Ubaidullah Inquiry Committee Report: Resistance, Reformation and Repentance

(Submitted by Rabia Najm)

I remember the exact moment the Ubaidullah Inquiry Committee Report was released because it has had a lasting impact on the way I view and experience my time at LUMS. I was walking back to my dorm from the sports complex when I got the email. I started reading it as I walked. I wasn’t fully aware of the events leading up to Ubaidullah’s passing so I skimmed down to the Timeline Section and started reading from there. Not more than a couple of paragraphs into it, I had to stop. I had to stop because in that moment I felt incredibly overwhelmed and could feel tears stinging my eyes.

While I can never claim to understand or make sense of Ubaidullah’s individual experience at LUMS, I can say that it hit closer to home than I expected it to. Our circumstances were dissimilar, but the feelings of hopelessness and being lost were a commonality, a commonality that isn’t just restricted to the two of us, but to so many students who pass through university in general.

Going to university is a very destabilizing experience. In most circumstances you have to live away from home, or learn to be independent. You have to settle into a new environment and adapt to completely different social settings. Academic stress can be crippling especially when it is accompanied by other problems such as financial or family issues. Getting used to all of this is incredibly hard, and even more so when there is no support from the institutions that should be offering it.

As a first year student, I was going through the debilitating process of learning to handle all of these problems, and in that situation to read the Inquiry Committee Report and realize that I would be getting no help or support from the institution that was supposed to be my ‘home’ for the next four years, was terribly scary. Looking at what Ubaidullah went through at LUMS made me realize that this could be me, this could be my friends, this could be anyone at LUMS and there would be no mechanism in place to prevent such a tragedy from happening again.

In desperation I scrolled through the Summary of Recommendations in the report, searching for anything that would give me some sort of hope that my peers and I weren’t alone in this anymore. And it seemed as if my hopes weren’t unfounded; there was an acceptance of institutional failings on part of the committee, a commitment to reforming how certain bodies like the Disciplinary Committee operated and a positive change in how student welfare and autonomy were perceived.

However, despite the fact that the recommendations in the report were received positively by the student body and many members of the faculty, they came to nothing because the report itself was rejected by certain higher ups in the administrative body. As it is with things like these, despite the best efforts of the people involved in the establishment of the Inquiry Committee and the report, the outrage around this tragic incident fizzled out, and Ubaidullah’s batch mates along with other concerned seniors graduated.

Towards the end of Spring 2017-18, the semester in which the report was released, a small group of students made another effort to address some of the issues highlighted in the report by writing a letter to the VC. While no official response was given to this letter, it did garner a lot of support from the LUMS student body in the form of ‘likes on LDF’ and ‘dropping down of roll numbers’, something Luminites are particularly talented at. In the following academic year, Fall 2018-2019, all attempts to reignite conversation on the ‘Letter to the VC’, and the Ubaidullah Committee Report were met with a lukewarm to non-existent response, except the usual LDF activism.

The lack of support and commitment from the student body to the implementation of the proposed reforms is rather puzzling, keeping in mind the sort of events that have unfolded on campus this year. Case in point is how the culture of surveillance and authoritarianism on campus has intensified this past academic year; from the way the M2 issue was handled to how guards with flashlights were stationed in the free parking lot. It is not to say that there hasn’t been any resistance to these policies; however the problem remains that often this resistance is sporadic, reactionary and non-constructive. It does not target the root cause of the problem which may be something like the amount of power a certain individual or office has in the administration, rather it will only target the administrative response in that particular event. While in that moment the huge backlash from the student body may payoff through a revoking of the policy, it has no impact on changing the administrative structure and mindsets behind it, and sooner or later in a similar situation, the same sort of policy is enforced again.

It is great that there was a big enough outcry against the free parking policy for it to be amended, are we going to talk about the fact that this policy is an off-shoot of the increased surveillance culture on campus? This increased surveillance has manifested itself in innocent students being harassed by guards for, smoking in certain places, being warned that they are being ‘observed’ and having their privacy breached by having their rooms broken into or entered without permission. The point here is simple, for there to be constructive long term change in administrative attitudes, our resistance needs to be well thought out and better organized. It cannot be a one- off event in which the students get angry, protest and hope for a response from the powers that be. We need to mobilize the student body to pressure the administration into accepting reforms  aimed at structural changes such as the ones proposed in the Letter to the VC and Inquiry Committee Report.

