point, however, is that Kashmir is not necessarily underdeveloped and even the areas in which it is lagging behind have nothing to do with Article 370 and Article 35A of the constitution. So, what about separatism then? There are many reasons for why separatist tendencies exist in the Kashmiri population. The first and most obvious one, is oppression at the hands of the Indian state. According to Mr. Modi himself, 42000 people have died in the last 3 decades due to violence alone. There are reports of illegal detention, torture and rape at the hands of security forces. I won’t explore this issue further because of precisely how well documented this is. What is relevant is that members of the population resort to violence against the state because of the actions of the state and the unwillingness of the state to change its behaviour and hold criminals operating within it accountable. Pakistani support for violent groups is also a reason for why members of the population become terrorists. Pakistani patronage gives violent dissidents access to resources that they otherwise would not have had. Notice however, that not only do both these broad reasons have nothing to do with both articles of the constitution, they will only be exacerbated further in response to the Indian government’s actions. With most of their political leaders in some form of state-mandated confinement and a crackdown on media, communication services and any form of peaceful organisation, the separatist sentiment in Kashmir will only get worse. This will also increase pressure on the Pakistani government to do something, given how important Kashmir is to Pakistani identity and therefore the Pakistani population and may lead to further support being given to these groups if the states current attempts at taking the issue up at international forums fails.

Why would the Modi government do this then? Jammu and Kashmir has been a focal point for Hindu nationalism ever since Partition. While Jinnah and the Muslim League considered that being a Muslim-majority state it should have been part of Pakistan and that Partition would remain unachieved so long as the whole of Kashmir remained under Indian rule, for the Hindu nationalists the state was inseparably a part of India. The transfer of one more state to Pakistan would make it stronger and India weaker. The Bharatiya Janata Party has a history of opposition to Article 370. In 1953, Syama Prasad Mukherjee, died in a jail in Srinagar where he was detained by the Sheikh Abdullah government for protesting against Kashmir being an autonomous republic within India. A year before his death, Mukherjee was the president of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh – the predecessor of the present day Bharatiya Janata Party. He saw it as a threat to national unity and famously proclaimed, “Ek desh mein do Vidhan, do Pradhan aur Do Nishan nahi challenge.” There is a strong element of territoriality within the ideology of Hindu nationalism and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. Hindutva is not only based on ethno-religious categories but also on the belief that India occupies a sacred land whose frontiers matter as much as religion and language. Hence the demand for Akhand Bharat (complete, undivided India), which emerged in the 1950s and which implied that Partition should be undone to restore the natural extension of the sacred land that is Bharat. Such measures inevitably allow the BJP to secure its more hard-line electoral base. These actions will also appease party activists and politicians who lean towards the extreme right. Splitting Jammu and Kashmir into two union territories can be viewed as a unique attempt at gerrymandering to prove electoral outcomes for the BJP. We would be remiss however to exclusively focus on the Hindu right wing as has been the case with most coverage on the issue. Commentators have pointed out that this may also be an attempt by the BJP to divert criticism from India’s lack lustre economic performance. India’s economic growth cooled sharply in the first three months of this year. Gross domestic product increased 5.8 per cent from the same quarter the previous year, down from the 6.6 per cent growth rate recorded in the last quarter of the 2018 calendar year. The Indian economy also faces three huge problems: an ever-increasing population, deteriorating infrastructure and public sector corruption. Therefore, economic growth does not necessarily translate into a better quality of life for the vast majority of Indians. Triggering controversy in Kashmir takes media and public focus away from this difficult conversation and enables the BJP to dominate positive headlines. And yes, most headlines are positive. Comparing the Indian media to the work of Pewdiepie would be a disgrace to Pewdiepie (although he too has given shout outs to fascist organisations). There is also a crackdown on dissenting voices. The founders of NDTV, a channel that has been quite critical of the Modi government were prevented from leaving the country because of a “money-laundering” case. Videos published by the BBC have been called “fake news” by elected officials. As a result, most Indians are currently accessing news that portrays this as a move that was long overdue and will be in the national interest.

We must remember that Kashmiris are the primary stakeholders in this situation. They have been historically discriminated against and oppressed. They have not consented to Article 35A and Article 370 being revoked. They have been denied access to information, which is a fundamental right in any democracy. They have been stripped off their right to protest against this decision by a government that is framing its actions as necessary for the prosperity of these people. What has happened to Kashmiris historically and what is happening to them currently is unjustifiable. No actor has cared about their dignity as human beings, has respected their autonomy or stood up for their right to self-determination. We should all be outraged by what is happening in Kashmir. But we must also remain cognisant of our own shortcomings. Because there are parts in Pakistan where citizens disappear never to be seen again. There are elected representatives of vulnerable communities who have been jailed for simply trying to make things better. There are criminals amongst those responsible for protecting all of us who have not been held responsible for their actions. We must criticise the actions of oppressors, but we must also introspect, lest we have our own version of Kashmir soon.

 

 

 

Everyone’s a mental health advocate

By Anonymous

Everyone’s a mental health advocate

… Until it’s not an abstract concept anymore.

You vomit positivity on your Facebook page, put the Artidote’s latest post on your Instagram story.

