How Joker Tackles Mental Illness *Spoilers*

This article contains spoilers about the movie. You have been warned.

 

By Syeda Sara Imran

 

Less than two weeks after its release, Todd Phillip’s fresh take on the notorious DC villain is already making big waves. Winning the Golden Lion and getting an eight-minute standing ovation at the 76th Venice International Film Festival, and rated a whopping 9.0 on IMDb, it’s clear that Joker is no joke when it comes to reception. However, with mental health discourse fast gaining traction, and especially with World Mental Health Day having just recently passed, it is an important question to ask: was Joker’s portrayal of mental illness accurate or not?

The film follows Arthur Fleck’s slow descent from a mentally ill social recluse, a self-proclaimed “mentally ill loner”, to a ruthless murderer on a rampage – the poster boy of anarchy.

Admittedly, Joker does an adept job at depicting just how hard it is for people with a mental illness to get help. Arthur is someone who shows up regularly for his appointments. Though he is not very interested in the therapy part of his treatment, he does repeatedly ask his psychiatrist to increase his dosage; he wants to get better. Yet, life still deals him a bad hand, and Gotham’s healthcare funding gets cut anyway – a nod to the fate of healthcare for mental illnesses in our modern world. One of the most poignant scenes in the movie is not in the form of a dialogue, but rather when an introspective Arthur scribbles in his journal: “The worst part about having a mental illness is people expect you to behave as if you don’t.” My own heart went out to the protagonist in this scene.

And yet, Phillips failed to carry on this level of understanding about mental illness in what was to follow. What Joker does in its depiction of its protagonist spiralling into a well of insanity and escapism, is administer a death blow to a positive public perception of mental illness. This type of error is not without consequences; what is at stake is the stigmatisation of people who have to live and suffer with mental illness. Narratives like Joker lead audiences to think of persons who are mentally ill as ticking time-bombs which will blow up if ignored and/or vilified for long enough. This is the trope all Hollywood films looking to exploit mental illness for a quick buck put forward, and this is what Joker makes full use of.

Extensive research shows that there is no evidence people with mental illness are more prone to commit acts of violence than anyone else. Studies demonstrate that “even if the elevated risk of violence in people with mental illness is reduced to the average risk in those without mental illness, an estimated 96% of the violence that currently occurs in the general population would continue to occur.”

In fact, people with mental health disorders are far more likely to be victims of violence (up to 10 times more likely than the general population) than the perpetrators. “Indeed, the vast majority of those with mental disorders are not violent…” states Carla Marie Manly, PhD, a clinical psychologist in California.

Dr Manly points to the reality of the matter, that is, the majority of mental illness revolves around depression: quiet, simmering. But of course Hollywood wouldn’t make millions writing a quietly suffering character who – surprise, surprise – remains quietly suffering till the end of the film. Thus, we fall into this pit of romanticising and fetishizing mental illness and those who suffer from it.

Let us not forget we live in the same world where an assassination attempt was made on a presidential candidate after the accused was inspired by the political assassination in Taxi Driver (a film Joker itself heavily borrows from), which he watched fifteen times, having become obsessed with the protagonist. Let us not forget that “incel” culture is on the rise, and narratives like these only add fuel to the fire.

Let us hope for more responsible filmmaking in the future, with the intent to unify rather than vilify.

Mental Health – a sad state of affairs

 

Cloaked in a black hood, I crept into the darkness searching for a spot that would allow me to drain out the valve of despair seeping the life out my soul. The orchestra of chaos bursting inside my head could no longer silenced by the semblance of normalcy my words expressed.

Until that point, my cheeks had never felt tears stream with sheer intensity. Struggling socially and academically, I had hit rock bottom 7 months into my LUMS journey.

Suddenly, I sensed movement in the corner adjacent to mine. At first, my heart pounded—have I been exposed in a state of extreme vulnerability?

However, a few moments later, a deeper concern struck me: How many other people drowned in the abyss of despair at 3am on a Tuesday?

I clearly wasn’t alone seeking refuge in the dark corners of this prestigious institution.

Adjusting to life in an alien environment can be difficult and the environment at LUMS is far from perfect. A simple visit to the page Help@LUMS will acquaint you with the quantitative severity of mental issues we as a community face.

Apart from the heightened academic competition, a simmering pressure to fit in dominates the social scene. Sitting at the Khokha or having a meal all by yourself can be intimidating. Add social anxiety to the equation and you’ll have trouble finding decent company.

When your bedroom and classroom coexist in the same vicinity, the personal gets entangled with other aspects of your life. Your academic performance might suffer, causing irrevocable damage. Substance abuse is another wormhole you might become susceptible to. This paves the way for mental instability that might linger beyond the duration of your degree.

Despite hailing to be among the most progressive institutions in Pakistan, LUMS fails to prioritize the mental health of its student body.

A mere number of two psychologists cater to the needs of thousands of students. To make matters worse, the repute of these psychologists is embroiled in controversy; several students have complained a breach of confidentiality.

The administration itself is infamous for fostering an apathetic attitude towards the students, viewing individual concerns with a glare of cynicism. This issue was particularly highlighted in the inquiry report drafted after the tragic suicide of a former student.

The report stated, “The Committee repeatedly heard from students how OSA staff, whom students approached during a crisis, treated them without the empathy that the situation called for. The Committee heard examples of students berated after the death of a parent, students being threatened with removal of financial aid, or students chastised for their physical appearances or put down for their class background. While it was beyond the Committee’s ability to triangulate each of these claims, these accounts do fit a pattern of behavior between students and OSA staff that has long been noted by both students and faculty.”

But the aspect that pierces my heart deeply is the veil of stigma shrouding mental health as a serious issue in the minds of the collective majority. During a Psychology at LUMS event, my efforts at raising mental health awareness at the Khokha were met with chuckles of ignorance and derision.

A mountain of change stands in the way of mental health becoming a priority. However, until we begin the arduous process of incorporating long-term solutions into the administrative framework, I believe an impact can be made informally.

Amid the ensuing bleakness, I believe the onus falls on us— ones who have preserved through the turbulence of the early LUMS experience—to help the young freshman and sophomores or anyone still treading in the darkness.

Our help might not be enough or a long-term solution, but I cannot remain passive knowing my fellow colleagues wrestle the same anguish as I did.

So, I urge you to proactively try to make your colleagues feel more inclusive.

I urge you to give advice to that young, shy freshman regarding their aspirations in your society.

Help them correct their technique at the gym.

Strike up a conversation when you spot them at the Khokha.

Sit with them at PDC if they don’t mind company.

Ask them why they have trouble speaking up in class (assuming you are the TA).

 

This obviously doesn’t solve the deeper problem. In the meanwhile, this should not deplete your will to look towards a better future. You would be surprised how often the little things go a long way in making someone feel home.