It cannot be stressed enough how important it is for positive changes like these to be adopted into the administrative structure at LUMS. The type of hostile and unsafe environment that increased campus surveillance has created is terrible for the mental and emotional wellbeing of students especially for those who live on campus, and have no choice but to see it as their home. The insensitivity and callousness with which OSA handles student concerns also has the same impact on student welfare and can lead to increased alienation and feelings of helplessness in students who are already struggling. In a university setting where things like cut throat competition, academic challenges already take a huge toll on student welfare, it is imperative that the structures that should provide support be properly reformed and equipped to carry out their duties.

Events leading up to Ubaidullah’s untimely passing are a painful reminder that LUMS failed as an institution to help a student who desperately needed some show of empathy. The Ubaidullah Inquiry Committee Report has had a defining impact on my time at LUMS because it made me realize that there are other students in LUMS who struggled like me, and some of them were not lucky enough to find the type of informal support networks that I did. No one deserves to feel so lost and directionless that everyday functioning becomes hard, and life becomes a bit less livable to the point that it leads to a spiral that is impossible to pull up from. Our failure as a community played a role in the mental anguish that Ubaidullah Lodhi went through; we owe it to him to make sure it doesn’t happen again to any other student.

 

 

 

 

 

In -NOT- Laughing Colours

Despite many issues with the LUMS administration and other facets of the institution, the university has continued to excel in academics, producing graduates who have been the standard-bearers of the country.

For an outsider therefore, LUMS epitomizes academic excellence in Pakistan. The sheer efforts of the faculty and students deserve all the acknowledgment for upholding educational standards and establishing a name in international academia.

We also get to hear a lot about university enabling ethnic and other forms of diversity within its community and providing a liberal environment to its students. Recently, however some students have taken this diversity for granted and have actively contributed in making these hallowed halls a less safer place for all its students.

If you happen to scroll down your twitter newsfeed, LDF, or any major forum, you will likely come across the hashtag #LUMS. On a closer look at the trend, you will notice a flurry of activity happening. This has been surrounding a LUMS student Ali Zar who is a self-proclaimed public figure owing to his Youtube channel Inlaughing Colours. This status of a public figure is important here because it raises two important issues. Firstly, since he has voluntarily put up his life and opinions on the internet, that makes him fair game for people like us to comment on (long story short, you can’t sue us). Secondly, it begs the question that if Ali Zar uses his status as a student of LUMS in his content, does that mean he has the moral duty to be more careful not to channel ideas that might be problematic and therefore owing to a negative image of the institution.

Most people have argued that he has the freedom of speech to publish whatever he says. Another group has taken the route of saying that even though his content is problematic and completely not representative of the LUMS body, the onus falls on us the readers to not give him the attention which is his motive. They argue that we must simply ignore him and this will pass. The third group of people say that this point is moot because whoever consumes his content automatically imposes his point of view on us, the students of LUMS. This means that he must be more careful of what he posts on Twitter or Youtube.

 

Let’s look at Youtube first. Just about last year, as part of his vlog campaign: “Life at LUMS,” he was seen to actively endorse harassment in one of his videos. When the issue was brought on the university forum, Ali Zar unsuccessfully defended himself by arguing that as a host it is his responsibility to mimic the characters in his video. Which raised the question whether it was even reasonable to mimic a problematic personality and then post it publicly online to be viewed thousands of people?

Second comes the recent Twitter war that even some instructors got involved in. Ali Zar posted that getting in LUMS was more about merit than class or the privilege that stems from it. This is particularly tone deaf in light of the recent cuts in financial aid which have severely disadvantaged the students who aren’t as privileged in the way Mr. Zar clearly is. Therefore, he unfairly delegitimized their issues and as an extension made it the official stance of the LUMS student body in the eyes of the media and the world outside the university. No matter our outrage on LDF, we cannot convince others that we do not agree with his ideas because of his significant following.

One thing is clear, is that Ali Zar is widely unpopular for his work/ opinions and the recent tweet just added fuel to the fire to his already controversial personality. But let us now address his 3-point response and conclude that getting into LUMS is actually more about privilege than anything else.

When people talk about enrolling in LUMS as a significant milestone, they often miss the point that there is a long list of privileges that the particular individual enjoyed in their lifetime. True, that money on its own cannot buy you admission into the institution, but money helped you secure a place in one of the elitist schools in Pakistan, that prepared you well for all the necessary admission requirements. Money helped you get internet access and other cultural capital that the marginalized community can never possibly afford. Money aided you in seeking career counseling like Dignosco which cost almost as much as a kidney and avail evening tuition services so that you could perform well in your SAT. While, your financial capital may not have directly admitted you into LUMS, it surely did assist you in several other ways.