You’re a good person.

Until you’re not. Until you see that girl you heard an unsubstantiated rumour about show up. You whisper a witty comment just within earshot, and your friends erupt in sniggers.

Just a bit of harmless fun.

Until it’s not.

And hey, I’m not blaming you. God knows that I’ve done the same thing countless times. Any distraction from our insecurities is a welcome one, and exploiting someone else’s insecurities achieves that while moving us up a rung on the social ladder.

What else can you expect from a people who are taught to look at the less fortunate, not with compassion, but with relief — at least I’m better off than that guy.

F**k your performative woke-ness. Being aware is useless if action does not follow. You have to hold yourself to higher standards. Your expensive university education means nothing if you graduate without learning to think for yourself. Use that brain that-almost-got-you-into-the-Ivy-League-leken-visa-nahi-aya and engage in some good old-fashioned critical thinking. Your definition of mental illness must extend beyond “Be nice to me when I’m sad, while I continue to be a d**k to everyone around me.”

Next time, when you hear something about someone, maybe try weighing your amusement against a person’s reputation. Next time you have a witty remark up your sleeve, ask yourself: is this truly witty, or am I just using the shock value of saying something offensive to score brownie points with the people who I call my friends?

To be brave in this life does not have to mean dying on battlefields. It can also mean holding on to warmth and compassion in spite of the horrible things that have happened to you. If being kind were easy, everyone would do it. Kindness is a virtue because of how difficult it is in practice. To exist in this world and not be jaded; that is the true challenge.

Be better.

The friends we once had

Remember your best friend in grade 8? I remember mine. We used to talk on the phone for 8 hours straight till my mom would come out of her room at 6AM and glare at me with hints of disbelief and quite prominent traces of anger in her eyes. It would take a lot of scolding and many threats of being ‘phone-grounded’ from my mom to make me stop talking to my best friend. 7 years later, I don’t even know how she’s doing.

It’s the summer of 2019 and I’m about to enter into my junior year which quite honestly I’m still having a hard time believing. But having one of those early 20s crises most of us are pretty familiar with at this point, I’m wondering where it all went wrong. We all have had friends we used to be close to in junior school or college but are not anymore. Some have fought their way into distance and some have ‘drifted apart’ from people they could hardly imagine their lives without. But somewhere in our heads, when we see photographs of our school plays or when Facebook and Snapchat memories rub it in our noses, we stop and think about what genuinely went wrong. Like an epiphany it hits me: being in my early 20’s means I’m about to graduate and it technically also means that these friends I’ve made in my entire life, they are the ones who will know about all the phases I will never want my work friends to know about, They will know about the crazy haircuts, the emo diary entries, the dramatic junior school break ups and all the shameful playlists and posters we had. They will also be the people who have seen our families struggle and make it to where they are, who have seen us fall in love for the first time, they have encouraged us to follow our dream and apply for that English degree everyone else thinks is useless. They are a part of who we are at this point in our lives and we may find many more friends and acquaintances in life but will they will really only know one half of who we are.

I’m afraid this sounds more dramatic than I intended, but it hits me like a slap in the face and I reach out to all the old friends, afraid of not being able to connect like we did in the past yet taking the risk because if not now, then when? We come out of school, looking forward to college and leave college thrilled about going to a university; amidst all these huge changes what we fail to realize is that somewhere between the transition from uniforms to casual kurtis, we forget about the priceless feeling we got when we made that first best friend in grade 6 and promised it was forever.

PS: It’s not too late to text the friend you haven’t seen in years, the friend you terribly miss when you see a packet of cocomo or a cold drink poured in a plastic bag-‘Kal ho na ho’, my friend (shameless Bollywood reference because it can truly never be irrelevant).

LUMS STREETSTYLE- AN INTERVIEW WITH ANQA KHAN

If you are an avid Instagram user, chances are that you might have at some point come across the page @lumsstreetstyle. With followers nearing 2000 in just a span of 5 months, the blog is a must-follow for all fashion enthusiasts out there. It doesn’t matter if you are into traditional wear or find yourself more presentable in Western clothing, LUMS Streetstyle has something for everyone!

Meet Anqa Khan, the person behind the blog! Although, she is originally an Econ-Pol major, her interests for fashion sees no boundaries at all.

PLUMS asked Anqa about her 5-month journey into fashion blogging, her inspirations/motivations and what at the end of the day keeps her going!

Tell us about LUMS streetstyle

“LUMS streetstyle is basically a fashion blog where I post anything related to “streetstyle fashion.” As the name suggests, I look for people here at LUMS and whosoever fits the requirements I have in mind gets featured on the page. Additionally, while the purpose of the blog is to highlight fashion trends, I also use it as a platform to give tips to general audience on how to dress and better etc. More importantly, I would say the page is about appreciation, validation and complementing people.”

How did you come up with this idea?

“Well to be completely honest, I never knew I would be doing all of this fashion blog thing. But a lot of people (mainly my friends) asked me start one and that’s how I got all my motivation. Also, for a very long time I had been following the hashtag #parisstreetsyle on Instagram, which I would say was an immediate reason for creating the LUMS streetstyle page.”