The case of NOP scholars and those on Financial Aid is a valid opposing argument to make but let us also not forget the proportion of NOP scholars at LUMS in comparison to the individuals studying on a full-tuition fee. Even with the National Outreach Program, the selection criteria is often set very high restricting the total number of beneficiaries. On the other hand, excessive red-tape measures involved with the Financial Aid request makes the process a task too arduous in its undertaking consequently discouraging many from applying to the program in the first place. More importantly, excluding nitty-gritty details, holding assets that may not directly exhibit your financial privilege and utilizing expenses for some essential work will eventually make the person ineligible for assistance.

Lastly, it would be absurd to argue that LUMINITIES have some “class” that makes them superior beings. This extremely nebulous and problematic term class is something more suited in our classrooms under the guidance of learned instructors rather than something to be thrown around carelessly to prove merit.

 

Removing Ali Zar from LDF is not a long term solution because that disowning from the LUMS body is not something the world is aware of. He cannot be allowed to speak for all of us using his public platform.

#MeToo: LUMS edition

The last semester brought onto LUMS a dark, Lahori smog-esque cloud that seemed to be looming over my female colleagues and I throughout and continues to do so even through the summer break.  

With the curtains opening to the exposé of Dankpuna – the private Facebook group containing grotesquely misogynistic memes with 600 male members (both current students and alumni), elections drama and allegations revolving around the running candidates, the curtain finally falls as we prepare to welcome the incoming first-years with alleged harassers and hard to trust men on board the O-Week committee. Hits in the ever varying forms of sexual harassment just keep on coming.  

While MangoBaaz and the likes found their way into LUMS like gossip aunties and put out articles, the public statements released by the administration expressed regret regarding the incident and promises of furthering conversation on campus were made. However, little has been done to address the toll every incident has taken on the mental health of the female population of the student body.  

Coming to LUMS from toxic patriarchal family settings, from high schools where the headmistress advises the student body to “stay away from the cancerous #MeToo movement” after allegations were made against a teacher because it tarnishes the name of the reputable private institution to beginning to call LUMS ‘home’ – this semester has failed many students who saw LUMS as an escape from all that they left behind.  

It is a rather saddening experience to suddenly become distrusting of the environment around you – of the friends you saw as allies, the seniors you looked up to as mentors, the instructors you trusted to fall back on for support and guidance, seeing the female friends you never thought could betray you standing up to protect harassers and rapists (I’d like to call them what I believe them to be but also what they’ve been proven to be), witnessing the people you grew up with to suddenly be on the other side- it all converges to the boiling point when everyone comes up to you for the affirmation of their reality when your own is pretty much shaken up.  

The recent incidents have left me disappointed, to say the very least, because somehow the whispers around khokha, and sometimes not even whispers but loud LDF posts ‘BUMP’ed far and wide for “someone finally spoke some sense” find their pointing fingers at none other than the victims of the misogynistic environment themselves.  

The over politicization of LDF has also been a huge contributor towards the deterioration of mental health because after a few hundred hits and likes, a post maker becomes the messiah of the masses for being “liberal” enough to see through the “libel overreach” and attempt to put an end to it. But imagine this: apparently, the women who support each other to be brave enough to report against their abusers are blamed for “seeding the idea of harassment” and have confused poor little “harassment” to be RAPE. Gasp. Add victim blaming by bringing in the girl’s alcohol intake and partying background and you have a 180 degree shift in the blame. The fact that these posts are also written by women who have either internalized this abuse or do so to protect their friends who have been accused, just gives a validation to the hidden sexist people on LDF. Comments about how these are the “good feminists” compared to the “feminazis” that campaign to take these harassers to the disciplinary committee create a huge gulf. Debates about this dichotomy become the real issue while the victims do not get justice. 

I realize I’ve taken a somber tone but that’s not why I wanted to write this. I regained hope because of all the strong women who stood up for all of us, who braved ugly storms and kicked down shut doors. They bore the burden of the hundreds of us, sacrificed their mental wellbeing to raise their voice and speak for all of us who were silently enduring the torture. The protest and drafted emails and proposals marked a refusal to be passive. I know this hardly suffices but I would like to thank you all – you know who you are.  

For all the male allies, who stood by us, protested and facilitated us with great numbers and the instructors who used their position to allow their students to take part in the sit-in, who emailed and spoke out when necessary – you give us hope when there’s little to find. 

For the rest of us, the silent victims of the increasingly threatening environment we are beginning to face at LUMS – stay strong. Stand by each other in these tormenting times and for the sake of whatever God there is that and if you believe in, enable each other instead of putting each other down. We need each other far more than we realize.