Have your friends been any supportive?

“A lot. I always make it a point to take advice from my friends before featuring anyone on the page. Funnily enough, there have also been times when my friend would literally force me to come downstairs from my dorm because they found someone well-dressed.”

 

Why Instagram? Why not Facebook or Snapchat? Do you plan on extending your idea further?

“Instagram is all about pictures! That is what my blog is about and that is what fashion is about. Regarding any extension plans? I don’t plan on shifting to either Facebook or Snapchat but I do want to personalize some aspects of my page.”

How do you decide what gets published on the page? In other words, is selecting a “well-dressed” individual something very spontaneous or you really have to try and look around?

“Its definitely not spontaneous, definitely not. I really have to try and look around people who would fit the requirements I have in mind. A lot of things matter, from shirts to shoes (no chappals, mind you!). But above all I also have to consider the quality of the picture.”

What are the three essential fashion elements you look for in a person?

  1. Formal dressing
  2. Contrasting colour
  3. Wearing something different but carrying it in a casual way

Speaking for the LUMS community, do you think people here do not value traditional wear as much as they do Western clothing? Are you tackling this notion somehow?

“I don’t think there is a biasness against traditional clothing. I have been giving equal importance to both the trends and on the other hand, I have seen people putting in a lot of effort in traditional clothing.   Honestly, weather has a big role to play in that regard. People prefer wearing Western because it keeps you warm in Winters while on the contrary, Shalwar Kameez are pretty comfortable to wear during summers. However, I do have one concern or rather a suggestion to make. I would advise guys to wear more Shalwar Kameez or Kurtas. It looks so good on them but more often than not you will only see them wearing on Fridays. “

Talk us through your collaboration with RGB and other clothing brands?

“I have collaborated with two clothing brands so far: RGB and Perfect Tee Company. I think that’s a big success considering it has just been one semester since I first started the blog.
So, these two brands wanted to target the LUMS community and they reached out to me for help. I have enjoyed and liked the collaboration a lot. It gave me control over my creative space where I knew my opinion was being validated and given weightage.”

Who is your fashion inspiration?

“Don’t get me started on that! It’s a long and a very exhaustive list but I will try cutting it down short. First and foremost, as I mentioned earlier, I am a lot into Paris Streetstyle and I try following different pages on social media that reflect on Parisian fashion vibes. Its very minimalistic yet sophisticated at the same time.
I religiously follow Nicole Kidman’s Instagram. Just love her fashion sense. Closer to home, Amrita Thakur is one of my favorite fashion bloggers/style curator. In Pakistan, Khadija Shah, the owner of Elan also has inspired me all along this way.”

 

What is the future outlook like for your fashion blog? Do you plan on pursuing your passion in some other ways?

“My dream job is to be a style curator following the footsteps of Amrita Thakur and start my own fashion company. I realize this plan seems quite farfetched at this point. However, I hope my Econ-Pol degree lands me a job in fashion retail business where I can be a corporate cool along with enjoying my passion.
As far as my blog is concerned, I realize the page will not be restricted to LUMS and inevitably has to spread out. However, my short-term goal at the moment is to focus more on personalizing the account.”

Sonder and Mokita: In conversation with Haider Ilahi

“The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge”- Stephen Hawking

There is something to be said about a person who draws knowledge from the world, the people and the events surrounding him, the good and the bad; and turning it into a symphony of words that speaks to the soul. Like a tree with its roots firmly in the ground with the world spinning quickly by, as years turning into aeons; people into a kaleidoscope of colours whirling into a spectacular illustration; time burdening it with its age-old secret and the dawning truth ageing it further every day.

There is nothing more radical than to learn, unlearn and relearn oneself from the knowledge that one is provided with and it was by chance that I stumbled upon somebody quite similar to that. From the batch of 2019, Mr Haider Ilahi tells us about what he learnt so far from his experience as a member of the LUMS community and how it shaped him as a person.

Sleepless due to reading Songs of Blood and Sword the whole night, downing a cup of coffee and making our way towards Khoka in the chilly November morning, I and my two friends went to meet Mr.Ilahi as he greeted us with a polite smile.

We started off by asking him about his routine.

Q: How do you usually spend your day?

 A: Previously, I would sleep and wake up very late. I wanted to adjust my routine since it was messing my day up. Directing my biological clock to wake up at 6 am, I started rising to a clean, empty and quiet campus giving me a clear head to think. I have my breakfast and then do my readings outside with the music always playing in the background. Then my friends begin to wake up and I start wasting time (smiles!). By the end of the day, I go to bed early usually around 10 or 11 pm and even though it’s really hard, I still try to maintain this routine.

Q: What kind of literature do you like?

A: I used to read a lot of fiction but I am lucky in the respect that I really like the courses that I take. So, primarily, having just started my senior year, this is the first semester that I am really involved with my course packs. Usually, it would be me opening my books only during a mid or a final, but now it’s constant. So, whenever I am free and have to read something, I’ll do a reading of the course that legitimately interests me like philosophy or sociology. When I do have the time, I try to find novels and books suggested by friends. But I hardly have the time right now, so it seems to be just course packs.

Q: What about your childhood book-preferences?

A: It would be novels, crime stories, and detective stories. Even now, some of the favourite books that I go back to are fiction; which I used to read when I was really young. So, uh, it wouldn’t be surprising that I go back to those Famous Five books (we all laugh) that usually send me back to my childhood. But other than that, philosophy would be my preferred genre.

Q: What made you decide upon your current major?

A: I had an understanding that I would do Political Sciences but my father wanted me to have an open mind about choosing another major if it appealed to me. He personally wanted me to take Economics but, ultimately, he left the choice on me saying that I should analyze my penchant as well as my strengths and weaknesses. When I came as a freshman, I took a month or two to contemplate and then decided on doing Pol Sci and stuck with it. Despite that, even though I am a Pol major and its requirements aren’t very stringent, I promised myself that I’ll take up courses from other disciplines as well except for SDSB, which I had to take eventually as an out-group (the word ‘unfortunately’ was left unsaid). This really broadened my perspective as a whole.

Q: Apart from studying, what hobbies do you indulge in like sports etc?

A: I used to play a lot of football before I came to LUMS. For some personal reasons, I gave that up. It was hard because at that point football was the only thing I was really passionate about. So when I gave it up, I had to sort of find a replacement for it; something to keep me active in a way. Then by the end of my sophomore year and the beginning of my junior year, I found that spark in a specific branch of academics. Met with a couple of teachers who really inspired me to align my goals and ambitions. So if I had to choose now in retrospect, I’ll always choose this over football as it is something much more fulfilling and gratifying.

Since he mentioned music previously,

Q: What about your taste in music and did it develop over time?

A: Yeah, it did develop over time. If I had to go and pick one genre, it would be Blues. I have discovered some of the most incredible blues artists from the 60s and even early 30s. Other than that, since it’s in my blood probably, I have recently started to get really deep into Sufi qawwalis since almost all qawwalis do use spiritual and Sufi takes. As my Punjabi isn’t really good, I have sort of become a student of that. So, 50% it’s qawwali and 50% it’s blues.

Q: What are your thoughts on Iqbal since you mentioned that you respect his philosophy?

A: Well, I can’t talk about Iqbal without talking about society because even my own opinion is formed partly due to society. So when I was growing up, I understood Iqbal as how he was taught: “Qoumi Shayar hain” and “Unko Pakistan ka khwaab aya tha”; that’s all very nice and cute but in my junior year I heard about a course being offered called ‘Philosophy and Poetry of Iqbal’. This course was being taught by the only person I call my teacher, Sir Koshul. Since it required the consent of the instructor, the professor took my interview. I remember when he asked me why I wanted to take this course up, my reply was that one of the things my father used to talk about was my generation; that the most unfortunate aspect of our generation is that we haven’t studied Iqbal well and even if we have, we didn’t try to understand him. That really stuck with me. At that time I was trying to study Kant and Nietzsche on my own and, although it was fun, there was a thirst and a void inside me as if I was missing something. So, ultimately, I stumbled upon Iqbal and truth be told, that course changed my life. It was primarily the philosophy of Iqbal but the poetry of it cannot be separated as they complement each other.

Q: Why did Iqbal impact you so?

A: This course and Iqbal’s ‘Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam’, it struck me really deeply and my whole life was turned upside down.  Those questions that plagued my mind, Iqbal answered them.  Culturally specific and contextual, Iqbal is not just for Muslims only. He is beyond that; he is universal. Iqbal understood the fact that the need of the current day and age, and I hate using this word since it has an extensive debate behind it, is for us to reconcile things ‘rationally’. For instance, and I speak personally, growing up in a Sunni Muslim not-so-extremist family I would have questions about my religion and somewhat related aspects.  When I would look for the answers, religion would always say this is where you take a leap of faith.  Kind of like religious schooling in subtext. Whilst from my school to my university, the exact opposite coaching’s been done: to perceive everything rationally and build reasonable, sound arguments so it could all make sense. So you can imagine the conflict inside me and I notice this about a lot of people in my generation as well. The disparity has expanded so much that both of our domains do not even see eye to eye most of the time. It has thus created a perception-gap throughout because we have failed to understand the needs of our time. And Iqbal talks about this in the preface that the need of the time requires a method that is physiologically sound and mentally adequate or something along these lines. That is why Iqbal is so exceptional and made so much sense to me. Where religion told me to take a leap of faith and I couldn’t uncover any empirical or sort of logical reason for that, Iqbal resolved my conflict through his philosophy and I started seeing patterns in things as my observational sense got acute. I feel like he is truly misunderstood whenever I have this conversation, even with my friends. I apologize if this is getting lengthy (we didn’t mind at all), but Iqbal is a teacher of mine and I think everyone could learn from Iqbal regardless of what their personal inclinations are towards everything. Religion, faith, science, whatever belief you hold; I think if you respect the text and go to it as a student, you’ll take a lot from it in the end.

Q: How did these texts change your perception?

A: For that, I’ll talk about the point where I started to understand things or rather, I thought I started to understand things and that came from the fact that if I had a text in front of me, whether it be of Allama’s or any other’s, I had to treat it with respect. More than knowledge, it is the self-discipline that is necessary to understand something. My favourite movie of all time ‘Good Will Hunting’ has this powerful scene between Will and his therapist Sean where the therapist says: “You think I know the first thing about how hard your life has been, how you feel, who you are because I read Oliver Twist? Does that encapsulate you?” So whatever surface idea you garner, that’s probably the worst interpretation you can attain from a text. The text Sir Koshal is teaching us, he is still working on it and even now he goes back to his very beginnings. And it’s only due to self-discipline that you start forming your own conclusions which are very sound, probably by not endorsing anyone else’s opinion. When we come to the Quran, the stipulation in which the country is right now is most likely because people have reduced the text. They have reduced God. Had they grappled with the text, had they had the self-discipline; this country wouldn’t be suffering from the current repercussions. Not saying that I have that sort of self-discipline and this is perhaps the reason I haven’t picked up Quran’s translation till now. The other end of the spectrum is that you start understanding it and you begin discovering things that are fascinatingly tangible for your inner world. Then yes, your life changes, your company changes, your friends change and your relationship with the world changes. It’s because your understanding of the world has changed and if it is worth something, you will definitely change.

Q: You talked about having some questions growing up. What were those?

A: There were a lot of questions that plagued me. I’ll talk about three of the most primary ones here. One of them was the biggest contradiction that I and most people find in religion: predestination and free will. If everything is pre-decided by God then where is this supposed free will? It bothered me a lot not being able to comprehend why I can’t understand my religious conviction. The second thing that troubled me was the nature of time. There are a lot of ways to understand time but how I perceived it was through observation. The earliest memory I have is of my mother picking me up as she prepared breakfast for me and my siblings when I was very little. Now, it’s the same mother and it’s the same Haider but when I am climbing stairs with my mum, she asks for my hand to help her ascend. This is how I understand time: seeing parents age, seeing myself grow and watching myself as I change. Thirdly, I started questioning death. I have seen death very closely and well everyone is subject to it; this developed a curiosity inside me to discern the nature of death in its truest form. So, these were the queries that I had growing up and the most intriguing thing is that many philosophers have presented these questions with answers of their own but none of them really stuck with me. That’s where Sir Basit Koshul came into the picture; he taught me about 150-200 pages of Iqbal thoroughly and that sort of lead to a mental progression for myself.

Q: The way you perceive different aspects of your life probably vary from that of your peers. Did you ever feel the need to make them understand your point of view?

A: The beauty of life is that every person lives his life in a unique way. Again Allama when he talks about human ego, call it a soul, a spirit or whatever, he says that every individual is a unique ego and everybody is looking at life with a different intellect. Doesn’t mean that somebody’s way of perceiving it is better than any other’s or only one way is the True way. These are just general rules for surviving on this Earth; a necessity if you may. It’s essential even to look at things in your own way and be respectful of how others are looking at them and then exchange ideas among yourselves. So when I am with my friends, this is the only sort of conversation that I have. Better to understand another than to gossip about someone else. Be respectful, be kind and you will start to realize that even though you might be looking at things through a different lens, you will be able to see the beauty in it. It’s really exciting if you and your friend perceive the same thing completely differently. And nothing is more beautiful than when this difference allows you to achieve the essence of that very thing.

Q: Did it change your perception of the institute that we study in?

A: I don’t want to scare you guys but I am sure that you all must have heard a lot when you first started studying here like there is freedom of inquiry, free objectivity and well the very best of education you could get in the entire country. After three and a half years, I would say it’s been probably the exact opposite. Because if LUMS is claiming this, then there sure are some conflicts within this claim. And for that, I will have to talk about rationality, something I am very cautious to talk about since we have understood it in a very restricted way. Weber gives four modes of rationality: theoretical (computative and analytical), formal (cause and benefits), practical (actions and reactions) and value (judgment mostly). What the university does and what science and each of its discipline do is endorse only formal rationality. This is the only form of rationality that they accentuate and consider to be ‘true’. According to them, the other three modes never existed. This approach is nothing but similar to a donkey whose eyes are blindfolded and is told to tread the path (this cracked me up since it was primarily apt).

“Never reduce your texts, your approach or your vision.”

And make no mistake about it; religion does the exact same thing with value rationality. So you need to reconcile the conflicts within by broadening your spectrum as these assertions make you question your courses, your chosen discipline, your degree and even the very claims that lead you to spend giant amounts of money in these four years. It is my right as well as my duty to question what this has given me in the long run. The point is that there is always more to a picture than someone would tell you. The university is, in my opinion, swindling you. That is why you need to be critical in your approach and question things. But they never address these issues because if they did, they are most likely screwed.

Q: How can we overcome such dishonest ways in your opinion?

A: Primarily by starting talking about it as it can’t go on forever. This has to change. So, talk about it and hopefully, someone with courage will stand up against it. This is all about progression. You play your part and hope that the next person plays their part for there will always be a next person. There shouldn’t be any despondency regarding this. Just keep playing your part and imparting something from it onto someone else so they can make their own choice by looking at the evidence and thus furthering the process. The change is sure to transpire. One thing I would say is that there is too much deception in this world; a lot of mirrors around creating an illusion of reality. So travel, it cleanses your mind. Take some time to yourself; take a step back to sort of escape that tornado of life. Breathe. Think. Analyze what is happening around you and to you. This is very necessary and I am kind of becoming an extremist in this (chuckles). This is how I start and end my day and I wouldn’t want it any other way since it is innately very enjoyable. If it’s chaotic inside, it will be chaotic outside and if it’s peaceful inside then it will be peaceful outside. Write if you need to. Because writing has given me a channel to express my inner-self through words and resolve the inner workings of my mind which, to be honest, has been a lot of help in bettering my life.

Quoting one of his favourite verses of Iqbal;

نوا پیرا ہو اے بُلبل کہ ہو تیرے ترنّم سے
کبوتر کے تنِ نازک میں شاہیں کا جگر پیدا

The history and significance of New Year festival

Contrary to popular belief, New Year’s wasn’t always celebrated on January 1st. Historically, it had been celebrated at many different times. The Egyptians, Phoenicians, and Persians began their new year with the fall equinox, and the Greeks celebrated it on the winter solstice while the Mesopotamians had been celebrating it on March 1st for centuries before that. The custom of celebrating the new year began in 45 B.C when Julius Caesar created the Julian calendar, moving the first day of the year from March 1st to January 1st. The practice fell out of custom in the Middle Ages as it was decreed as “unchristian” due to its supposed ties with paganism. It was then celebrated on 25 December instead. However, it was resurrected when the Gregorian calendar was implemented in 1982 and the date was given significance as ‘the day of circumcision’ following the Jewish tradition of circumcision and naming a child 8 days after its birth. Since then, New Year’s Day has been celebrated around the world and has recently gained considerable popularity in Pakistan too.

Festivities usually include gathering your loved ones and toasting to the upcoming year. A distinct feature of the event is fireworks and general fanfare to welcome the new year. The customs on New Year’s Day vary from country to country. A particularly significant event is of course the ball drop in New York City, which is a long standing tradition and seems to grow in its magnificence every year. In Greece, it is customary to turn off the lights at midnight and eat basil pie. This strange tradition does have a purpose – there is a hidden coin in the pie and whoever finds it is said to have good luck for the rest of the year! And the Greek aren’t the only ones with a strange custom. The Spanish eat 12 grapes at midnight to symbolise 12 months of fertility, and the Canadians and the Scandinavians, despite the extreme cold, plunge themselves in cold water!

These many many customs aren’t the only thing New Year’s has carried with it, it is accompanied by a long standing debate on whether or not the celebration has any use to society at all.

From a Marxist perspective, the festival is utter capitalist ploy. For Marx, mankind has been ruled by ‘historical materialism’, where every phase of civilized society had the fundamental characteristic of class inequality. The poor serfs or labour were made to work long and hard while the landowners and factory owners got the profit. For Marx, history can easily be viewed as an effort of the bourgeoisie to subdue the proletariat and control the means of production. He had predicted that one day the workers would realise this, gain class consciousness, and hence work to overthrow the capitalist structures. Clearly, this hasn’t happened till now. To explain this, neo-Marxists like Althusser devised the Ideological State Apparatus theory. This explains how media, religion and the state all propagate the capitalist ideology so that class consciousness is impossible to achieve. Our consumerist culture is of course a direct result of their efforts. Simply put, we now express ourselves in objects, constructing our identity around what we own and what we can afford. We express love by buying presents and anger by taking away items. We are addicted to buying more and more in order to fulfill the void that capitalism has created. Gradually, we are isolated from our peers because we are so consumed in our self preservation and reach the stage where everything without a price tag is meaningless. We are taught to work hard and continue working until we are able to afford all the luxuries that are flaunted in front of us all day, everyday. From this perspective, New Year’s Day is just another cog in the system. Nowadays, all festivals seem like nothing but capitalist constructs to get us to spend more and more, on food entertainment and gifts, than we did at the last occasion. Taking just one example, the whole month of December is laden with sales and advertisements to get us to spend our savings and end-of-year bonuses on lavish new year parties and dresses. On a psychological level, the significance of New Year’s eve comes from the way it delivers a sense of hope to the masses. The new year seems like an opportunity to bring change to one’s lifestyle, and for some, a chance to start over from scratch – a clean slate! For Marxists, this is merely a clever illusion to give people a false sense of control in their life. Organise your life with new drawers, buy new clothes to revamp your look for the new year, throw away old belongings to declutter your new life and the list goes on. They build a facade of control in our life, and very subtly shift the focus away from the people who are actually in control. We then believe we are the reason for our poverty or lack of success and not the sheer inequality of the capitalist society.

On the other hand, functionalists believe that everything in the status quo has a function. Durkheim founded the theory on ‘value consensus’ of a society. He believes that in order for society to function seamlessly, everyone must agree on the norms and values of the society. Once that has been established, every action of its members is to preserve and pass on those norms. For Parson, a society needs 4 things to function: an ability to adapt to the everyday challenges and changes of time, a collective goal, a mechanism to pass on values and a system to integrate its members. From this perspective, New Year’s eve has a distinct purpose. Festivals can be events to reinforce the collective identity and value consensus of a society. New Year’s showcases the culture and customs of a society, thus integrating its members and also passing them to the new generation. The Spanish custom of eating grapes or the American one of watching the ball drop all serve the same function. It is a moment for people to come together and celebrate their coexistence in harmony. The occasion celebrates life and our connection with one another. We feel connected not only to our society but to the rest of the world as well as we all step back and watch the countdown to a new year. In that moment we are reminded that we are all.

The history of new years is steeped in tradition and custom that is impossible to disregard. Even if it is just another holiday hijacked by the capitalist propaganda, it’s importance cannot be ignored.  It is up to us how we choose to spend the day and what significance we are willing to give it. Perhaps the real legacy of new years is its ability to make us reflect on our actions and give us hope for the coming year.

 

The Winter Skin Survival Guide

If you’re like me, you tend to get super dry skin during the colder months of the year. Not only does dryness make your skin look tired and ashy, but if left untreated, it can lead to your skin becoming flaky, then cracking, or even eczema in more severe cases. But fret not! Even though your skin does require some extra TLC during the winter, it’s actually a very simple process to get rid of the Sahara Desert that has begun to take over your skin. I’ve listed some of the things that help me get smooth skin, below:

  1. Moisturize religiously

I mean that. Moisturize like your life depends upon it. Do it in the morning and at night before bed, and whenever else you feel like your skin needs a little extra. Also be sure to do it right after you shower to really seal in your skin’s natural oils and moisture. If you’ve been using those really pretty perfumed lotions, ditch them. They don’t do much, apart from looking super cute on your vanity. They’ve been shown to contain silicone, which makes your skin feel temporarily soft, but doesn’t actually hydrate it. They also contain some not-so-good-for-the-skin toxins, and perfume in skincare is generally a no-no, unless it’s completely natural. My personal favourite (and something my dermatologist also recommended to me) is Physiogel. It will hydrate skin regardless of how dry it is, and has no scent, so it’s perfect for sensitive skin too. It is a little on the pricier side, but it’s definitely an investment for your skin!

  1. Turn off the hot water

I know this one seems cruel, but hot showers do really dry your skin out! They sap the skin’s natural oils, and can even damage the surface of your skin if the water is too hot. So do yourself a favour, and turn the temperature on the water down. Because it’s impossible to take a cold shower during the winter (please don’t, you could get hypothermia), a slightly warm shower is perfect. Not only is it adequately comfortable, it won’t strip your skin of moisture, either. Also, a hydrating shower cream or bath oil will help further nourish your skin.

  1. Use an exfoliator or scrub

Exfoliating is an important part of most people’s summer skincare routine, but it’s also really important during the winter. Using a scrub or exfoliating wash will slough away the dead skin, encourage blood circulation and cell rejuvenation. This will ultimately allow new skin cells to emerge that haven’t been affected by the harsh winter weather. I recommend using a homemade scrub so that you know exactly what’s it in. The sugar scrub I make at home contains brown sugar and white sugar (equal parts), natural coconut oil and raw honey. To use it, scrub it onto your skin (this is especially good for your hands and feet), massage for a few minutes and then wash it off. It’ll leave your skin feeling like silk, I’m not even joking. After you wash it off and dry your skin, don’t forget to- you guessed it- MOISTURIZE!

  1. Visit the dermatologist

Finally, if your skin becomes dry to the point of itching, burning or forming a rash, definitely go see your dermatologist. It could be eczema, which spreads quite quickly and needs to be treated with prescription medication. Don’t put going to the dermatologist off, as this could make your problems much worse.

Removing the Taboo One Conversation at a Time

The sunlight dances its way into the room through the huge windows as soft music plays in the background, yet the atmosphere inside remains tense. A young woman clad in a burqa sits on a sofa, clearly distressed. I cannot see her face, but her eyes water up as if in pain. Her voice falters as she proclaims, “Zindagi buri lagti hai…khatam karnay ka dil karta hai” (Life itself seems to be horrible, I sometimes want to end it). Across from her sits Dr. Fareed Aslam Minhas.

Dr. Minhas is a psychiatrist- perhaps one amongst a limited number in Pakistan. As he welcomes me into his clinic during the afternoon on a Monday, I get a quick look into what is my first ever visit to a psychiatrist in Pakistan. The office itself seems to defy my expectations of the typical whitewashed doctor’s office filled with the distinct smell of medicines and blood veiled by antiseptics. One side looks into the garden outside with big windows stretching up to the ceiling. A watercolor painting of a cat faces one of the many comfortable seats lying around. An armchair sits in one corner, behind it the wall is covered by huge wooden cabinets that hold papers and books.  The doctor himself sits in the center, in a swivel chair that he moves around in as patients come and go. He is impeccably dressed in a black suit, a bright pink tie loosely fastened around the collar.

“I think I was in my third year of medical school when I learnt about a woman who was operated on twice- yet it was later discovered that her ailment was mental and not physical. It was then that I realized how psychological and social factors in illness are neglected in our country.”, says the doctor, as he explains his choice of profession to me. Born in Rawalpindi to a large family with 6 siblings above him, Dr. Minhas breaks into a smile as he tells me he had eight parents to supervise him growing up. He moved on to do his MBBS from Rawalpindi Medical College, where he specialized in Psychiatry. It has been a long road since then, and 30 years into his practice he tells me that psychiatric disorders are not only misunderstood by the community, but also by the medical profession in Pakistan.

“Either there are physical problems or there are medical problems, but people by and large tend to disregard mental illnesses due to the belief systems our population has”, he tells me, taking off his thinly framed glasses. Dr. Minhas has throughout his successful career, tried to raise awareness about mental illnesses. Having remained the head of the Institute of psychiatry at Rawalpindi Medical College and the Head of the Department of Psychiatry at Benazir Bhutto Hospital, he has overlooked various projects that work on removing the taboo from mental illnesses in Pakistan, while improving the facilities available to both psychiatrists and patients. It has not been an easy journey.

“You do get problems from time to time. There are certain people who find it difficult to leave treatments, and that is when sad incidents take place. I’ve been hit by my patients several times; my colleagues have faced the same. The people we are dealing with don’t understand what is right and wrong- they lose that sanity, that control over their behavior and actions”, he says.

As patients walk in, the doctor gets up to greet them, remembering their names with ease and greeting them in different ways. He disarms them with his warm smile, making the occasional joke and letting them rant about their problems. As a couple walk in, the woman complains about her husband to the doctor, who responds by jovially remarking “Wo shohar hi kya jo tang na karay” (What sort of a husband is he who doesn’t bother his wife at all). The patient almost at once falls into ease, smiling at his response. Expecting him to use medical jargon, I am left surprised at the way he translates the diagnosis he has for his patients:

“Imagine that you have to go to Siachen from Rawalpindi- you can either walk or take the plane. The plane will get you there faster. These medicines were supposed to be that plane you took on your route to faster recovery. However, we will take the longer route now- but we will still get there.” he says as he reassures a worried patient whose medications are not having the desired effect.

As we fall into a conversation about the recent cases of child abuse in Pakistan, he remarks sadly that child sex abuse is so common in the Pakistani society that around 1 out of 5 patients that he gets have suffered from child abuse at some point in their lives, which has affected their behavior as adults.

“Unfortunately, we live in a very hypocritical society. We choose not to talk about these things- the things that need to be talked about. All the players who matter are involved themselves in the sad events that take place during child abuse. That is how I view my society as a psychiatrist”.

As our meeting moves towards an end, I ask the doctor about his views on the media and its portrayal of mentally ill patients- who are (usually) sadly portrayed raging lunatics, with poorly crafted stories of supernatural control over these patients. Dr. Minhas seems to be upset about this. “The portrayal of mental health in the media is itself stigmatizing the cause of mental health in this country. They simply don’t seem to care- they are more concerned about what news brings in more money”. He does, however, remark that the media too can help join the fight against mental illnesses by showing them as they are and not creating a warped image of people who are victims of various mental illnesses just to create content that the public enjoys at the expense of others.

At the end of the meeting, Dr. Minhas remarks that it is his ability to affect people’s lives for the better with the knowledge he has, that motivates him every single day. As I leave his clinic, I take with me a changed perspective on the world of psychiatry in Pakistan and a renewed hope in the state of the psychiatric care in Pakistan, through the commitment of individuals like Dr. Fareed Aslam Minhas who leave no stone unturned in their fight against mental illnesses.

 

 

 

 

Cloth on my face

It’s just a cloth on my face

It’s just a cloth on my face

Don’t look at me so

Don’t raise the eyebrows

Don’t turn your faces

Don’t ignore my views

Don’t make judgments about me

It’s just a cloth on my face

I am scared to go ‘all black’ today

Because I am scared to hear ‘ninja’ in the silence that spreads

Each day I adorn myself with ‘colour’

While inside the voiceless comments suffocate me

I dress while always fearing their ‘liberalism’

I am scared to go out today, though I wonder

Isn’t it just a cloth on my face?

I see people I know pass by me

Every time I have to stop and wave at them

I have to wait for them to recognize

I have to wait for them to see

I have to wait for them to acknowledge

Every time I wonder, why don’t you see?

Don’t sell me excuses of how the cloth hides me

It’s just a cloth, there is so much more to me

The way I walk

The way I speak

Says a lot about me

If you only cared to stop and see

Don’t you dare sell me excuses about how you failed to see

As soon as I walk in a room

The cloth on my face stands out more than me

A silence spreads and eyes bore into me

Each glance is loaded with judgment

Each person maintains a distance

I want to ask so much

What is it that repels you so much?

It’s just a cloth on my face

I want to scream out to you

I want to be heard

I want to be seen

I want to be known

Because there is so much more to me than the cloth on my face

Agents of change

Opinions, opinions

Incessant, aplenty

Unsafe to voice them,

Unsafe to act

Guards who swear

Protection and safety

Would not hesitate

To break the pact

The worth of life

Is not much more

Than a few bills of cash

We take to our keyboards

And Facebook and Twitter

In a hurry to bash

To lash

Out at the world – the system that seems so unfair

But none of us can dare

To actually care

Enough to start with ourselves

And change what we can.